Enormous filtering run oddity - Page 2

jasonp · 2009-01-04, 15:40

Jeez, you have so many excess relations that you ran out of cliques with size < 8, and still had too much excess (only by a little though). You can force the merge phase to run by changing the 'exit(-1);' call on line 654 of gnfs/filter/clique.c to 'break;'. But the target excess is ~14.8M, about 1M smaller than with 2 clique passes, so I don't expect the final matrix to be of size < 22.5M if you got 25.6M before.

It looks like one should not give up if there are no cliques left, but instead should start deleting relations. Presumably they should get deleted in order of decreasing weight, but if there's too much excess now then you shouldn't have to worry much about preserving sparsity. As a quick fix, you can change the following at line 133 of gnfs/filter.c:

Code:

	filtmin_r = filtmin_a = nfs_purge_duplicates(obj, &fb, 0);
	if (obj->nfs_lower)
		filtmin_r = obj->nfs_lower;
	if (obj->nfs_upper)
		filtmin_a = obj->nfs_upper;

into

Code:

	filtmin_r = filtmin_a = nfs_purge_duplicates(obj, &fb, obj->nfs_upper);

and then run the filtering using '-nc1 0,X' where X is the number of relations you want to keep. This saves having to manually generate hard-drive-size data files over and over again. Sucks that filtering runs will still take a week though; if you want to save lots of time, we can modify the code to output temporary files after clique processing, and start from those files as long as X only increases. That should save having to run most of the clique processing every time.

Is the 22.5M matrix running now, or are you waiting to get a better matrix? I realize it's painful to ask that you do stuff like this.

frmky · 2009-01-04, 18:55

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonp

Is the 22.5M matrix running now, or are you waiting to get a better matrix? I realize it's painful to ask that you do stuff like this.

I'll make the changes and try again. No, the matrix is not running yet. I was holding off on the linear algebra on this one to perhaps try Patrick Stach's GPU linear algebra implementation, but he hasn't gotten it to me yet anyway.

It's interesting that after a point, additional relations increased the matrix size. I'll try with the number of relations reduced to halfway between Bruce's run and what we have now.

frmky · 2009-01-11, 23:34

A little better, at about 24.3M^2 once the matrix is created. I'll run it one last time with the number of relations Bruce used to see if we can get the 22.5M^2 matrix again.

Code:

Sun Jan  4 19:11:15 2009  Msieve v. 1.38
Sun Jan  4 19:11:15 2009  random seeds: 0b229a0a 48f16efd
Sun Jan  4 19:11:15 2009  factoring 1523730872006476065948363676129458676149278444031460349472566973967334168144122839831601974268424799167249117433966350288390769855219490595979807225811317497929238722439950754301281289518517474506321086318238010563399750224881258591495613213552981037427691447296080033 (268 digits)
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  commencing number field sieve (268-digit input)
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  R0: -2854495385411919762116571938898990272765493248
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  R1:  1
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A0:  1
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A1:  0
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A2:  0
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A3:  0
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A4:  0
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A5:  0
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  A6:  4
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  size score = 3.818099e-13, Murphy alpha = 1.946683, combined = 2.189247e-13
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  commencing relation filtering
Sun Jan  4 19:11:20 2009  commencing duplicate removal, pass 1
Sun Jan  4 20:51:42 2009  found 47773505 hash collisions in 486972508 relations
Sun Jan  4 20:52:33 2009  added 1218925 free relations
Sun Jan  4 20:52:33 2009  commencing duplicate removal, pass 2
Sun Jan  4 21:24:23 2009  found 29787 duplicates and 560832998 unique relations
Sun Jan  4 21:24:23 2009  memory use: 2139.0 MB
Sun Jan  4 21:24:24 2009  reading rational ideals above 235995136
Sun Jan  4 21:24:24 2009  reading algebraic ideals above 235995136
Sun Jan  4 21:24:24 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 1
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 7107617
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 38859193
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 120914521
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 190150022
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 152676183
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 50848867
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 276595
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  560832998 relations and about 124543269 large ideals
Sun Jan  4 23:23:04 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 2
Mon Jan  5 01:20:23 2009  found 5097659 singletons
Mon Jan  5 01:20:23 2009  current dataset: 555735339 relations and about 119427908 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 01:20:27 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 3
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 7107617
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 38756612
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 120226812
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 188463000
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 150829561
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 50075142
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 276595
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  555735339 relations and about 193918986 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 03:19:53 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 4
Mon Jan  5 05:17:45 2009  found 18208576 singletons
Mon Jan  5 05:17:45 2009  current dataset: 537526763 relations and about 175480669 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 05:17:46 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 5
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 7107617
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 38381197
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 117741475
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 182412408
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 144265031
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 47342440
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 276595
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  537526763 relations and about 243280583 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 07:14:11 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 6
Mon Jan  5 09:10:16 2009  found 27356205 singletons
Mon Jan  5 09:10:16 2009  current dataset: 510170558 relations and about 215382061 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 09:10:16 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 7
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 7107617
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 37796402
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 113921385
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 173252112
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 134485706
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 43330741
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 276595
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  510170558 relations and about 257749939 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 11:02:13 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 8
Mon Jan  5 12:55:05 2009  found 20077217 singletons
Mon Jan  5 12:55:05 2009  current dataset: 490093341 relations and about 237366033 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 12:55:05 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 9
Mon Jan  5 14:43:03 2009  found 1948044 singletons
Mon Jan  5 14:43:03 2009  current dataset: 488145297 relations and about 235414562 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 14:43:03 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 10
Mon Jan  5 16:30:02 2009  found 145664 singletons
Mon Jan  5 16:30:02 2009  current dataset: 487999633 relations and about 235268876 large ideals
Mon Jan  5 16:30:03 2009  commencing singleton removal, final pass
Mon Jan  5 18:39:50 2009  memory use: 9312.6 MB
Mon Jan  5 18:39:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan  5 18:43:30 2009  begin with 487999394 relations and 269440074 unique ideals
Mon Jan  5 19:17:19 2009  reduce to 479733295 relations and 261132914 ideals in 8 passes
Mon Jan  5 19:17:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 47
Mon Jan  5 19:21:24 2009  reading rational ideals above 720000
Mon Jan  5 19:21:24 2009  reading algebraic ideals above 720000
Mon Jan  5 19:21:25 2009  commencing singleton removal, final pass
Mon Jan  5 23:26:45 2009  keeping 272050871 ideals with weight <= 30, new excess is 14987161
Mon Jan  5 23:52:08 2009  memory use: 13600.6 MB
Mon Jan  5 23:52:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan  5 23:56:23 2009  begin with 479733295 relations and 272050871 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 00:06:06 2009  reduce to 479733294 relations and 272050870 ideals in 2 passes
Tue Jan  6 00:06:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 00:22:36 2009  removing 2365567 relations and 1965567 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 00:22:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 00:26:59 2009  begin with 477367727 relations and 272050870 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 00:51:11 2009  reduce to 477363324 relations and 270080892 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan  6 00:51:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 01:07:32 2009  removing 1915717 relations and 1515717 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 01:07:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 01:11:52 2009  begin with 475447607 relations and 270080892 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 01:31:03 2009  reduce to 475444630 relations and 268562191 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 01:31:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 01:47:16 2009  removing 1755931 relations and 1355931 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 01:47:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 01:51:34 2009  begin with 473688699 relations and 268562191 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 02:10:39 2009  reduce to 473686080 relations and 267203641 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 02:10:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 02:26:47 2009  removing 1654274 relations and 1254274 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 02:27:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 02:31:04 2009  begin with 472031806 relations and 267203641 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 02:50:03 2009  reduce to 472029084 relations and 265946644 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 02:50:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 03:06:07 2009  removing 1575809 relations and 1175809 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 03:06:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 03:10:23 2009  begin with 470453275 relations and 265946644 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 03:29:18 2009  reduce to 470450906 relations and 264768459 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 03:29:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 03:45:16 2009  removing 1528946 relations and 1128946 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 03:45:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 03:49:30 2009  begin with 468921960 relations and 264768459 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 04:08:20 2009  reduce to 468919795 relations and 263637345 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 04:08:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 04:24:14 2009  removing 1509936 relations and 1109936 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 04:24:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 04:28:27 2009  begin with 467409859 relations and 263637345 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 04:47:12 2009  reduce to 467407927 relations and 262525476 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 04:47:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 05:03:02 2009  removing 1452193 relations and 1052193 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 05:03:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 05:07:15 2009  begin with 465955734 relations and 262525476 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 05:25:59 2009  reduce to 465953289 relations and 261470838 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 05:25:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 05:41:47 2009  removing 1429136 relations and 1029136 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 05:42:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 05:45:59 2009  begin with 464524153 relations and 261470838 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 06:04:40 2009  reduce to 464522773 relations and 260440320 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 06:04:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 06:20:23 2009  removing 1392802 relations and 992802 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 06:20:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 06:24:34 2009  begin with 463129971 relations and 260440320 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 06:43:09 2009  reduce to 463128387 relations and 259445930 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 06:43:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 06:58:46 2009  removing 1343887 relations and 943887 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 06:59:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 07:02:55 2009  begin with 461784500 relations and 259445930 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 07:21:22 2009  reduce to 461782409 relations and 258499950 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 07:21:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 07:36:54 2009  removing 1350099 relations and 950099 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 07:37:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 07:41:02 2009  begin with 460432310 relations and 258499950 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 07:59:24 2009  reduce to 460430410 relations and 257547948 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 07:59:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 08:14:52 2009  removing 1319264 relations and 919264 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 08:15:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 08:18:59 2009  begin with 459111146 relations and 257547948 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 08:37:18 2009  reduce to 459109088 relations and 256626624 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 08:37:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 08:52:43 2009  removing 1300472 relations and 900472 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 08:53:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 08:56:49 2009  begin with 457808616 relations and 256626624 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 09:15:04 2009  reduce to 457806273 relations and 255723804 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 09:15:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 09:30:24 2009  removing 1275696 relations and 875696 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 09:30:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 09:34:30 2009  begin with 456530577 relations and 255723804 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 09:52:41 2009  reduce to 456528098 relations and 254845626 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 09:52:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 10:07:58 2009  removing 1234594 relations and 834594 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 10:08:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 10:12:02 2009  begin with 455293504 relations and 254845626 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 10:30:08 2009  reduce to 455291172 relations and 254008699 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 10:30:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 10:45:22 2009  removing 1232347 relations and 832347 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 10:45:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 10:49:26 2009  begin with 454058825 relations and 254008699 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 11:07:31 2009  reduce to 454057135 relations and 253174659 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 11:07:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 11:22:42 2009  removing 1216887 relations and 816887 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 11:23:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 11:26:44 2009  begin with 452840248 relations and 253174659 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 11:44:43 2009  reduce to 452838564 relations and 252356084 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 11:44:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 11:59:50 2009  removing 1208769 relations and 808769 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 12:00:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 12:03:52 2009  begin with 451629795 relations and 252356084 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 12:21:50 2009  reduce to 451628027 relations and 251545545 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 12:21:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 12:36:53 2009  removing 1205880 relations and 805880 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 12:37:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 12:40:55 2009  begin with 450422147 relations and 251545545 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 12:58:47 2009  reduce to 450420387 relations and 250737903 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 12:58:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 13:13:49 2009  removing 1178012 relations and 778012 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 13:14:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 13:17:49 2009  begin with 449242375 relations and 250737903 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 13:35:38 2009  reduce to 449240381 relations and 249957896 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 13:35:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 13:50:36 2009  removing 1194035 relations and 794035 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 13:50:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 13:54:36 2009  begin with 448046346 relations and 249957896 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 14:12:19 2009  reduce to 448044654 relations and 249162166 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 14:12:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 14:27:13 2009  removing 1202034 relations and 802034 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 14:27:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 14:31:12 2009  begin with 446842620 relations and 249162166 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 14:48:53 2009  reduce to 446841191 relations and 248358701 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 14:48:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 15:03:43 2009  removing 1190055 relations and 790055 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 15:04:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 15:07:41 2009  begin with 445651136 relations and 248358701 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 15:25:20 2009  reduce to 445649716 relations and 247567224 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 15:25:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 15:40:09 2009  removing 1160828 relations and 760828 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 15:40:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 15:44:06 2009  begin with 444488888 relations and 247567224 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 16:01:41 2009  reduce to 444487096 relations and 246804601 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 16:01:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 16:16:25 2009  removing 1194625 relations and 794625 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 16:16:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 16:20:21 2009  begin with 443292471 relations and 246804601 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 16:37:52 2009  reduce to 443291048 relations and 246008552 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 16:37:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 16:52:33 2009  removing 1155797 relations and 755797 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 16:52:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 16:56:29 2009  begin with 442135251 relations and 246008552 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 17:13:57 2009  reduce to 442133482 relations and 245250983 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 17:13:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 17:28:35 2009  removing 1183984 relations and 783984 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 17:28:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 17:32:30 2009  begin with 440949498 relations and 245250983 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 17:45:32 2009  reduce to 440947937 relations and 244465437 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 17:45:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 18:00:06 2009  removing 1155645 relations and 755645 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 18:00:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 18:04:00 2009  begin with 439792292 relations and 244465437 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 18:17:01 2009  reduce to 439790466 relations and 243707960 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 18:17:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 18:31:32 2009  removing 1148909 relations and 748909 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 18:31:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 18:35:25 2009  begin with 438641557 relations and 243707960 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 18:48:23 2009  reduce to 438639558 relations and 242957039 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 18:48:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 19:02:51 2009  removing 1138069 relations and 738069 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 19:03:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 19:06:43 2009  begin with 437501489 relations and 242957039 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 19:23:57 2009  reduce to 437499275 relations and 242216754 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan  6 19:23:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 19:38:21 2009  removing 1108041 relations and 708041 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 19:38:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 19:42:12 2009  begin with 436391234 relations and 242216754 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 19:55:05 2009  reduce to 436388610 relations and 241506084 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 19:55:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 20:09:26 2009  removing 1090274 relations and 690274 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 20:09:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 20:13:16 2009  begin with 435298336 relations and 241506084 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 20:26:06 2009  reduce to 435295794 relations and 240813262 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 20:26:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 20:40:25 2009  removing 1163867 relations and 763867 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 20:40:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 20:44:14 2009  begin with 434131927 relations and 240813262 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 20:57:01 2009  reduce to 434130882 relations and 240048344 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 20:57:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 21:11:16 2009  removing 1127616 relations and 727616 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 21:11:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 21:15:05 2009  begin with 433003266 relations and 240048344 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 21:27:51 2009  reduce to 433002135 relations and 239319593 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 21:27:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 21:42:03 2009  removing 1064528 relations and 664528 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 21:42:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 21:45:51 2009  begin with 431937607 relations and 239319593 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 21:58:32 2009  reduce to 431935962 relations and 238653414 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 21:58:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 22:12:40 2009  removing 1130819 relations and 730819 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 22:12:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 22:16:27 2009  begin with 430805143 relations and 238653414 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 22:29:05 2009  reduce to 430804014 relations and 237921460 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 22:29:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 22:43:10 2009  removing 1094175 relations and 694175 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 22:43:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 22:46:57 2009  begin with 429709839 relations and 237921460 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 22:59:32 2009  reduce to 429708647 relations and 237226089 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 22:59:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 23:13:34 2009  removing 1087905 relations and 687905 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 23:13:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 23:17:20 2009  begin with 428620742 relations and 237226089 unique ideals
Tue Jan  6 23:29:54 2009  reduce to 428619534 relations and 236536972 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan  6 23:29:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Tue Jan  6 23:43:51 2009  removing 1066511 relations and 666511 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan  6 23:44:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan  6 23:47:35 2009  begin with 427553023 relations and 236536972 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 00:00:06 2009  reduce to 427551598 relations and 235869035 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 00:00:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 00:14:00 2009  removing 1089258 relations and 689258 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 00:14:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 00:17:45 2009  begin with 426462340 relations and 235869035 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 00:30:14 2009  reduce to 426461116 relations and 235178551 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 00:30:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 00:44:06 2009  removing 1054247 relations and 654247 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 00:44:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 00:47:50 2009  begin with 425406869 relations and 235178551 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 01:00:17 2009  reduce to 425405378 relations and 234522811 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 01:00:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 01:14:07 2009  removing 1034189 relations and 634189 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 01:14:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 01:17:50 2009  begin with 424371189 relations and 234522811 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 01:30:14 2009  reduce to 424369378 relations and 233886807 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 01:30:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 01:44:00 2009  removing 1022779 relations and 622779 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 01:44:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 01:47:43 2009  begin with 423346599 relations and 233886807 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 02:00:06 2009  reduce to 423344629 relations and 233262053 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 02:00:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 02:13:51 2009  removing 985589 relations and 585589 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 02:14:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 02:17:32 2009  begin with 422359040 relations and 233262053 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 02:34:00 2009  reduce to 422356376 relations and 232673795 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 02:34:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 02:47:43 2009  removing 1107432 relations and 707432 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 02:48:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 02:51:24 2009  begin with 421248944 relations and 232673795 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 03:03:42 2009  reduce to 421247826 relations and 231965238 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 03:03:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 03:17:20 2009  removing 1067411 relations and 667411 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 03:17:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 03:21:00 2009  begin with 420180415 relations and 231965238 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 03:33:15 2009  reduce to 420179432 relations and 231296841 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 03:33:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 03:46:49 2009  removing 1086345 relations and 686345 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 03:47:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 03:50:29 2009  begin with 419093087 relations and 231296841 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 04:02:42 2009  reduce to 419092237 relations and 230609646 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 04:02:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 04:16:14 2009  removing 1052780 relations and 652780 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 04:16:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 04:19:54 2009  begin with 418039457 relations and 230609646 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 04:32:06 2009  reduce to 418038364 relations and 229955771 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 04:32:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 04:45:35 2009  removing 1046034 relations and 646034 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 04:45:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 04:49:13 2009  begin with 416992330 relations and 229955771 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 05:01:22 2009  reduce to 416991107 relations and 229308512 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 05:01:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 05:14:48 2009  removing 1029112 relations and 629112 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 05:15:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 05:18:25 2009  begin with 415961995 relations and 229308512 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 05:30:30 2009  reduce to 415960433 relations and 228677837 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 05:30:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 05:43:52 2009  removing 999533 relations and 599533 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 05:44:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 05:47:28 2009  begin with 414960900 relations and 228677837 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 05:59:32 2009  reduce to 414958971 relations and 228076371 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 05:59:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 06:12:53 2009  removing 983589 relations and 583589 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 06:13:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 06:16:29 2009  begin with 413975382 relations and 228076371 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 06:28:31 2009  reduce to 413973252 relations and 227490647 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 06:28:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 06:41:49 2009  removing 1086915 relations and 686915 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 06:42:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 06:45:24 2009  begin with 412886337 relations and 227490647 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 06:57:21 2009  reduce to 412885069 relations and 226802463 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 06:57:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 07:10:35 2009  removing 1046424 relations and 646424 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 07:10:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 07:14:09 2009  begin with 411838645 relations and 226802463 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 07:26:06 2009  reduce to 411837306 relations and 226154694 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 07:26:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 07:39:17 2009  removing 1024290 relations and 624290 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 07:39:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 07:42:50 2009  begin with 410813016 relations and 226154694 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 07:54:44 2009  reduce to 410811317 relations and 225528702 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 07:54:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 08:07:54 2009  removing 1015928 relations and 615928 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 08:08:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 08:11:27 2009  begin with 409795389 relations and 225528702 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 08:27:16 2009  reduce to 409793492 relations and 224910873 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 08:27:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 08:40:23 2009  removing 974741 relations and 574741 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 08:40:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 08:43:55 2009  begin with 408818751 relations and 224910873 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 08:55:45 2009  reduce to 408816422 relations and 224333790 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 08:55:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 09:08:49 2009  removing 1053204 relations and 653204 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 09:09:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 09:12:21 2009  begin with 407763218 relations and 224333790 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 09:24:10 2009  reduce to 407761443 relations and 223678801 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 09:24:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 09:37:12 2009  removing 1023277 relations and 623277 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 09:37:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 09:40:42 2009  begin with 406738166 relations and 223678801 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 09:52:28 2009  reduce to 406736218 relations and 223053567 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 09:52:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 10:05:27 2009  removing 1006409 relations and 606409 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 10:05:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 10:08:57 2009  begin with 405729809 relations and 223053567 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 10:20:41 2009  reduce to 405727651 relations and 222444992 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 10:20:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 10:33:37 2009  removing 970069 relations and 570069 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 10:33:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 10:37:06 2009  begin with 404757582 relations and 222444992 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 10:48:48 2009  reduce to 404754882 relations and 221872217 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 10:48:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 11:01:42 2009  removing 1031152 relations and 631152 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 11:01:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 11:05:11 2009  begin with 403723730 relations and 221872217 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 11:16:49 2009  reduce to 403721470 relations and 221238793 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 11:16:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 11:29:39 2009  removing 1004699 relations and 604699 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 11:29:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 11:33:07 2009  begin with 402716771 relations and 221238793 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 11:44:44 2009  reduce to 402714515 relations and 220631825 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 11:44:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 11:57:32 2009  removing 975536 relations and 575536 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 11:57:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 12:01:00 2009  begin with 401738979 relations and 220631825 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 12:12:38 2009  reduce to 401736200 relations and 220053496 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 12:12:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 12:25:26 2009  removing 994535 relations and 594535 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 12:25:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 12:28:54 2009  begin with 400741665 relations and 220053496 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 12:40:28 2009  reduce to 400738889 relations and 219456164 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 12:40:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 12:53:13 2009  removing 994678 relations and 594678 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 12:53:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 12:56:39 2009  begin with 399744211 relations and 219456164 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 13:08:09 2009  reduce to 399741383 relations and 218858628 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 13:08:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 13:20:50 2009  removing 962229 relations and 562229 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 13:21:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 13:24:15 2009  begin with 398779154 relations and 218858628 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 13:35:42 2009  reduce to 398776131 relations and 218293354 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 13:35:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 13:48:20 2009  removing 988983 relations and 588983 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 13:48:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 13:51:44 2009  begin with 397787148 relations and 218293354 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 14:06:57 2009  reduce to 397783840 relations and 217701030 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 14:06:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 14:19:33 2009  removing 959407 relations and 559407 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 14:19:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 14:22:56 2009  begin with 396824433 relations and 217701030 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 14:34:18 2009  reduce to 396820909 relations and 217138069 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 14:34:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 14:46:52 2009  removing 966963 relations and 566963 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 14:47:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 14:50:15 2009  begin with 395853946 relations and 217138069 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 15:05:23 2009  reduce to 395850177 relations and 216567307 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 15:05:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 15:17:56 2009  removing 956450 relations and 556450 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 15:18:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 15:21:18 2009  begin with 394893727 relations and 216567307 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 15:32:37 2009  reduce to 394889859 relations and 216006956 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 15:32:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 15:45:07 2009  removing 950171 relations and 550171 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 15:45:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 15:48:28 2009  begin with 393939688 relations and 216006956 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 16:03:30 2009  reduce to 393935434 relations and 215452477 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 16:03:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 16:15:59 2009  removing 941598 relations and 541598 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 16:16:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 16:19:21 2009  begin with 392993836 relations and 215452477 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 16:30:38 2009  reduce to 392989490 relations and 214906492 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 16:30:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 16:43:05 2009  removing 933024 relations and 533024 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 16:43:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 16:46:25 2009  begin with 392056466 relations and 214906492 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 16:57:38 2009  reduce to 392052282 relations and 214369231 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 16:57:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 17:10:02 2009  removing 914064 relations and 514064 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 17:10:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 17:13:22 2009  begin with 391138218 relations and 214369231 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 17:24:33 2009  reduce to 391133820 relations and 213850706 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 17:24:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 17:36:55 2009  removing 906620 relations and 506620 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 17:37:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 17:40:14 2009  begin with 390227200 relations and 213850706 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 17:51:23 2009  reduce to 390222429 relations and 213339240 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 17:51:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 18:03:43 2009  removing 906850 relations and 506850 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 18:03:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 18:07:01 2009  begin with 389315579 relations and 213339240 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 18:18:10 2009  reduce to 389310813 relations and 212827544 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 18:18:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 18:30:28 2009  removing 906287 relations and 506287 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 18:30:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 18:33:46 2009  begin with 388404526 relations and 212827544 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 18:44:50 2009  reduce to 388399618 relations and 212316275 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 18:44:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 18:57:04 2009  removing 904581 relations and 504581 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 18:57:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 19:00:22 2009  begin with 387495037 relations and 212316275 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 19:11:26 2009  reduce to 387490257 relations and 211806843 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 19:11:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 19:23:39 2009  removing 904262 relations and 504262 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 19:23:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 19:26:56 2009  begin with 386585995 relations and 211806843 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 19:37:56 2009  reduce to 386581380 relations and 211297901 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 19:37:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 19:50:06 2009  removing 902443 relations and 502443 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 19:50:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 19:53:22 2009  begin with 385678937 relations and 211297901 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 20:04:20 2009  reduce to 385674210 relations and 210790648 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 20:04:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 20:16:26 2009  removing 901433 relations and 501433 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 20:16:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 20:19:42 2009  begin with 384772777 relations and 210790648 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 20:34:16 2009  reduce to 384767996 relations and 210284375 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 20:34:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 20:46:22 2009  removing 901786 relations and 501786 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 20:46:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 20:49:37 2009  begin with 383866210 relations and 210284375 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 21:04:08 2009  reduce to 383861584 relations and 209777906 ideals in 4 passes
Wed Jan  7 21:04:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 21:16:11 2009  removing 900111 relations and 500111 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 21:16:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 21:19:26 2009  begin with 382961473 relations and 209777906 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 21:30:19 2009  reduce to 382956948 relations and 209273199 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 21:30:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 21:42:23 2009  removing 899541 relations and 499541 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 21:42:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 21:45:38 2009  begin with 382057407 relations and 209273199 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 21:56:33 2009  reduce to 382052742 relations and 208768941 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 21:56:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 22:08:37 2009  removing 898497 relations and 498497 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 22:08:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 22:11:49 2009  begin with 381154245 relations and 208768941 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 22:22:36 2009  reduce to 381149764 relations and 208265885 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 22:22:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 22:34:32 2009  removing 896743 relations and 496743 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 22:34:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 22:37:45 2009  begin with 380253021 relations and 208265885 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 22:48:31 2009  reduce to 380248626 relations and 207764691 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 22:48:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 23:00:26 2009  removing 896959 relations and 496959 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 23:00:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 23:03:38 2009  begin with 379351667 relations and 207764691 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 23:14:26 2009  reduce to 379347255 relations and 207263252 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 23:14:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 23:26:21 2009  removing 895605 relations and 495605 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 23:26:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 23:29:33 2009  begin with 378451650 relations and 207263252 unique ideals
Wed Jan  7 23:40:16 2009  reduce to 378447227 relations and 206763160 ideals in 3 passes
Wed Jan  7 23:40:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Wed Jan  7 23:52:08 2009  removing 895281 relations and 495281 ideals in 400000 cliques
Wed Jan  7 23:52:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan  7 23:55:20 2009  begin with 377551946 relations and 206763160 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 00:06:06 2009  reduce to 377547572 relations and 206263439 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 00:06:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 00:17:56 2009  removing 894758 relations and 494758 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 00:18:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 00:21:06 2009  begin with 376652814 relations and 206263439 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 00:31:47 2009  reduce to 376648379 relations and 205764182 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 00:31:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 00:43:35 2009  removing 893247 relations and 493247 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 00:43:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 00:46:45 2009  begin with 375755132 relations and 205764182 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 00:57:24 2009  reduce to 375750757 relations and 205266503 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 00:57:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 01:09:10 2009  removing 892665 relations and 492665 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 01:09:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 01:12:19 2009  begin with 374858092 relations and 205266503 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 01:22:56 2009  reduce to 374853949 relations and 204769616 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 01:22:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 01:34:40 2009  removing 891194 relations and 491194 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 01:34:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 01:37:49 2009  begin with 373962755 relations and 204769616 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 01:48:23 2009  reduce to 373958459 relations and 204274055 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 01:48:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 02:00:05 2009  removing 891305 relations and 491305 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 02:00:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 02:03:14 2009  begin with 373067154 relations and 204274055 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 02:13:49 2009  reduce to 373062880 relations and 203778423 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 02:13:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 02:25:29 2009  removing 890365 relations and 490365 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 02:25:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 02:28:37 2009  begin with 372172515 relations and 203778423 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 02:39:09 2009  reduce to 372168225 relations and 203283723 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 02:39:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 02:50:46 2009  removing 889543 relations and 489543 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 02:51:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 02:53:53 2009  begin with 371278682 relations and 203283723 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 03:04:21 2009  reduce to 371274557 relations and 202789984 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 03:04:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 03:15:55 2009  removing 888356 relations and 488356 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 03:16:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 03:19:01 2009  begin with 370386201 relations and 202789984 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 03:29:28 2009  reduce to 370382024 relations and 202297392 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 03:29:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 03:41:01 2009  removing 887591 relations and 487591 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 03:41:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 03:44:07 2009  begin with 369494433 relations and 202297392 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 03:54:31 2009  reduce to 369490219 relations and 201805515 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 03:54:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 04:06:01 2009  removing 887354 relations and 487354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 04:06:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 04:09:06 2009  begin with 368602865 relations and 201805515 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 04:19:28 2009  reduce to 368598750 relations and 201313989 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 04:19:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 04:30:57 2009  removing 886324 relations and 486324 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 04:31:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 04:34:01 2009  begin with 367712426 relations and 201313989 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 04:44:21 2009  reduce to 367708283 relations and 200823471 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 04:44:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 04:55:48 2009  removing 884987 relations and 484987 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 04:56:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 04:58:52 2009  begin with 366823296 relations and 200823471 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 05:09:10 2009  reduce to 366819224 relations and 200334371 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 05:09:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 05:20:35 2009  removing 884564 relations and 484564 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 05:20:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 05:23:38 2009  begin with 365934660 relations and 200334371 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 05:33:54 2009  reduce to 365930713 relations and 199845806 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 05:33:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 05:45:15 2009  removing 883358 relations and 483358 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 05:45:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 05:48:18 2009  begin with 365047355 relations and 199845806 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 05:58:33 2009  reduce to 365043365 relations and 199358406 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 05:58:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 06:09:54 2009  removing 883069 relations and 483069 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 06:10:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 06:12:56 2009  begin with 364160296 relations and 199358406 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 06:23:10 2009  reduce to 364156416 relations and 198871405 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 06:23:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 06:34:29 2009  removing 881869 relations and 481869 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 06:34:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 06:37:30 2009  begin with 363274547 relations and 198871405 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 06:47:40 2009  reduce to 363270597 relations and 198385535 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 06:47:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 06:58:56 2009  removing 881309 relations and 481309 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 06:59:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 07:01:57 2009  begin with 362389288 relations and 198385535 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 07:12:08 2009  reduce to 362385281 relations and 197900157 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 07:12:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 07:23:21 2009  removing 880965 relations and 480965 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 07:23:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 07:26:22 2009  begin with 361504316 relations and 197900157 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 07:36:29 2009  reduce to 361500480 relations and 197415292 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 07:36:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 07:47:41 2009  removing 879453 relations and 479453 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 07:47:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 07:50:41 2009  begin with 360621027 relations and 197415292 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 08:04:08 2009  reduce to 360617246 relations and 196932008 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 08:04:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 08:15:18 2009  removing 878330 relations and 478330 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 08:15:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 08:18:17 2009  begin with 359738916 relations and 196932008 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 08:28:19 2009  reduce to 359735255 relations and 196449977 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 08:28:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 08:39:26 2009  removing 877256 relations and 477256 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 08:39:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 08:42:25 2009  begin with 358857999 relations and 196449977 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 08:52:27 2009  reduce to 358855133 relations and 195969822 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 08:52:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 09:03:32 2009  removing 876804 relations and 476804 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 09:03:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 09:06:31 2009  begin with 357978329 relations and 195969822 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 09:16:32 2009  reduce to 357975343 relations and 195489986 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 09:16:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 09:27:38 2009  removing 875693 relations and 475693 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 09:27:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 09:30:36 2009  begin with 357099650 relations and 195489986 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 09:40:34 2009  reduce to 357096386 relations and 195010994 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 09:40:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 09:51:35 2009  removing 874985 relations and 474985 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 09:51:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 09:54:33 2009  begin with 356221401 relations and 195010994 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 10:04:29 2009  reduce to 356218123 relations and 194532682 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 10:04:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 10:15:31 2009  removing 873823 relations and 473823 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 10:15:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 10:18:28 2009  begin with 355344300 relations and 194532682 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 10:31:43 2009  reduce to 355341092 relations and 194055599 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 10:31:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 10:42:41 2009  removing 872409 relations and 472409 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 10:42:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 10:45:37 2009  begin with 354468683 relations and 194055599 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 10:55:27 2009  reduce to 354465217 relations and 193579676 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 10:55:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 11:06:21 2009  removing 872401 relations and 472401 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 11:06:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 11:09:17 2009  begin with 353592816 relations and 193579676 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 11:19:06 2009  reduce to 353589362 relations and 193103774 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 11:19:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 11:29:59 2009  removing 871874 relations and 471874 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 11:30:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 11:32:53 2009  begin with 352717488 relations and 193103774 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 11:42:40 2009  reduce to 352714068 relations and 192628420 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 11:42:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 11:53:30 2009  removing 871088 relations and 471088 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 11:53:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 11:56:24 2009  begin with 351842980 relations and 192628420 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 12:06:08 2009  reduce to 351839547 relations and 192153847 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 12:06:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 12:16:55 2009  removing 869845 relations and 469845 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 12:17:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 12:19:48 2009  begin with 350969702 relations and 192153847 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 12:29:39 2009  reduce to 350966180 relations and 191680426 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 12:29:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 12:41:04 2009  removing 868699 relations and 468699 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 12:41:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 12:43:57 2009  begin with 350097481 relations and 191680426 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 12:53:46 2009  reduce to 350093805 relations and 191207998 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 12:53:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 13:04:34 2009  removing 867714 relations and 467714 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 13:04:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 13:07:27 2009  begin with 349226091 relations and 191207998 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 13:20:18 2009  reduce to 349222257 relations and 190736391 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 13:20:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 13:31:04 2009  removing 868101 relations and 468101 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 13:31:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 13:33:56 2009  begin with 348354156 relations and 190736391 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 13:43:34 2009  reduce to 348350381 relations and 190264454 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 13:43:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 13:54:17 2009  removing 867175 relations and 467175 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 13:54:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 13:57:09 2009  begin with 347483206 relations and 190264454 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 14:06:47 2009  reduce to 347479492 relations and 189793515 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 14:06:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 14:17:29 2009  removing 866103 relations and 466103 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 14:17:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 14:20:20 2009  begin with 346613389 relations and 189793515 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 14:29:56 2009  reduce to 346609550 relations and 189323512 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 14:29:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 14:40:35 2009  removing 864856 relations and 464856 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 14:40:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 14:43:26 2009  begin with 345744694 relations and 189323512 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 14:52:59 2009  reduce to 345740664 relations and 188854564 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 14:52:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 15:03:38 2009  removing 864337 relations and 464337 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 15:03:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 15:06:28 2009  begin with 344876327 relations and 188854564 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 15:15:59 2009  reduce to 344872182 relations and 188385997 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 15:15:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 15:26:37 2009  removing 863942 relations and 463942 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 15:26:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 15:29:25 2009  begin with 344008240 relations and 188385997 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 15:38:54 2009  reduce to 344004058 relations and 187917807 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 15:38:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 15:49:28 2009  removing 862763 relations and 462763 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 15:49:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 15:52:16 2009  begin with 343141295 relations and 187917807 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 16:01:44 2009  reduce to 343137132 relations and 187450804 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 16:01:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 16:12:16 2009  removing 860901 relations and 460901 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 16:12:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 16:15:04 2009  begin with 342276231 relations and 187450804 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 16:24:30 2009  reduce to 342271780 relations and 186985362 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 16:24:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 16:34:59 2009  removing 861556 relations and 461556 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 16:35:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 16:37:46 2009  begin with 341410224 relations and 186985362 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 16:47:08 2009  reduce to 341405857 relations and 186519322 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 16:47:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 16:57:36 2009  removing 860243 relations and 460243 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 16:57:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 17:00:23 2009  begin with 340545614 relations and 186519322 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 17:09:44 2009  reduce to 340541089 relations and 186054457 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 17:09:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 17:20:10 2009  removing 859820 relations and 459820 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 17:20:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 17:22:56 2009  begin with 339681269 relations and 186054457 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 17:32:15 2009  reduce to 339676751 relations and 185590015 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 17:32:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 17:42:37 2009  removing 858595 relations and 458595 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 17:42:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 17:45:29 2009  begin with 338818156 relations and 185590015 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 17:55:11 2009  reduce to 338813492 relations and 185126642 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 17:55:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 18:05:35 2009  removing 857874 relations and 457874 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 18:05:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 18:08:20 2009  begin with 337955618 relations and 185126642 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 18:17:37 2009  reduce to 337950913 relations and 184663950 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 18:17:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 18:27:52 2009  removing 857159 relations and 457159 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 18:28:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 18:30:36 2009  begin with 337093754 relations and 184663950 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 18:39:48 2009  reduce to 337088901 relations and 184201820 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 18:39:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 18:49:59 2009  removing 855787 relations and 455787 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 18:50:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 18:52:43 2009  begin with 336233114 relations and 184201820 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 19:01:53 2009  reduce to 336228195 relations and 183740987 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 19:01:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 19:12:02 2009  removing 855159 relations and 455159 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 19:12:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 19:14:46 2009  begin with 335373036 relations and 183740987 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 19:26:56 2009  reduce to 335367745 relations and 183280412 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 19:26:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 19:37:03 2009  removing 856344 relations and 456344 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 19:37:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 19:39:45 2009  begin with 334511401 relations and 183280412 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 19:48:52 2009  reduce to 334506604 relations and 182819159 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 19:48:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 19:58:59 2009  removing 856459 relations and 456459 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 19:59:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 20:01:41 2009  begin with 333650145 relations and 182819159 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 20:10:48 2009  reduce to 333645462 relations and 182357909 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 20:10:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 20:20:51 2009  removing 854953 relations and 454953 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 20:21:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 20:23:33 2009  begin with 332790509 relations and 182357909 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 20:32:35 2009  reduce to 332785505 relations and 181897846 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 20:32:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 20:42:37 2009  removing 854484 relations and 454484 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 20:42:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 20:45:18 2009  begin with 331931021 relations and 181897846 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 20:54:18 2009  reduce to 331926002 relations and 181438225 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 20:54:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 21:04:15 2009  removing 852980 relations and 452980 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 21:04:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 21:06:55 2009  begin with 331073022 relations and 181438225 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 21:15:54 2009  reduce to 331067819 relations and 180979921 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 21:15:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 21:25:50 2009  removing 851688 relations and 451688 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 21:26:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 21:28:29 2009  begin with 330216131 relations and 180979921 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 21:37:25 2009  reduce to 330210685 relations and 180522654 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 21:37:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 21:47:20 2009  removing 852511 relations and 452511 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 21:47:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 21:49:58 2009  begin with 329358174 relations and 180522654 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 21:58:53 2009  reduce to 329352991 relations and 180064846 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 21:58:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 22:08:45 2009  removing 851534 relations and 451534 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 22:08:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 22:11:23 2009  begin with 328501457 relations and 180064846 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 22:23:14 2009  reduce to 328496081 relations and 179607800 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 22:23:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 22:33:03 2009  removing 851066 relations and 451066 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 22:33:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 22:35:41 2009  begin with 327645015 relations and 179607800 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 22:47:28 2009  reduce to 327639538 relations and 179151106 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan  8 22:47:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 22:57:16 2009  removing 849898 relations and 449898 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 22:57:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 22:59:53 2009  begin with 326789640 relations and 179151106 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 23:08:44 2009  reduce to 326783934 relations and 178695338 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 23:08:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 23:18:30 2009  removing 848673 relations and 448673 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 23:18:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 23:21:06 2009  begin with 325935261 relations and 178695338 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 23:29:53 2009  reduce to 325929245 relations and 178240492 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 23:29:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Thu Jan  8 23:39:35 2009  removing 848688 relations and 448688 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan  8 23:39:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan  8 23:42:11 2009  begin with 325080557 relations and 178240492 unique ideals
Thu Jan  8 23:50:56 2009  reduce to 325074753 relations and 177785832 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan  8 23:50:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 00:00:38 2009  removing 848442 relations and 448442 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 00:00:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 00:03:13 2009  begin with 324226311 relations and 177785832 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 00:11:56 2009  reduce to 324220668 relations and 177331571 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 00:11:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 00:21:35 2009  removing 847389 relations and 447389 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 00:21:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 00:24:10 2009  begin with 323373279 relations and 177331571 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 00:32:51 2009  reduce to 323367141 relations and 176877888 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 00:32:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 00:42:29 2009  removing 846050 relations and 446050 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 00:42:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 00:45:03 2009  begin with 322521091 relations and 176877888 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 00:56:36 2009  reduce to 322514598 relations and 176425150 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 00:56:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 01:06:13 2009  removing 845612 relations and 445612 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 01:06:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 01:08:46 2009  begin with 321668986 relations and 176425150 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 01:17:23 2009  reduce to 321662813 relations and 175973183 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 01:17:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 01:26:57 2009  removing 845289 relations and 445289 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 01:27:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 01:29:30 2009  begin with 320817524 relations and 175973183 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 01:38:09 2009  reduce to 320811179 relations and 175521373 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 01:38:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 01:47:41 2009  removing 843977 relations and 443977 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 01:47:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 01:50:13 2009  begin with 319967202 relations and 175521373 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 01:58:47 2009  reduce to 319960720 relations and 175070728 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 01:58:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 02:08:18 2009  removing 843705 relations and 443705 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 02:08:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 02:10:50 2009  begin with 319117015 relations and 175070728 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 02:19:24 2009  reduce to 319110323 relations and 174620127 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 02:19:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 02:28:52 2009  removing 842792 relations and 442792 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 02:29:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 02:31:24 2009  begin with 318267531 relations and 174620127 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 02:39:57 2009  reduce to 318261007 relations and 174170612 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 02:39:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 02:49:24 2009  removing 842026 relations and 442026 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 02:49:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 02:51:55 2009  begin with 317418981 relations and 174170612 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 03:00:25 2009  reduce to 317412003 relations and 173721370 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 03:00:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 03:09:51 2009  removing 840787 relations and 440787 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 03:10:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 03:12:21 2009  begin with 316571216 relations and 173721370 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 03:20:49 2009  reduce to 316564239 relations and 173273379 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 03:20:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 03:30:11 2009  removing 839392 relations and 439392 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 03:30:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 03:32:41 2009  begin with 315724847 relations and 173273379 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 03:41:07 2009  reduce to 315717441 relations and 172826359 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 03:41:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 03:50:28 2009  removing 839884 relations and 439884 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 03:50:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 03:52:58 2009  begin with 314877557 relations and 172826359 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 04:01:23 2009  reduce to 314870309 relations and 172378992 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 04:01:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 04:10:42 2009  removing 840084 relations and 440084 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 04:10:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 04:13:11 2009  begin with 314030225 relations and 172378992 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 04:24:22 2009  reduce to 314023306 relations and 171931800 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 04:24:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 04:33:38 2009  removing 840042 relations and 440042 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 04:33:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 04:36:07 2009  begin with 313183264 relations and 171931800 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 04:44:28 2009  reduce to 313176342 relations and 171484600 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 04:44:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 04:53:44 2009  removing 839128 relations and 439128 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 04:53:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 04:56:12 2009  begin with 312337214 relations and 171484600 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 05:04:34 2009  reduce to 312330137 relations and 171038153 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 05:04:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 05:13:48 2009  removing 838152 relations and 438152 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 05:14:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 05:16:16 2009  begin with 311491985 relations and 171038153 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 05:24:33 2009  reduce to 311484649 relations and 170592437 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 05:24:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 05:33:45 2009  removing 836903 relations and 436903 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 05:33:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 05:36:12 2009  begin with 310647746 relations and 170592437 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 05:44:30 2009  reduce to 310640062 relations and 170147585 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 05:44:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 05:53:41 2009  removing 836462 relations and 436462 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 05:53:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 05:56:08 2009  begin with 309803600 relations and 170147585 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 06:04:24 2009  reduce to 309795942 relations and 169703229 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 06:04:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 06:13:34 2009  removing 836239 relations and 436239 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 06:13:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 06:16:00 2009  begin with 308959703 relations and 169703229 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 06:24:14 2009  reduce to 308952068 relations and 169259104 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 06:24:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 06:33:19 2009  removing 835269 relations and 435269 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 06:33:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 06:35:45 2009  begin with 308116799 relations and 169259104 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 06:46:41 2009  reduce to 308109082 relations and 168815841 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 06:46:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 06:55:45 2009  removing 834270 relations and 434270 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 06:55:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 06:58:10 2009  begin with 307274812 relations and 168815841 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 07:06:20 2009  reduce to 307266817 relations and 168373322 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 07:06:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 07:15:23 2009  removing 833119 relations and 433119 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 07:15:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 07:17:47 2009  begin with 306433698 relations and 168373322 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 07:25:55 2009  reduce to 306425316 relations and 167931514 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 07:25:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 07:34:56 2009  removing 833603 relations and 433603 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 07:35:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 07:37:19 2009  begin with 305591713 relations and 167931514 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 07:45:24 2009  reduce to 305583729 relations and 167489625 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 07:45:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 07:54:21 2009  removing 832268 relations and 432268 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 07:54:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 07:56:44 2009  begin with 304751461 relations and 167489625 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 08:04:48 2009  reduce to 304743302 relations and 167048872 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 08:04:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 08:13:43 2009  removing 831504 relations and 431504 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 08:13:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 08:16:05 2009  begin with 303911798 relations and 167048872 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 08:26:46 2009  reduce to 303903365 relations and 166608586 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 08:26:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 08:35:40 2009  removing 831345 relations and 431345 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 08:35:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 08:38:02 2009  begin with 303072020 relations and 166608586 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 08:46:03 2009  reduce to 303063565 relations and 166168479 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 08:46:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 08:54:55 2009  removing 830226 relations and 430226 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 08:55:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 08:57:16 2009  begin with 302233339 relations and 166168479 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 09:05:16 2009  reduce to 302224675 relations and 165729261 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 09:05:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 09:14:07 2009  removing 829625 relations and 429625 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 09:14:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 09:16:29 2009  begin with 301395050 relations and 165729261 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 09:27:05 2009  reduce to 301386137 relations and 165290391 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 09:27:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 09:35:55 2009  removing 828962 relations and 428962 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 09:36:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 09:38:15 2009  begin with 300557175 relations and 165290391 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 09:46:12 2009  reduce to 300548094 relations and 164851997 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 09:46:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 09:54:59 2009  removing 828033 relations and 428033 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 09:55:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 09:57:18 2009  begin with 299720061 relations and 164851997 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 10:05:12 2009  reduce to 299711014 relations and 164414553 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 10:05:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 10:13:57 2009  removing 827215 relations and 427215 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 10:14:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 10:16:16 2009  begin with 298883799 relations and 164414553 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 10:24:09 2009  reduce to 298874661 relations and 163977845 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 10:24:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 10:32:53 2009  removing 826040 relations and 426040 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 10:33:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 10:35:12 2009  begin with 298048621 relations and 163977845 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 10:43:04 2009  reduce to 298038610 relations and 163541386 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 10:43:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 10:51:47 2009  removing 826349 relations and 426349 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 10:51:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 10:54:05 2009  begin with 297212261 relations and 163541386 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 11:01:54 2009  reduce to 297203080 relations and 163105493 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 11:01:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 11:10:33 2009  removing 826354 relations and 426354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 11:10:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 11:12:51 2009  begin with 296376726 relations and 163105493 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 11:20:37 2009  reduce to 296367589 relations and 162669650 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 11:20:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 11:29:14 2009  removing 825471 relations and 425471 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 11:29:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 11:31:32 2009  begin with 295542118 relations and 162669650 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 11:39:17 2009  reduce to 295532834 relations and 162234455 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 11:39:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 11:47:51 2009  removing 824862 relations and 424862 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 11:48:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 11:50:08 2009  begin with 294707972 relations and 162234455 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 11:57:51 2009  reduce to 294698422 relations and 161799672 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 11:57:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 12:06:25 2009  removing 823693 relations and 423693 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 12:06:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 12:08:41 2009  begin with 293874729 relations and 161799672 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 12:16:23 2009  reduce to 293864817 relations and 161365651 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 12:16:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 12:24:55 2009  removing 823801 relations and 423801 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 12:25:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 12:27:11 2009  begin with 293041016 relations and 161365651 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 12:35:07 2009  reduce to 293031559 relations and 160931982 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 12:35:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 12:45:49 2009  removing 822981 relations and 422981 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 12:46:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 12:48:48 2009  begin with 292208578 relations and 160931982 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 12:58:56 2009  reduce to 292198871 relations and 160498881 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 12:58:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 13:09:58 2009  removing 821829 relations and 421829 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 13:10:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 13:12:57 2009  begin with 291377042 relations and 160498881 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 13:26:15 2009  reduce to 291366890 relations and 160066451 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 13:26:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 13:35:21 2009  removing 821122 relations and 421122 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 13:35:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 13:37:44 2009  begin with 290545768 relations and 160066451 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 13:45:49 2009  reduce to 290535681 relations and 159634809 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 13:45:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 13:54:47 2009  removing 820721 relations and 420721 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 13:54:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 13:57:06 2009  begin with 289714960 relations and 159634809 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 14:07:34 2009  reduce to 289704535 relations and 159203208 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan  9 14:07:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 14:16:19 2009  removing 819964 relations and 419964 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 14:16:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 14:18:36 2009  begin with 288884571 relations and 159203208 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 14:26:19 2009  reduce to 288874058 relations and 158772283 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 14:26:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 14:34:57 2009  removing 819001 relations and 419001 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 14:35:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 14:37:13 2009  begin with 288055057 relations and 158772283 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 14:44:56 2009  reduce to 288044467 relations and 158342221 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 14:44:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 14:53:30 2009  removing 818679 relations and 418679 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 14:53:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 14:55:46 2009  begin with 287225788 relations and 158342221 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 15:03:26 2009  reduce to 287214987 relations and 157912260 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 15:03:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 15:11:59 2009  removing 817923 relations and 417923 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 15:12:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 15:14:14 2009  begin with 286397064 relations and 157912260 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 15:21:52 2009  reduce to 286386056 relations and 157482807 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 15:21:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 15:30:20 2009  removing 816833 relations and 416833 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 15:30:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 15:32:35 2009  begin with 285569223 relations and 157482807 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 15:40:12 2009  reduce to 285557834 relations and 157054055 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 15:40:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 15:48:39 2009  removing 816400 relations and 416400 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 15:48:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 15:50:53 2009  begin with 284741434 relations and 157054055 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 15:58:27 2009  reduce to 284729892 relations and 156625537 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 15:58:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 16:06:52 2009  removing 816075 relations and 416075 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 16:07:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 16:09:06 2009  begin with 283913817 relations and 156625537 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 16:16:37 2009  reduce to 283902853 relations and 156197964 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 16:16:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 16:25:00 2009  removing 815822 relations and 415822 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 16:25:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 16:27:13 2009  begin with 283087031 relations and 156197964 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 16:34:44 2009  reduce to 283076047 relations and 155770610 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 16:34:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 16:43:06 2009  removing 814666 relations and 414666 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 16:43:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 16:45:18 2009  begin with 282261381 relations and 155770610 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 16:52:47 2009  reduce to 282249654 relations and 155343630 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 16:52:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 17:01:06 2009  removing 814511 relations and 414511 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 17:01:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 17:03:18 2009  begin with 281435143 relations and 155343630 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 17:10:45 2009  reduce to 281423743 relations and 154917164 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 17:10:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 17:19:03 2009  removing 813570 relations and 413570 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 17:19:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 17:21:14 2009  begin with 280610173 relations and 154917164 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 17:28:40 2009  reduce to 280598495 relations and 154491344 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 17:28:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 17:36:57 2009  removing 813089 relations and 413089 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 17:37:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 17:39:08 2009  begin with 279785406 relations and 154491344 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 17:46:34 2009  reduce to 279773742 relations and 154066034 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 17:46:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 17:54:48 2009  removing 812543 relations and 412543 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 17:54:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 17:56:56 2009  begin with 278961199 relations and 154066034 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 18:04:16 2009  reduce to 278949172 relations and 153640893 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 18:04:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 18:12:29 2009  removing 811741 relations and 411741 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 18:12:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 18:14:38 2009  begin with 278137431 relations and 153640893 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 18:22:00 2009  reduce to 278125215 relations and 153216337 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 18:22:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 18:30:11 2009  removing 811136 relations and 411136 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 18:30:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 18:32:20 2009  begin with 277314079 relations and 153216337 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 18:39:38 2009  reduce to 277301852 relations and 152792372 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 18:39:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 18:47:51 2009  removing 810441 relations and 410441 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 18:48:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 18:50:03 2009  begin with 276491411 relations and 152792372 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 18:57:31 2009  reduce to 276478284 relations and 152368141 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 18:57:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 19:05:52 2009  removing 810249 relations and 410249 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 19:06:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 19:08:04 2009  begin with 275668035 relations and 152368141 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 19:15:33 2009  reduce to 275655694 relations and 151944923 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 19:15:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 19:23:46 2009  removing 809615 relations and 409615 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 19:23:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 19:25:54 2009  begin with 274846079 relations and 151944923 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 19:33:11 2009  reduce to 274833657 relations and 151522265 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 19:33:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 19:41:20 2009  removing 808978 relations and 408978 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 19:41:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 19:43:27 2009  begin with 274024679 relations and 151522265 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 19:50:41 2009  reduce to 274012044 relations and 151099995 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 19:50:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 19:58:47 2009  removing 808370 relations and 408370 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 19:58:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 20:00:55 2009  begin with 273203674 relations and 151099995 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 20:08:06 2009  reduce to 273190915 relations and 150678131 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 20:08:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 20:16:11 2009  removing 807679 relations and 407679 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 20:16:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 20:18:20 2009  begin with 272383236 relations and 150678131 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 20:25:36 2009  reduce to 272370422 relations and 150256940 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 20:25:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 20:33:45 2009  removing 807156 relations and 407156 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 20:33:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 20:35:53 2009  begin with 271563266 relations and 150256940 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 20:43:11 2009  reduce to 271549903 relations and 149835672 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 20:43:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 20:51:19 2009  removing 806671 relations and 406671 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 20:51:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 20:53:28 2009  begin with 270743232 relations and 149835672 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 21:00:43 2009  reduce to 270730042 relations and 149415038 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 21:00:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 21:08:50 2009  removing 806359 relations and 406359 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 21:09:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 21:10:56 2009  begin with 269923683 relations and 149415038 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 21:18:02 2009  reduce to 269910717 relations and 148995000 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 21:18:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 30
Fri Jan  9 21:25:59 2009  removing 805675 relations and 405675 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 21:26:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 21:28:04 2009  begin with 269105042 relations and 148995000 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 21:35:06 2009  reduce to 269091695 relations and 148575256 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 21:35:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 21:42:59 2009  removing 805078 relations and 405078 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 21:43:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 21:45:02 2009  begin with 268286617 relations and 148575256 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 21:52:03 2009  reduce to 268272888 relations and 148155722 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 21:52:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 21:59:55 2009  removing 804564 relations and 404564 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 22:00:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 22:01:58 2009  begin with 267468324 relations and 148155722 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 22:08:57 2009  reduce to 267454843 relations and 147736937 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 22:08:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 22:16:47 2009  removing 804101 relations and 404101 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 22:16:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 22:18:50 2009  begin with 266650742 relations and 147736937 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 22:25:49 2009  reduce to 266636902 relations and 147318216 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 22:25:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 22:33:36 2009  removing 803675 relations and 403675 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 22:33:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 22:35:39 2009  begin with 265833227 relations and 147318216 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 22:42:34 2009  reduce to 265819187 relations and 146899732 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 22:42:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 22:50:21 2009  removing 803294 relations and 403294 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 22:50:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 22:52:22 2009  begin with 265015893 relations and 146899732 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 22:59:15 2009  reduce to 265001711 relations and 146481463 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 22:59:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 23:08:15 2009  removing 802767 relations and 402767 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 23:08:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 23:10:45 2009  begin with 264198944 relations and 146481463 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 23:19:15 2009  reduce to 264184821 relations and 146063811 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 23:19:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 23:28:36 2009  removing 802471 relations and 402471 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 23:28:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 23:31:03 2009  begin with 263382350 relations and 146063811 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 23:37:49 2009  reduce to 263367635 relations and 145645806 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 23:37:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Fri Jan  9 23:45:20 2009  removing 802206 relations and 402206 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan  9 23:45:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan  9 23:47:19 2009  begin with 262565429 relations and 145645806 unique ideals
Fri Jan  9 23:54:03 2009  reduce to 262550795 relations and 145228152 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan  9 23:54:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 00:01:32 2009  removing 802047 relations and 402047 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 00:01:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 00:03:30 2009  begin with 261748748 relations and 145228152 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 00:10:14 2009  reduce to 261733959 relations and 144810512 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 00:10:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 00:17:42 2009  removing 802091 relations and 402091 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 00:17:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 00:19:40 2009  begin with 260931868 relations and 144810512 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 00:26:20 2009  reduce to 260916352 relations and 144392052 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 00:26:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 00:33:45 2009  removing 802158 relations and 402158 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 00:33:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 00:35:42 2009  begin with 260114194 relations and 144392052 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 00:42:21 2009  reduce to 260098806 relations and 143973657 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 00:42:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 00:49:42 2009  removing 802115 relations and 402115 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 00:49:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 00:51:39 2009  begin with 259296691 relations and 143973657 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 00:58:16 2009  reduce to 259281546 relations and 143555533 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 00:58:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 01:05:36 2009  removing 802081 relations and 402081 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 01:05:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 01:07:32 2009  begin with 258479465 relations and 143555533 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 01:14:07 2009  reduce to 258464448 relations and 143137612 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 01:14:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 01:21:27 2009  removing 802147 relations and 402147 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 01:21:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 01:23:23 2009  begin with 257662301 relations and 143137612 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 01:29:55 2009  reduce to 257647683 relations and 142720022 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 01:29:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 01:37:09 2009  removing 802106 relations and 402106 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 01:37:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 01:39:04 2009  begin with 256845577 relations and 142720022 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 01:45:33 2009  reduce to 256830886 relations and 142302421 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 01:45:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 01:52:46 2009  removing 801973 relations and 401973 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 01:52:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 01:54:40 2009  begin with 256028913 relations and 142302421 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 02:01:08 2009  reduce to 256014581 relations and 141885334 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 02:01:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 02:08:18 2009  removing 801994 relations and 401994 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 02:08:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 02:10:12 2009  begin with 255212587 relations and 141885334 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 02:16:38 2009  reduce to 255198332 relations and 141468324 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 02:16:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 02:23:45 2009  removing 801946 relations and 401946 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 02:23:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 02:25:38 2009  begin with 254396386 relations and 141468324 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 02:32:02 2009  reduce to 254382509 relations and 141051738 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 02:32:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 02:39:09 2009  removing 801979 relations and 401979 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 02:39:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 02:41:02 2009  begin with 253580530 relations and 141051738 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 02:47:25 2009  reduce to 253566642 relations and 140635160 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 02:47:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 02:54:29 2009  removing 802002 relations and 402002 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 02:54:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 02:56:22 2009  begin with 252764640 relations and 140635160 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 03:02:43 2009  reduce to 252751118 relations and 140218991 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 03:02:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 03:09:45 2009  removing 801954 relations and 401954 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 03:09:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 03:11:36 2009  begin with 251949164 relations and 140218991 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 03:17:55 2009  reduce to 251935942 relations and 139803077 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 03:17:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 03:24:54 2009  removing 801965 relations and 401965 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 03:25:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 03:26:44 2009  begin with 251133977 relations and 139803077 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 03:33:01 2009  reduce to 251121015 relations and 139387439 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 03:33:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 03:39:57 2009  removing 802020 relations and 402020 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 03:40:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 03:41:48 2009  begin with 250318995 relations and 139387439 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 03:48:03 2009  reduce to 250306315 relations and 138972102 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 03:48:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 03:54:58 2009  removing 801911 relations and 401911 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 03:55:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 03:56:48 2009  begin with 249504404 relations and 138972102 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 04:03:03 2009  reduce to 249491860 relations and 138557023 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 04:03:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 04:09:56 2009  removing 801924 relations and 401924 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 04:10:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 04:11:46 2009  begin with 248689936 relations and 138557023 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 04:17:57 2009  reduce to 248677395 relations and 138141970 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 04:17:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 04:24:48 2009  removing 801873 relations and 401873 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 04:24:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 04:26:38 2009  begin with 247875522 relations and 138141970 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 04:32:51 2009  reduce to 247863252 relations and 137727278 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 04:32:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 04:39:39 2009  removing 801797 relations and 401797 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 04:39:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 04:41:28 2009  begin with 247061455 relations and 137727278 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 04:47:39 2009  reduce to 247049462 relations and 137312896 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 04:47:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 04:54:25 2009  removing 801806 relations and 401806 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 04:54:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 04:56:14 2009  begin with 246247656 relations and 137312896 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 05:02:21 2009  reduce to 246235922 relations and 136898839 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 05:02:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 05:09:04 2009  removing 801786 relations and 401786 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 05:09:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 05:10:52 2009  begin with 245434136 relations and 136898839 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 05:16:58 2009  reduce to 245422493 relations and 136484908 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 05:16:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 05:23:42 2009  removing 801801 relations and 401801 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 05:23:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 05:25:30 2009  begin with 244620692 relations and 136484908 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 05:31:36 2009  reduce to 244609308 relations and 136071188 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 05:31:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 05:38:17 2009  removing 801787 relations and 401787 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 05:38:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 05:40:05 2009  begin with 243807521 relations and 136071188 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 05:46:09 2009  reduce to 243796397 relations and 135657774 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 05:46:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 05:52:48 2009  removing 801742 relations and 401742 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 05:52:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 05:54:34 2009  begin with 242994655 relations and 135657774 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 06:00:34 2009  reduce to 242983762 relations and 135244626 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 06:00:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 06:07:10 2009  removing 801723 relations and 401723 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 06:07:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 06:08:55 2009  begin with 242182039 relations and 135244626 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 06:14:55 2009  reduce to 242171187 relations and 134831596 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 06:14:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 06:21:29 2009  removing 801772 relations and 401772 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 06:21:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 06:23:14 2009  begin with 241369415 relations and 134831596 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 06:29:11 2009  reduce to 241358871 relations and 134418821 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 06:29:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 06:35:43 2009  removing 801696 relations and 401696 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 06:35:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 06:37:27 2009  begin with 240557175 relations and 134418821 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 06:43:23 2009  reduce to 240546953 relations and 134006491 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 06:43:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 06:49:52 2009  removing 801782 relations and 401782 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 06:50:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 06:51:36 2009  begin with 239745171 relations and 134006491 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 06:57:28 2009  reduce to 239734871 relations and 133593969 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 06:57:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 07:03:56 2009  removing 801748 relations and 401748 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 07:04:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 07:05:41 2009  begin with 238933123 relations and 133593969 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 07:11:34 2009  reduce to 238922956 relations and 133181638 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 07:11:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 07:18:00 2009  removing 801612 relations and 401612 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 07:18:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 07:19:44 2009  begin with 238121344 relations and 133181638 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 07:25:36 2009  reduce to 238111534 relations and 132769809 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 07:25:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 07:32:00 2009  removing 801706 relations and 401706 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 07:32:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 07:33:44 2009  begin with 237309828 relations and 132769809 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 07:39:36 2009  reduce to 237300074 relations and 132357954 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 07:39:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 07:45:59 2009  removing 801659 relations and 401659 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 07:46:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 07:47:42 2009  begin with 236498415 relations and 132357954 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 07:53:32 2009  reduce to 236489041 relations and 131946537 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 07:53:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 07:59:53 2009  removing 801573 relations and 401573 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 08:00:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 08:01:35 2009  begin with 235687468 relations and 131946537 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 08:07:22 2009  reduce to 235678081 relations and 131535192 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 08:07:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 08:13:41 2009  removing 801684 relations and 401684 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 08:13:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 08:15:23 2009  begin with 234876397 relations and 131535192 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 08:21:09 2009  reduce to 234867290 relations and 131124013 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 08:21:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 08:27:26 2009  removing 801568 relations and 401568 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 08:27:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 08:29:08 2009  begin with 234065722 relations and 131124013 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 08:34:53 2009  reduce to 234056681 relations and 130713055 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 08:34:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 08:41:08 2009  removing 801563 relations and 401563 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 08:41:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 08:42:49 2009  begin with 233255118 relations and 130713055 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 08:48:32 2009  reduce to 233246409 relations and 130302436 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 08:48:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 08:54:46 2009  removing 801545 relations and 401545 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 08:54:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 08:56:26 2009  begin with 232444864 relations and 130302436 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 09:02:06 2009  reduce to 232436216 relations and 129891916 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 09:02:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 09:08:15 2009  removing 801585 relations and 401585 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 09:08:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 09:09:56 2009  begin with 231634631 relations and 129891916 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 09:15:35 2009  reduce to 231626196 relations and 129481571 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 09:15:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 09:21:43 2009  removing 801582 relations and 401582 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 09:21:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 09:23:23 2009  begin with 230824614 relations and 129481571 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 09:29:01 2009  reduce to 230816425 relations and 129071485 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 09:29:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 09:35:08 2009  removing 801517 relations and 401517 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 09:35:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 09:36:47 2009  begin with 230014908 relations and 129071485 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 09:42:24 2009  reduce to 230006808 relations and 128661585 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 09:42:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 09:48:28 2009  removing 801513 relations and 401513 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 09:48:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 09:50:06 2009  begin with 229205295 relations and 128661585 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 09:55:41 2009  reduce to 229197509 relations and 128251993 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 09:55:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 10:01:43 2009  removing 801461 relations and 401461 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 10:01:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 10:03:21 2009  begin with 228396048 relations and 128251993 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 10:08:56 2009  reduce to 228388239 relations and 127842447 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 10:08:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 10:14:57 2009  removing 801509 relations and 401509 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 10:15:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 10:16:35 2009  begin with 227586730 relations and 127842447 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 10:22:06 2009  reduce to 227579263 relations and 127433193 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 10:22:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 10:28:05 2009  removing 801510 relations and 401510 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 10:28:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 10:29:42 2009  begin with 226777753 relations and 127433193 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 10:35:12 2009  reduce to 226770469 relations and 127024132 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 10:35:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 10:41:08 2009  removing 801554 relations and 401554 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 10:41:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 10:42:44 2009  begin with 225968915 relations and 127024132 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 10:50:01 2009  reduce to 225961705 relations and 126615140 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 10 10:50:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 10:55:55 2009  removing 801481 relations and 401481 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 10:56:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 10:57:31 2009  begin with 225160224 relations and 126615140 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 11:02:57 2009  reduce to 225153335 relations and 126206538 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 11:02:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 11:08:49 2009  removing 801411 relations and 401411 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 11:08:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 11:10:25 2009  begin with 224351924 relations and 126206538 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 11:15:48 2009  reduce to 224345101 relations and 125798068 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 11:15:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 11:21:38 2009  removing 801404 relations and 401404 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 11:21:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 11:23:14 2009  begin with 223543697 relations and 125798068 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 11:28:38 2009  reduce to 223536892 relations and 125389624 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 11:28:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 11:34:27 2009  removing 801422 relations and 401422 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 11:34:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 11:36:03 2009  begin with 222735470 relations and 125389624 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 11:41:25 2009  reduce to 222729002 relations and 124981534 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 11:41:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 29
Sat Jan 10 11:47:12 2009  removing 801443 relations and 401443 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 11:47:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 11:48:47 2009  begin with 221927559 relations and 124981534 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 11:54:08 2009  reduce to 221921397 relations and 124573702 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 11:54:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 11:59:54 2009  removing 801308 relations and 401308 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 12:00:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 12:01:28 2009  begin with 221120089 relations and 124573702 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 12:06:49 2009  reduce to 221113906 relations and 124166016 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 12:06:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 12:12:32 2009  removing 801326 relations and 401326 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 12:12:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 12:14:06 2009  begin with 220312580 relations and 124166016 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 12:19:23 2009  reduce to 220306385 relations and 123758307 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 12:19:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 12:25:05 2009  removing 801200 relations and 401200 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 12:25:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 12:26:38 2009  begin with 219505185 relations and 123758307 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 12:31:54 2009  reduce to 219499515 relations and 123351271 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 12:31:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 12:37:33 2009  removing 801221 relations and 401221 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 12:37:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 12:39:05 2009  begin with 218698294 relations and 123351271 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 12:44:19 2009  reduce to 218692589 relations and 122944171 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 12:44:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 12:49:55 2009  removing 801269 relations and 401269 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 12:50:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 12:51:27 2009  begin with 217891320 relations and 122944171 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 12:56:41 2009  reduce to 217885695 relations and 122537089 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 12:56:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 13:02:16 2009  removing 801264 relations and 401264 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 13:02:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 13:03:47 2009  begin with 217084431 relations and 122537089 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 13:09:00 2009  reduce to 217079062 relations and 122130310 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 13:09:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 13:14:34 2009  removing 801247 relations and 401247 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 13:14:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 13:16:05 2009  begin with 216277815 relations and 122130310 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 13:21:16 2009  reduce to 216272812 relations and 121723917 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 13:21:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 13:26:47 2009  removing 801208 relations and 401208 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 13:26:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 13:28:19 2009  begin with 215471604 relations and 121723917 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 13:33:31 2009  reduce to 215466638 relations and 121317589 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 13:33:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 13:39:01 2009  removing 801212 relations and 401212 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 13:39:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 13:40:31 2009  begin with 214665426 relations and 121317589 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 13:45:38 2009  reduce to 214660581 relations and 120911392 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 13:45:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 13:51:05 2009  removing 801208 relations and 401208 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 13:51:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 13:52:35 2009  begin with 213859373 relations and 120911392 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 13:57:41 2009  reduce to 213854617 relations and 120505304 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 13:57:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 14:03:07 2009  removing 801289 relations and 401289 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 14:03:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 14:04:37 2009  begin with 213053328 relations and 120505304 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 14:09:41 2009  reduce to 213048736 relations and 120099323 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 14:09:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 14:15:05 2009  removing 801267 relations and 401267 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 14:15:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 14:16:34 2009  begin with 212247469 relations and 120099323 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 14:21:38 2009  reduce to 212242912 relations and 119693401 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 14:21:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 14:26:59 2009  removing 801219 relations and 401219 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 14:27:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 14:28:27 2009  begin with 211441693 relations and 119693401 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 14:33:28 2009  reduce to 211437372 relations and 119287749 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 14:33:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 14:38:47 2009  removing 801157 relations and 401157 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 14:38:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 14:40:16 2009  begin with 210636215 relations and 119287749 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 14:45:15 2009  reduce to 210632032 relations and 118882280 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 14:45:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 14:50:32 2009  removing 801165 relations and 401165 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 14:50:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 14:52:00 2009  begin with 209830867 relations and 118882280 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 14:56:59 2009  reduce to 209826710 relations and 118476877 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 14:56:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:02:13 2009  removing 801238 relations and 401238 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:02:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 15:03:40 2009  begin with 209025472 relations and 118476877 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 15:08:38 2009  reduce to 209021563 relations and 118071635 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 15:08:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:13:50 2009  removing 801238 relations and 401238 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:13:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 15:15:17 2009  begin with 208220325 relations and 118071635 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 15:20:12 2009  reduce to 208216450 relations and 117666452 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 15:20:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:25:23 2009  removing 801225 relations and 401225 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:25:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 15:26:49 2009  begin with 207415225 relations and 117666452 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 15:31:43 2009  reduce to 207411613 relations and 117261533 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 15:31:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:36:51 2009  removing 801182 relations and 401182 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:36:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 15:38:17 2009  begin with 206610431 relations and 117261533 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 15:43:10 2009  reduce to 206606911 relations and 116856733 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 15:43:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:48:17 2009  removing 801122 relations and 401122 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:48:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 15:49:42 2009  begin with 205805789 relations and 116856733 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 15:54:33 2009  reduce to 205802380 relations and 116452153 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 15:54:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 15:59:37 2009  removing 801146 relations and 401146 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 15:59:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:01:02 2009  begin with 205001234 relations and 116452153 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 16:05:52 2009  reduce to 204997841 relations and 116047524 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 16:05:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 16:10:55 2009  removing 801116 relations and 401116 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 16:11:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:12:20 2009  begin with 204196725 relations and 116047524 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 16:17:07 2009  reduce to 204193568 relations and 115643197 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 16:17:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 16:22:06 2009  removing 801157 relations and 401157 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 16:22:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:23:31 2009  begin with 203392411 relations and 115643197 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 16:28:17 2009  reduce to 203389357 relations and 115238926 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 16:28:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 16:33:16 2009  removing 801091 relations and 401091 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 16:33:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:34:40 2009  begin with 202588266 relations and 115238926 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 16:39:25 2009  reduce to 202585397 relations and 114834918 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 16:39:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 16:44:21 2009  removing 801087 relations and 401087 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 16:44:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:45:46 2009  begin with 201784310 relations and 114834918 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 16:50:30 2009  reduce to 201781509 relations and 114430972 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 16:50:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 16:55:25 2009  removing 801042 relations and 401042 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 16:55:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 16:56:49 2009  begin with 200980467 relations and 114430972 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:01:31 2009  reduce to 200977832 relations and 114027241 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:01:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:06:23 2009  removing 801098 relations and 401098 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 17:06:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 17:07:45 2009  begin with 200176734 relations and 114027241 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:12:25 2009  reduce to 200174174 relations and 113623535 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:12:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:17:16 2009  removing 801057 relations and 401057 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 17:17:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 17:18:38 2009  begin with 199373117 relations and 113623535 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:23:15 2009  reduce to 199370682 relations and 113220005 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:23:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:28:02 2009  removing 801024 relations and 401024 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 17:28:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 17:29:23 2009  begin with 198569658 relations and 113220005 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:34:00 2009  reduce to 198567193 relations and 112816478 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:34:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:38:45 2009  removing 800969 relations and 400969 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 17:38:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 17:40:06 2009  begin with 197766224 relations and 112816478 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:44:40 2009  reduce to 197763922 relations and 112413156 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:44:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:49:23 2009  removing 801064 relations and 401064 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 17:49:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 17:50:43 2009  begin with 196962858 relations and 112413156 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 17:55:16 2009  reduce to 196960593 relations and 112009804 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 17:55:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 17:59:57 2009  removing 800962 relations and 400962 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:00:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:01:17 2009  begin with 196159631 relations and 112009804 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:05:49 2009  reduce to 196157503 relations and 111606687 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:05:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 18:10:28 2009  removing 801001 relations and 401001 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:10:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:11:48 2009  begin with 195356502 relations and 111606687 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:16:18 2009  reduce to 195354571 relations and 111203723 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:16:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 18:20:55 2009  removing 800876 relations and 400876 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:21:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:22:15 2009  begin with 194553695 relations and 111203723 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:26:43 2009  reduce to 194551798 relations and 110800930 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:26:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 18:31:18 2009  removing 800893 relations and 400893 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:31:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:32:37 2009  begin with 193750905 relations and 110800930 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:37:03 2009  reduce to 193749080 relations and 110398198 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:37:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 18:41:36 2009  removing 800869 relations and 400869 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:41:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:42:54 2009  begin with 192948211 relations and 110398198 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:47:19 2009  reduce to 192946407 relations and 109995498 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:47:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 18:51:49 2009  removing 800859 relations and 400859 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 18:51:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 18:53:07 2009  begin with 192145548 relations and 109995498 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 18:57:32 2009  reduce to 192143880 relations and 109592944 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 18:57:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:02:04 2009  removing 800764 relations and 400764 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:02:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:03:23 2009  begin with 191343116 relations and 109592944 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 19:07:48 2009  reduce to 191341523 relations and 109190570 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 19:07:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:12:18 2009  removing 800828 relations and 400828 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:12:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:13:36 2009  begin with 190540695 relations and 109190570 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 19:18:01 2009  reduce to 190539187 relations and 108788213 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 19:18:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:22:29 2009  removing 800800 relations and 400800 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:22:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:23:47 2009  begin with 189738387 relations and 108788213 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 19:28:10 2009  reduce to 189736980 relations and 108385996 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 19:28:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:32:38 2009  removing 800790 relations and 400790 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:32:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:33:56 2009  begin with 188936190 relations and 108385996 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 19:38:19 2009  reduce to 188934841 relations and 107983838 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 19:38:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:42:47 2009  removing 800707 relations and 400707 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:42:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:44:05 2009  begin with 188134134 relations and 107983838 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 19:48:55 2009  reduce to 188132871 relations and 107581846 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 19:48:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 19:53:46 2009  removing 800688 relations and 400688 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 19:53:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 19:55:11 2009  begin with 187332183 relations and 107581846 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:00:01 2009  reduce to 187330961 relations and 107179921 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:00:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 20:04:52 2009  removing 800739 relations and 400739 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:04:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 20:06:16 2009  begin with 186530222 relations and 107179921 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:11:04 2009  reduce to 186529047 relations and 106777988 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:11:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 20:15:53 2009  removing 800676 relations and 400676 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:16:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 20:17:17 2009  begin with 185728371 relations and 106777988 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:22:03 2009  reduce to 185727337 relations and 106376263 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:22:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 28
Sat Jan 10 20:26:51 2009  removing 800615 relations and 400615 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:26:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 20:28:14 2009  begin with 184926722 relations and 106376263 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:32:59 2009  reduce to 184925629 relations and 105974542 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:32:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 20:37:44 2009  removing 800606 relations and 400606 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:37:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 20:39:07 2009  begin with 184125023 relations and 105974542 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:43:51 2009  reduce to 184124025 relations and 105572927 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:43:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 20:48:33 2009  removing 800574 relations and 400574 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:48:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 20:49:56 2009  begin with 183323451 relations and 105572927 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 20:54:38 2009  reduce to 183322485 relations and 105171377 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 20:54:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 20:59:18 2009  removing 800543 relations and 400543 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 20:59:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:00:40 2009  begin with 182521942 relations and 105171377 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:05:22 2009  reduce to 182521108 relations and 104769995 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:05:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:10:01 2009  removing 800490 relations and 400490 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:10:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:11:22 2009  begin with 181720618 relations and 104769995 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:16:01 2009  reduce to 181719769 relations and 104368651 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:16:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:20:38 2009  removing 800477 relations and 400477 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:20:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:21:59 2009  begin with 180919292 relations and 104368651 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:26:36 2009  reduce to 180918502 relations and 103967369 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:26:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:31:10 2009  removing 800448 relations and 400448 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:31:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:32:31 2009  begin with 180118054 relations and 103967369 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:36:45 2009  reduce to 180117278 relations and 103566133 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:36:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:40:49 2009  removing 800442 relations and 400442 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:40:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:42:01 2009  begin with 179316836 relations and 103566133 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:46:05 2009  reduce to 179316158 relations and 103165001 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:46:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:50:05 2009  removing 800414 relations and 400414 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:50:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 21:51:17 2009  begin with 178515744 relations and 103165001 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 21:55:19 2009  reduce to 178515026 relations and 102763857 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 21:55:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 21:59:19 2009  removing 800352 relations and 400352 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 21:59:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:00:31 2009  begin with 177714674 relations and 102763857 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:04:33 2009  reduce to 177713977 relations and 102362798 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:04:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:08:30 2009  removing 800354 relations and 400354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:08:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:09:41 2009  begin with 176913623 relations and 102362798 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:13:43 2009  reduce to 176912917 relations and 101961733 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:13:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:17:38 2009  removing 800311 relations and 400311 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:17:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:18:49 2009  begin with 176112606 relations and 101961733 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:22:47 2009  reduce to 176112010 relations and 101560818 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:22:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:26:41 2009  removing 800263 relations and 400263 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:26:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:27:50 2009  begin with 175311747 relations and 101560818 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:30:28 2009  reduce to 175311137 relations and 101159939 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:30:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:34:20 2009  removing 800247 relations and 400247 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:34:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:35:29 2009  begin with 174510890 relations and 101159939 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:38:07 2009  reduce to 174510309 relations and 100759103 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:38:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:41:57 2009  removing 800207 relations and 400207 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:42:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:43:06 2009  begin with 173710102 relations and 100759103 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:45:43 2009  reduce to 173709555 relations and 100358344 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:45:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:49:30 2009  removing 800252 relations and 400252 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:49:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:50:39 2009  begin with 172909303 relations and 100358344 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 22:53:15 2009  reduce to 172908829 relations and 99957612 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 22:53:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 22:57:00 2009  removing 800207 relations and 400207 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 22:57:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 22:58:09 2009  begin with 172108622 relations and 99957612 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:00:44 2009  reduce to 172108193 relations and 99556970 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:00:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:04:26 2009  removing 800206 relations and 400206 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:04:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:05:33 2009  begin with 171307987 relations and 99556970 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:08:08 2009  reduce to 171307591 relations and 99156362 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:08:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:11:48 2009  removing 800193 relations and 400193 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:11:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:12:56 2009  begin with 170507398 relations and 99156362 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:15:30 2009  reduce to 170507084 relations and 98755850 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:15:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:19:10 2009  removing 800183 relations and 400183 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:19:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:20:18 2009  begin with 169706901 relations and 98755850 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:22:50 2009  reduce to 169706591 relations and 98355356 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:22:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:26:29 2009  removing 800154 relations and 400154 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:26:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:27:35 2009  begin with 168906437 relations and 98355356 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:30:07 2009  reduce to 168906182 relations and 97954946 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:30:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:33:41 2009  removing 800132 relations and 400132 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:33:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:34:48 2009  begin with 168106050 relations and 97954946 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:37:19 2009  reduce to 168105839 relations and 97554602 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:37:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:40:52 2009  removing 800151 relations and 400151 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:40:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:41:59 2009  begin with 167305688 relations and 97554602 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:44:29 2009  reduce to 167305483 relations and 97154246 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:44:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:47:59 2009  removing 800116 relations and 400116 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:48:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:49:04 2009  begin with 166505367 relations and 97154246 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:51:33 2009  reduce to 166505174 relations and 96753937 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:51:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sat Jan 10 23:55:02 2009  removing 800118 relations and 400118 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 10 23:55:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 10 23:56:08 2009  begin with 165705056 relations and 96753937 unique ideals
Sat Jan 10 23:58:37 2009  reduce to 165704885 relations and 96353647 ideals in 2 passes
Sat Jan 10 23:58:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:02:03 2009  removing 800114 relations and 400114 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:02:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:03:08 2009  begin with 164904771 relations and 96353647 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:05:35 2009  reduce to 164904614 relations and 95953376 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:05:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:09:00 2009  removing 800100 relations and 400100 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:09:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:10:04 2009  begin with 164104514 relations and 95953376 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:12:29 2009  reduce to 164104396 relations and 95553158 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:12:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:15:52 2009  removing 800110 relations and 400110 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:15:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:16:57 2009  begin with 163304286 relations and 95553158 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:19:23 2009  reduce to 163304170 relations and 95152932 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:19:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:22:43 2009  removing 800084 relations and 400084 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:22:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:23:47 2009  begin with 162504086 relations and 95152932 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:26:11 2009  reduce to 162503976 relations and 94752736 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:26:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:29:29 2009  removing 800069 relations and 400069 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:29:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:30:33 2009  begin with 161703907 relations and 94752736 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:32:57 2009  reduce to 161703798 relations and 94352558 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:32:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:36:13 2009  removing 800064 relations and 400064 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:36:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:37:16 2009  begin with 160903734 relations and 94352558 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:39:39 2009  reduce to 160903662 relations and 93952422 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:39:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:42:54 2009  removing 800074 relations and 400074 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:43:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:43:57 2009  begin with 160103588 relations and 93952422 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:46:20 2009  reduce to 160103500 relations and 93552260 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:46:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:49:31 2009  removing 800059 relations and 400059 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:49:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:50:33 2009  begin with 159303441 relations and 93552260 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:52:54 2009  reduce to 159303386 relations and 93152146 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:52:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 00:56:03 2009  removing 800055 relations and 400055 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 00:56:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 00:57:06 2009  begin with 158503331 relations and 93152146 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 00:59:27 2009  reduce to 158503268 relations and 92752028 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 00:59:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 01:02:34 2009  removing 800057 relations and 400057 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:02:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:03:36 2009  begin with 157703211 relations and 92752028 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:05:56 2009  reduce to 157703155 relations and 92351915 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:05:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 01:09:01 2009  removing 800045 relations and 400045 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:09:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:10:03 2009  begin with 156903110 relations and 92351915 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:12:21 2009  reduce to 156903059 relations and 91951819 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:12:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 27
Sun Jan 11 01:15:25 2009  removing 800049 relations and 400049 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:15:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:16:26 2009  begin with 156103010 relations and 91951819 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:18:45 2009  reduce to 156102961 relations and 91551721 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:18:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:21:47 2009  removing 800044 relations and 400044 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:21:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:22:47 2009  begin with 155302917 relations and 91551721 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:25:05 2009  reduce to 155302876 relations and 91151636 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:25:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:28:04 2009  removing 800045 relations and 400045 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:28:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:29:04 2009  begin with 154502831 relations and 91151636 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:31:21 2009  reduce to 154502798 relations and 90751558 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:31:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:34:17 2009  removing 800035 relations and 400035 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:34:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:35:17 2009  begin with 153702763 relations and 90751558 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:37:32 2009  reduce to 153702730 relations and 90351490 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:37:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:40:26 2009  removing 800030 relations and 400030 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:40:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:41:25 2009  begin with 152902700 relations and 90351490 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:43:40 2009  reduce to 152902669 relations and 89951429 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:43:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:46:32 2009  removing 800029 relations and 400029 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:46:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:47:32 2009  begin with 152102640 relations and 89951429 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:49:47 2009  reduce to 152102607 relations and 89551367 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:49:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:52:38 2009  removing 746340 relations and 373187 ideals in 373153 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:52:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:53:37 2009  begin with 151356267 relations and 89551367 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 01:55:50 2009  reduce to 151356240 relations and 89178153 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 01:55:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 01:58:38 2009  removing 94107 relations and 47067 ideals in 47040 cliques
Sun Jan 11 01:58:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 01:59:36 2009  begin with 151262133 relations and 89178153 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:01:49 2009  reduce to 151262110 relations and 89131063 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:01:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:04:37 2009  removing 90200 relations and 45108 ideals in 45092 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:04:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:05:36 2009  begin with 151171910 relations and 89131063 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:07:49 2009  reduce to 151171887 relations and 89085932 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:07:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:10:37 2009  removing 87085 relations and 43553 ideals in 43532 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:10:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:11:34 2009  begin with 151084802 relations and 89085932 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:13:48 2009  reduce to 151084782 relations and 89042359 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:13:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:16:37 2009  removing 83511 relations and 41768 ideals in 41743 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:16:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:17:34 2009  begin with 151001271 relations and 89042359 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:19:47 2009  reduce to 151001253 relations and 89000573 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:19:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:22:35 2009  removing 80298 relations and 40156 ideals in 40142 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:22:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:23:32 2009  begin with 150920955 relations and 89000573 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:25:44 2009  reduce to 150920936 relations and 88960398 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:25:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:28:32 2009  removing 76544 relations and 38278 ideals in 38266 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:28:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:29:30 2009  begin with 150844392 relations and 88960398 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:31:43 2009  reduce to 150844375 relations and 88922103 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:31:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:34:30 2009  removing 73922 relations and 36968 ideals in 36954 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:34:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:35:28 2009  begin with 150770453 relations and 88922103 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:37:40 2009  reduce to 150770437 relations and 88885119 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:37:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:40:28 2009  removing 71632 relations and 35824 ideals in 35808 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:40:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:41:25 2009  begin with 150698805 relations and 88885119 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:43:37 2009  reduce to 150698789 relations and 88849279 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:43:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:46:25 2009  removing 69160 relations and 34586 ideals in 34574 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:46:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:47:23 2009  begin with 150629629 relations and 88849279 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:49:35 2009  reduce to 150629616 relations and 88814680 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:49:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:52:23 2009  removing 66145 relations and 33078 ideals in 33067 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:52:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:53:21 2009  begin with 150563471 relations and 88814680 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 02:55:35 2009  reduce to 150563454 relations and 88781585 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 02:55:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 02:58:24 2009  removing 63592 relations and 31803 ideals in 31789 cliques
Sun Jan 11 02:58:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 02:59:21 2009  begin with 150499862 relations and 88781585 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:01:33 2009  reduce to 150499843 relations and 88749763 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:01:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:04:20 2009  removing 61466 relations and 30738 ideals in 30728 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:04:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:05:17 2009  begin with 150438377 relations and 88749763 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:07:29 2009  reduce to 150438372 relations and 88719020 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:07:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:10:15 2009  removing 59080 relations and 29545 ideals in 29535 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:10:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:11:12 2009  begin with 150379292 relations and 88719020 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:13:24 2009  reduce to 150379284 relations and 88689467 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:13:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:16:10 2009  removing 56857 relations and 28432 ideals in 28425 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:16:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:17:07 2009  begin with 150322427 relations and 88689467 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:19:20 2009  reduce to 150322420 relations and 88661028 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:19:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:22:06 2009  removing 54368 relations and 27186 ideals in 27182 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:22:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:23:04 2009  begin with 150268052 relations and 88661028 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:25:17 2009  reduce to 150268046 relations and 88633836 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:25:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:28:04 2009  removing 52259 relations and 26131 ideals in 26128 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:28:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:29:01 2009  begin with 150215787 relations and 88633836 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:31:14 2009  reduce to 150215783 relations and 88607701 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:31:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:34:01 2009  removing 50426 relations and 25215 ideals in 25211 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:34:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:34:58 2009  begin with 150165357 relations and 88607701 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:37:09 2009  reduce to 150165348 relations and 88582477 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:37:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:39:57 2009  removing 48986 relations and 24496 ideals in 24490 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:40:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:40:54 2009  begin with 150116362 relations and 88582477 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:43:06 2009  reduce to 150116356 relations and 88557975 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:43:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:45:59 2009  removing 46835 relations and 23420 ideals in 23415 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:46:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:47:00 2009  begin with 150069521 relations and 88557975 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:49:20 2009  reduce to 150069515 relations and 88534549 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:49:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:52:19 2009  removing 45336 relations and 22670 ideals in 22666 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:52:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:53:20 2009  begin with 150024179 relations and 88534549 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 03:55:44 2009  reduce to 150024173 relations and 88511873 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 03:55:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 03:58:46 2009  removing 43810 relations and 21907 ideals in 21903 cliques
Sun Jan 11 03:58:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 03:59:49 2009  begin with 149980363 relations and 88511873 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:02:09 2009  reduce to 149980360 relations and 88489963 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:02:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:05:14 2009  removing 42594 relations and 21300 ideals in 21294 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:05:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:06:16 2009  begin with 149937766 relations and 88489963 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:08:42 2009  reduce to 149937759 relations and 88468656 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:08:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:11:48 2009  removing 40998 relations and 20501 ideals in 20497 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:11:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:12:50 2009  begin with 149896761 relations and 88468656 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:15:18 2009  reduce to 149896754 relations and 88448148 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:15:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:18:24 2009  removing 39540 relations and 19773 ideals in 19767 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:18:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:19:27 2009  begin with 149857214 relations and 88448148 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:21:55 2009  reduce to 149857208 relations and 88428369 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:21:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:25:02 2009  removing 37899 relations and 18951 ideals in 18948 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:25:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:26:06 2009  begin with 149819309 relations and 88428369 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:28:33 2009  reduce to 149819306 relations and 88409415 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:28:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:31:39 2009  removing 36751 relations and 18377 ideals in 18374 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:31:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:32:43 2009  begin with 149782555 relations and 88409415 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:35:12 2009  reduce to 149782551 relations and 88391034 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:35:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:38:19 2009  removing 35224 relations and 17613 ideals in 17611 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:38:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:39:24 2009  begin with 149747327 relations and 88391034 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:41:53 2009  reduce to 149747324 relations and 88373418 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:41:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:45:01 2009  removing 34230 relations and 17116 ideals in 17114 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:45:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:46:05 2009  begin with 149713094 relations and 88373418 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:48:35 2009  reduce to 149713090 relations and 88356298 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:48:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:51:44 2009  removing 32926 relations and 16464 ideals in 16462 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:51:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:52:49 2009  begin with 149680164 relations and 88356298 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 04:55:19 2009  reduce to 149680163 relations and 88339833 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 04:55:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 04:58:29 2009  removing 31621 relations and 15811 ideals in 15810 cliques
Sun Jan 11 04:58:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 04:59:33 2009  begin with 149648542 relations and 88339833 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:02:03 2009  reduce to 149648538 relations and 88324018 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:02:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:05:12 2009  removing 30801 relations and 15402 ideals in 15399 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:05:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:06:16 2009  begin with 149617737 relations and 88324018 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:08:46 2009  reduce to 149617734 relations and 88308613 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:08:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:11:55 2009  removing 29987 relations and 14995 ideals in 14992 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:12:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:13:00 2009  begin with 149587747 relations and 88308613 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:15:31 2009  reduce to 149587742 relations and 88293613 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:15:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:18:41 2009  removing 29222 relations and 14612 ideals in 14610 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:18:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:19:47 2009  begin with 149558520 relations and 88293613 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:22:19 2009  reduce to 149558517 relations and 88278998 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:22:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:25:30 2009  removing 28448 relations and 14224 ideals in 14224 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:25:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:26:35 2009  begin with 149530069 relations and 88278998 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:29:05 2009  reduce to 149530068 relations and 88264773 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:29:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:32:17 2009  removing 27564 relations and 13783 ideals in 13781 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:32:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:33:22 2009  begin with 149502504 relations and 88264773 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:35:53 2009  reduce to 149502499 relations and 88250985 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:35:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:39:04 2009  removing 26960 relations and 13481 ideals in 13479 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:39:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:40:08 2009  begin with 149475539 relations and 88250985 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:42:38 2009  reduce to 149475537 relations and 88237502 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:42:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:45:50 2009  removing 25991 relations and 12996 ideals in 12995 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:45:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:46:55 2009  begin with 149449546 relations and 88237502 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:48:09 2009  reduce to 149449546 relations and 88224506 ideals in 1 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:48:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:51:22 2009  removing 25416 relations and 12710 ideals in 12706 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:51:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:52:27 2009  begin with 149424130 relations and 88224506 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 05:53:41 2009  reduce to 149424130 relations and 88211796 ideals in 1 passes
Sun Jan 11 05:53:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 05:56:53 2009  removing 24533 relations and 12268 ideals in 12265 cliques
Sun Jan 11 05:56:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 05:57:58 2009  begin with 149399597 relations and 88211796 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:00:30 2009  reduce to 149399594 relations and 88199525 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:00:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:03:42 2009  removing 23667 relations and 11834 ideals in 11833 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:03:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:04:47 2009  begin with 149375927 relations and 88199525 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:07:18 2009  reduce to 149375924 relations and 88187688 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:07:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:10:26 2009  removing 23015 relations and 11508 ideals in 11507 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:10:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:11:30 2009  begin with 149352909 relations and 88187688 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:14:18 2009  reduce to 149352907 relations and 88176178 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:14:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:17:50 2009  removing 22518 relations and 11259 ideals in 11259 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:17:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:19:01 2009  begin with 149330389 relations and 88176178 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:21:43 2009  reduce to 149330388 relations and 88164918 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:21:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:25:13 2009  removing 21895 relations and 10949 ideals in 10946 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:25:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:26:24 2009  begin with 149308493 relations and 88164918 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:27:46 2009  reduce to 149308493 relations and 88153969 ideals in 1 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:27:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:30:57 2009  removing 21059 relations and 10530 ideals in 10529 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:31:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:32:00 2009  begin with 149287434 relations and 88153969 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:34:26 2009  reduce to 149287432 relations and 88143437 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:34:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:37:32 2009  removing 20201 relations and 10101 ideals in 10100 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:37:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:38:36 2009  begin with 149267231 relations and 88143437 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:41:02 2009  reduce to 149267229 relations and 88133334 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:41:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:44:10 2009  removing 19368 relations and 9684 ideals in 9684 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:44:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:45:15 2009  begin with 149247861 relations and 88133334 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:46:27 2009  reduce to 149247861 relations and 88123650 ideals in 1 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:46:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:49:36 2009  removing 18786 relations and 9393 ideals in 9393 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:49:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:50:41 2009  begin with 149229075 relations and 88123650 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:53:07 2009  reduce to 149229074 relations and 88114256 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:53:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 06:56:16 2009  removing 18332 relations and 9167 ideals in 9165 cliques
Sun Jan 11 06:56:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 06:57:21 2009  begin with 149210742 relations and 88114256 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 06:59:48 2009  reduce to 149210741 relations and 88105088 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 06:59:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 07:02:59 2009  removing 17923 relations and 8962 ideals in 8961 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:03:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:04:04 2009  begin with 149192818 relations and 88105088 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:06:36 2009  reduce to 149192817 relations and 88096125 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:06:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 07:09:47 2009  removing 17095 relations and 8548 ideals in 8547 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:09:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:10:52 2009  begin with 149175722 relations and 88096125 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:12:06 2009  reduce to 149175722 relations and 88087577 ideals in 1 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:12:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 07:15:17 2009  removing 16501 relations and 8251 ideals in 8250 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:15:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:16:22 2009  begin with 149159221 relations and 88087577 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:18:54 2009  reduce to 149159220 relations and 88079325 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:18:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 26
Sun Jan 11 07:22:06 2009  too much excess; switching to 3-cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:26:42 2009  removing 21573956 relations and 10588017 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:26:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:27:49 2009  begin with 127585264 relations and 88079325 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:32:00 2009  reduce to 127465491 relations and 77367641 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:32:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Jan 11 07:36:34 2009  removing 19227901 relations and 9594620 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:36:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:37:28 2009  begin with 108237590 relations and 77367641 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:40:44 2009  reduce to 108107248 relations and 67638142 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:40:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Jan 11 07:44:30 2009  removing 21442443 relations and 10914290 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:44:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:45:14 2009  begin with 86664805 relations and 67638142 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:48:18 2009  reduce to 86382005 relations and 56431859 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:48:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Jan 11 07:51:32 2009  removing 8494130 relations and 4317763 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:51:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:52:04 2009  begin with 77887875 relations and 56431859 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 07:54:40 2009  reduce to 77851124 relations and 52064117 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Jan 11 07:54:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Jan 11 07:57:43 2009  removing 3972582 relations and 1934191 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 07:57:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 07:58:10 2009  begin with 73878542 relations and 52064117 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:00:07 2009  reduce to 73869862 relations and 50131346 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:00:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Jan 11 08:03:05 2009  removing 2516120 relations and 1177129 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:03:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:03:31 2009  begin with 71353742 relations and 50131346 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:05:22 2009  reduce to 71348966 relations and 48978886 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:05:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Jan 11 08:08:17 2009  removing 1958588 relations and 872512 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:08:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:08:42 2009  begin with 69390378 relations and 48978886 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:10:30 2009  reduce to 69385380 relations and 48103606 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:10:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 11 08:13:24 2009  removing 1393364 relations and 581659 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:13:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:13:48 2009  begin with 67992016 relations and 48103606 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:15:33 2009  reduce to 67987395 relations and 47554342 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:15:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 11 08:18:26 2009  removing 1308895 relations and 496588 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:18:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:18:50 2009  begin with 66678500 relations and 47554342 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:21:23 2009  reduce to 66675217 relations and 47080196 ideals in 6 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:21:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 11 08:24:16 2009  removing 1241471 relations and 446913 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:24:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:24:39 2009  begin with 65433746 relations and 47080196 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:26:19 2009  reduce to 65432506 relations and 46644527 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:26:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Sun Jan 11 08:29:10 2009  removing 1159430 relations and 445796 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:29:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:29:33 2009  begin with 64273076 relations and 46644527 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:31:12 2009  reduce to 64271965 relations and 46221275 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:31:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Jan 11 08:34:01 2009  removing 877819 relations and 447085 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:34:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:34:23 2009  begin with 63394146 relations and 46221275 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:36:00 2009  reduce to 63391479 relations and 45791484 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:36:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Jan 11 08:38:47 2009  removing 213385 relations and 122703 ideals in 68261 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:38:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:39:08 2009  begin with 63178094 relations and 45791484 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:41:09 2009  reduce to 63175621 relations and 45694719 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:41:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Jan 11 08:43:56 2009  removing 24886 relations and 41941 ideals in 8439 cliques
Sun Jan 11 08:43:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 11 08:44:17 2009  begin with 63150735 relations and 45694719 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:45:05 2009  reduce to 63150729 relations and 45684408 ideals in 2 passes
Sun Jan 11 08:45:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 2289739
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 7653515
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 16838923
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 19800304
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 12364724
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 3505533
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 223548
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 474443
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  commencing 2-way merge
Sun Jan 11 08:50:01 2009  reduce to 59884660 relation sets and 42418202 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:50:01 2009  commencing full merge
Sun Jan 11 09:18:06 2009  memory use: 3253.5 MB
Sun Jan 11 09:18:37 2009  found 27075882 cycles, need 24606402
Sun Jan 11 09:19:09 2009  weight of 24606402 cycles is about 1722448921 (70.00/cycle)
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  1 relations: 3222769
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  2 relations: 3413803
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  3 relations: 3099507
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  4 relations: 2997426
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  5 relations: 2774391
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  6 relations: 2445930
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  7 relations: 2087881
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  8 relations: 1698997
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  9 relations: 1334918
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  10+ relations: 1530780
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  heaviest cycle: 13 relations
Sun Jan 11 09:19:19 2009  commencing cycle optimization
Sun Jan 11 10:06:15 2009  start with 115991635 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:37:28 2009  pruned 6367340 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:37:33 2009  memory use: 3585.7 MB
Sun Jan 11 10:37:34 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Jan 11 10:37:35 2009  1 relations: 3222769
Sun Jan 11 10:37:36 2009  2 relations: 3553277
Sun Jan 11 10:37:36 2009  3 relations: 3374994
Sun Jan 11 10:37:37 2009  4 relations: 3261535
Sun Jan 11 10:37:38 2009  5 relations: 3042048
Sun Jan 11 10:37:38 2009  6 relations: 2593020
Sun Jan 11 10:37:39 2009  7 relations: 2109167
Sun Jan 11 10:37:40 2009  8 relations: 1550805
Sun Jan 11 10:37:40 2009  9 relations: 1054148
Sun Jan 11 10:37:41 2009  10+ relations: 844639
Sun Jan 11 10:37:41 2009  heaviest cycle: 13 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:40:00 2009  elapsed time 159:28:45

bdodson · 2009-01-12, 18:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by frmky

A little better, at about 24.3M^2 once the matrix is created. I'll run it one last time with the number of relations Bruce used to see if we can get the 22.5M^2 matrix again.

Any chance this one is already lighter than the previous 22.5M^2?
Also, were the relns you're using for the re-run lighter than the ones from
the first 22.5M^2? That could affect both size and weight, along with
just the number of relns used. -Bruce
-----

Quote:

Code:

Sun Jan 11 08:45:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 2289739
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 7653515
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 16838923
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 19800304
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 12364724
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 3505533
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 223548
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 474443
Sun Jan 11 08:48:01 2009  commencing 2-way merge
Sun Jan 11 08:50:01 2009  reduce to 59884660 relation sets and 42418202 unique ideals
Sun Jan 11 08:50:01 2009  commencing full merge
Sun Jan 11 09:18:06 2009  memory use: 3253.5 MB
Sun Jan 11 09:18:37 2009  found 27075882 cycles, need 24606402
Sun Jan 11 09:19:09 2009  weight of 24606402 cycles is about 1722448921 (70.00/cycle)
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  1 relations: 3222769
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  2 relations: 3413803
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  3 relations: 3099507
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  4 relations: 2997426
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  5 relations: 2774391
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  6 relations: 2445930
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  7 relations: 2087881
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  8 relations: 1698997
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  9 relations: 1334918
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  10+ relations: 1530780
Sun Jan 11 09:19:12 2009  heaviest cycle: 13 relations
Sun Jan 11 09:19:19 2009  commencing cycle optimization
Sun Jan 11 10:06:15 2009  start with 115991635 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:37:28 2009  pruned 6367340 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:37:33 2009  memory use: 3585.7 MB
Sun Jan 11 10:37:34 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Jan 11 10:37:35 2009  1 relations: 3222769
Sun Jan 11 10:37:36 2009  2 relations: 3553277
Sun Jan 11 10:37:36 2009  3 relations: 3374994
Sun Jan 11 10:37:37 2009  4 relations: 3261535
Sun Jan 11 10:37:38 2009  5 relations: 3042048
Sun Jan 11 10:37:38 2009  6 relations: 2593020
Sun Jan 11 10:37:39 2009  7 relations: 2109167
Sun Jan 11 10:37:40 2009  8 relations: 1550805
Sun Jan 11 10:37:40 2009  9 relations: 1054148
Sun Jan 11 10:37:41 2009  10+ relations: 844639
Sun Jan 11 10:37:41 2009  heaviest cycle: 13 relations
Sun Jan 11 10:40:00 2009  elapsed time 159:28:45

frmky · 2009-01-20, 07:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by frmky

A little better, at about 24.3M^2 once the matrix is created. I'll run it one last time with the number of relations Bruce used to see if we can get the 22.5M^2 matrix again.

Nope, it came out about the same.

Code:

Sun Jan 18 09:47:37 2009  found 27044622 cycles, need 24627310

So I went back to the previous run to a matrix, but ran into a problem:

Code:

Sun Jan 18 12:34:21 2009  Msieve v. 1.39
Sun Jan 18 12:34:21 2009  random seeds: 23b7e611 86b19e2f
Sun Jan 18 12:34:21 2009  factoring 1523730872006476065948363676129458676149278444031460349472566973967334168144122839831601974268424799167249117433966350288390769855219490595979807225811317497929238722439950754301281289518517474506321086318238010563399750224881258591495613213552981037427691447296080033 (268 digits)
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  commencing number field sieve (268-digit input)
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  R0: -2854495385411919762116571938898990272765493248
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  R1:  1
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A0:  1
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A1:  0
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A2:  0
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A3:  0
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A4:  0
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A5:  0
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  A6:  4
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  skew 0.00, size 3.818099e-13, alpha 1.946683, combined = 2.189247e-13
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  
Sun Jan 18 12:34:25 2009  commencing linear algebra
Sun Jan 18 12:34:34 2009  read 24606402 cycles
Sun Jan 18 12:54:46 2009  cycles contain 58037592 unique relations
Sun Jan 18 13:19:42 2009  read 58037592 relations
Sun Jan 18 13:27:50 2009  using 20 quadratic characters above 4294964538
Sun Jan 18 13:37:12 2009  building initial matrix
Sun Jan 18 16:05:16 2009  memory use: 7761.9 MB
Sun Jan 18 16:06:08 2009  read 24606402 cycles
Sun Jan 18 16:07:02 2009  matrix is 24598147 x 24606402 (7040.5 MB) with weight 2036008452 (82.74/col)
Sun Jan 18 16:07:02 2009  sparse part has weight 1599566879 (65.01/col)
Sun Jan 18 16:54:08 2009  filtering completed in 2 passes
Sun Jan 18 16:54:30 2009  matrix is 24416631 x 23898128 (6995.3 MB) with weight 2028134081 (84.87/col)
Sun Jan 18 16:54:30 2009  sparse part has weight 1594806393 (66.73/col)
Sun Jan 18 17:00:14 2009  read 23898128 cycles
Sun Jan 18 17:01:07 2009  matrix is 24416631 x 23898128 (6995.3 MB) with weight 2028134081 (84.87/col)
Sun Jan 18 17:01:07 2009  sparse part has weight 1594806393 (66.73/col)
Sun Jan 18 17:01:09 2009  matrix must have more columns than rows

At this point, since it was about the same size anyway, I used the latest filtering run. Same result:

Code:

Sun Jan 18 20:13:45 2009  Msieve v. 1.39
Sun Jan 18 20:13:45 2009  random seeds: 8d0380b6 b720a60f
Sun Jan 18 20:13:45 2009  factoring 1523730872006476065948363676129458676149278444031460349472566973967334168144122839831601974268424799167249117433966350288390769855219490595979807225811317497929238722439950754301281289518517474506321086318238010563399750224881258591495613213552981037427691447296080033 (268 digits)
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  commencing number field sieve (268-digit input)
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  R0: -2854495385411919762116571938898990272765493248
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  R1:  1
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A0:  1
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A1:  0
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A2:  0
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A3:  0
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A4:  0
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A5:  0
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  A6:  4
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  skew 0.00, size 3.818099e-13, alpha 1.946683, combined = 2.189247e-13
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  
Sun Jan 18 20:13:49 2009  commencing linear algebra
Sun Jan 18 20:14:01 2009  read 24627310 cycles
Sun Jan 18 20:40:25 2009  cycles contain 58056072 unique relations
Sun Jan 18 21:05:36 2009  read 58056072 relations
Sun Jan 18 21:14:30 2009  using 20 quadratic characters above 4294964538
Sun Jan 18 21:23:55 2009  building initial matrix
Sun Jan 18 23:44:04 2009  memory use: 7764.9 MB
Sun Jan 18 23:44:50 2009  read 24627310 cycles
Sun Jan 18 23:45:36 2009  matrix is 24619102 x 24627310 (7048.4 MB) with weight 2038277225 (82.76/col)
Sun Jan 18 23:45:36 2009  sparse part has weight 1601427281 (65.03/col)
Mon Jan 19 00:28:10 2009  filtering completed in 2 passes
Mon Jan 19 00:28:29 2009  matrix is 24441824 x 23923546 (7003.9 MB) with weight 2030616664 (84.88/col)
Mon Jan 19 00:28:29 2009  sparse part has weight 1596801047 (66.75/col)
Mon Jan 19 00:33:26 2009  read 23923546 cycles
Mon Jan 19 00:34:13 2009  matrix is 24441824 x 23923546 (7003.9 MB) with weight 2030616664 (84.88/col)
Mon Jan 19 00:34:13 2009  sparse part has weight 1596801047 (66.75/col)
Mon Jan 19 00:34:15 2009  matrix must have more columns than rows

Both of these were filtered with 1.38. Should I try to build a matrix with 1.38?

jasonp · 2009-01-20, 15:14

My guess is that the matrix has too many columns that would be empty after the matrix was preprocessed. If that's true, then v1.38 would give you a usable matrix but the linear algebra would fail. The only solution would be to have more cycles when the filtering completed; you did, but the code throws them away because it has no clue how much excess the matrix would really need.

The easiest way to get those cycles back would be to run the filtering with a large value of NUM_EXTRA_RELATIONS in gnfs/gnfs.h, maybe 100000. Of course, the fact that you need such a huge amount of excess means the filtering did a crappy job to begin with.

Not sure what to do.

frmky · 2009-02-13, 19:59

Just realized that I forgot to post an update. I trimmed the total relations to just under 487M, effectively throwing the rest away, and ran with msieve 1.39. This produced the best matrix yet, 20.7M x 20.7M. At the current rate, the LA will require 2.5 months. The log is below:

Code:

Tue Jan 20 16:04:53 2009  Msieve v. 1.39
Tue Jan 20 16:04:53 2009  random seeds: e9515b86 4089e894
Tue Jan 20 16:04:53 2009  factoring 1523730872006476065948363676129458676149278444031460349472566973967334168144122839831601974268424799167249117433966350288390769855219490595979807225811317497929238722439950754301281289518517474506321086318238010563399750224881258591495613213552981037427691447296080033 (268 digits)
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  no P-1/P+1/ECM available, skipping
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  commencing number field sieve (268-digit input)
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  R0: -2854495385411919762116571938898990272765493248
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  R1:  1
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A0:  1
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A1:  0
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A2:  0
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A3:  0
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A4:  0
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A5:  0
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  A6:  4
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  skew 0.00, size 3.818099e-13, alpha 1.946683, combined = 2.189247e-13
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  commencing relation filtering
Tue Jan 20 16:04:58 2009  commencing duplicate removal, pass 1
Tue Jan 20 17:44:48 2009  found 47773505 hash collisions in 486972507 relations
Tue Jan 20 17:45:38 2009  added 1218925 free relations
Tue Jan 20 17:45:38 2009  commencing duplicate removal, pass 2
Tue Jan 20 18:16:00 2009  found 2880 duplicates and 488188552 unique relations
Tue Jan 20 18:16:00 2009  memory use: 2139.0 MB
Tue Jan 20 18:16:00 2009  reading rational ideals above 235995136
Tue Jan 20 18:16:00 2009  reading algebraic ideals above 235995136
Tue Jan 20 18:16:00 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 1
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 6052344
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 36553798
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 108707959
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 165126199
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 129269093
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 42339312
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 139847
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  488188552 relations and about 123754635 large ideals
Tue Jan 20 19:56:47 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 2
Tue Jan 20 21:37:15 2009  found 6379774 singletons
Tue Jan 20 21:37:15 2009  current dataset: 481808778 relations and about 117342794 large ideals
Tue Jan 20 21:37:15 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 3
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 6052344
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 36409305
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 107802515
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 162994964
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 127003416
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 41406387
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 139847
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  481808778 relations and about 190533243 large ideals
Tue Jan 20 23:17:58 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 4
Wed Jan 21 00:58:20 2009  found 21985964 singletons
Wed Jan 21 00:58:20 2009  current dataset: 459822814 relations and about 168156416 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 00:58:20 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 5
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 6052344
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 35894342
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 104621378
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 155609589
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 119256328
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 38248986
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 139847
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  459822814 relations and about 234051994 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 02:35:51 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 6
Wed Jan 21 04:13:16 2009  found 32433741 singletons
Wed Jan 21 04:13:16 2009  current dataset: 427389073 relations and about 200710740 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 04:13:16 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 7
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 6052344
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 35094902
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 99776787
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 144611633
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 107967291
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 33746269
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 0
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 139847
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  427389073 relations and about 240397259 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 05:45:17 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 8
Wed Jan 21 07:17:12 2009  found 23807991 singletons
Wed Jan 21 07:17:12 2009  current dataset: 403581082 relations and about 216069082 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 07:17:12 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 9
Wed Jan 21 08:44:21 2009  found 3077918 singletons
Wed Jan 21 08:44:21 2009  current dataset: 400503164 relations and about 212980793 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 08:44:21 2009  commencing singleton removal, pass 10
Wed Jan 21 10:10:42 2009  found 317509 singletons
Wed Jan 21 10:10:42 2009  current dataset: 400185655 relations and about 212663150 large ideals
Wed Jan 21 10:10:43 2009  commencing singleton removal, final pass
Wed Jan 21 19:34:28 2009  memory use: 7543.3 MB
Wed Jan 21 19:34:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Wed Jan 21 19:37:32 2009  begin with 400185655 relations and 241840291 unique ideals
Wed Jan 21 20:14:11 2009  reduce to 390223714 relations and 231810447 ideals in 10 passes
Wed Jan 21 20:14:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 42
Wed Jan 21 20:17:45 2009  reading rational ideals above 720000
Wed Jan 21 20:17:45 2009  reading algebraic ideals above 720000
Wed Jan 21 20:17:45 2009  commencing singleton removal, final pass
Fri Jan 23 16:48:24 2009  keeping 237603736 ideals with weight <= 20, new excess is 20111827
Fri Jan 23 17:11:29 2009  memory use: 9915.6 MB
Fri Jan 23 17:11:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 17:14:47 2009  begin with 390223714 relations and 237603736 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 17:30:18 2009  reduce to 390223674 relations and 237603696 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 23 17:30:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 17:44:28 2009  removing 2754733 relations and 2354733 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 17:44:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 17:47:58 2009  begin with 387468941 relations and 237603696 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 18:07:21 2009  reduce to 387461501 relations and 235241512 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 18:07:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 18:21:17 2009  removing 2189688 relations and 1789688 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 18:21:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 18:24:44 2009  begin with 385271813 relations and 235241512 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 18:43:59 2009  reduce to 385266277 relations and 233446279 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 18:43:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 18:57:48 2009  removing 1991867 relations and 1591867 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 18:58:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 19:01:11 2009  begin with 383274410 relations and 233446279 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 19:20:00 2009  reduce to 383269793 relations and 231849791 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 19:20:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 19:33:38 2009  removing 1872288 relations and 1472288 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 19:33:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 19:37:00 2009  begin with 381397505 relations and 231849791 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 19:55:37 2009  reduce to 381393624 relations and 230373615 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 19:55:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 20:09:09 2009  removing 1785119 relations and 1385119 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 20:09:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 20:12:30 2009  begin with 379608505 relations and 230373615 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 20:31:06 2009  reduce to 379604289 relations and 228984278 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 20:31:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 20:44:50 2009  removing 1717012 relations and 1317012 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 20:45:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 20:48:19 2009  begin with 377887277 relations and 228984278 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 21:06:58 2009  reduce to 377883816 relations and 227663803 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 21:06:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 21:20:23 2009  removing 1654587 relations and 1254587 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 21:20:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 21:23:42 2009  begin with 376229229 relations and 227663803 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 21:38:32 2009  reduce to 376225445 relations and 226405426 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 23 21:38:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 21:52:02 2009  removing 1620029 relations and 1220029 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 21:52:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 21:55:24 2009  begin with 374605416 relations and 226405426 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 22:13:56 2009  reduce to 374601718 relations and 225181698 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 22:13:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 22:27:24 2009  removing 1569987 relations and 1169987 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 22:27:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 22:30:45 2009  begin with 373031731 relations and 225181698 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 22:49:19 2009  reduce to 373028718 relations and 224008698 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 22:49:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 23:02:36 2009  removing 1551208 relations and 1151208 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 23:02:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 23:05:54 2009  begin with 371477510 relations and 224008698 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 23:23:57 2009  reduce to 371474972 relations and 222854950 ideals in 5 passes
Fri Jan 23 23:23:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Fri Jan 23 23:36:55 2009  removing 1516609 relations and 1116609 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 23 23:37:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 23 23:40:08 2009  begin with 369958363 relations and 222854950 unique ideals
Fri Jan 23 23:54:19 2009  reduce to 369955348 relations and 221735323 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 23 23:54:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 00:07:12 2009  removing 1502476 relations and 1102476 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 00:07:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 00:10:24 2009  begin with 368452872 relations and 221735323 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 00:24:35 2009  reduce to 368449964 relations and 220629935 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 00:24:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 00:37:24 2009  removing 1484224 relations and 1084224 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 00:37:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 00:40:34 2009  begin with 366965740 relations and 220629935 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 00:54:39 2009  reduce to 366962840 relations and 219542810 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 00:54:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 01:07:23 2009  removing 1426151 relations and 1026151 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 01:07:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 01:10:32 2009  begin with 365536689 relations and 219542810 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 01:24:34 2009  reduce to 365532790 relations and 218512758 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 01:24:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 01:37:12 2009  removing 1446739 relations and 1046739 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 01:37:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 01:40:21 2009  begin with 364086051 relations and 218512758 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 01:54:17 2009  reduce to 364084079 relations and 217464046 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 01:54:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 02:06:50 2009  removing 1397023 relations and 997023 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 02:07:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 02:09:58 2009  begin with 362687056 relations and 217464046 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 02:23:47 2009  reduce to 362684755 relations and 216464720 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 02:23:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 02:36:16 2009  removing 1375469 relations and 975469 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 02:36:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 02:39:22 2009  begin with 361309286 relations and 216464720 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 02:53:06 2009  reduce to 361306657 relations and 215486617 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 02:53:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 03:05:34 2009  removing 1341982 relations and 941982 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 03:05:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 03:08:40 2009  begin with 359964675 relations and 215486617 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 03:22:29 2009  reduce to 359961561 relations and 214541517 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 03:22:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 03:34:51 2009  removing 1367354 relations and 967354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 03:35:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 03:37:55 2009  begin with 358594207 relations and 214541517 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 03:51:33 2009  reduce to 358591582 relations and 213571534 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 03:51:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 04:03:54 2009  removing 1345167 relations and 945167 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 04:04:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 04:06:58 2009  begin with 357246415 relations and 213571534 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 04:20:34 2009  reduce to 357243768 relations and 212623718 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 04:20:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 04:32:50 2009  removing 1318750 relations and 918750 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 04:33:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 04:35:52 2009  begin with 355925018 relations and 212623718 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 04:49:22 2009  reduce to 355921980 relations and 211701927 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 04:49:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 05:01:37 2009  removing 1320788 relations and 920788 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 05:01:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 05:04:39 2009  begin with 354601192 relations and 211701927 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 05:18:05 2009  reduce to 354598154 relations and 210778097 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 05:18:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 05:30:15 2009  removing 1308352 relations and 908352 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 05:30:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 05:33:17 2009  begin with 353289802 relations and 210778097 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 05:46:44 2009  reduce to 353286665 relations and 209866605 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 05:46:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 05:58:53 2009  removing 1287484 relations and 887484 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 05:59:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 06:01:54 2009  begin with 351999181 relations and 209866605 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 06:15:20 2009  reduce to 351995696 relations and 208975630 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 06:15:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 06:27:25 2009  removing 1268029 relations and 868029 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 06:27:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 06:30:25 2009  begin with 350727667 relations and 208975630 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 06:43:41 2009  reduce to 350723798 relations and 208103723 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 06:43:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 06:55:42 2009  removing 1248248 relations and 848248 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 06:55:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 06:58:41 2009  begin with 349475550 relations and 208103723 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 07:11:55 2009  reduce to 349472426 relations and 207252347 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 07:11:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 07:23:57 2009  removing 1249258 relations and 849258 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 07:24:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 07:26:53 2009  begin with 348223168 relations and 207252347 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 07:43:22 2009  reduce to 348220669 relations and 206400582 ideals in 5 passes
Sat Jan 24 07:43:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 07:55:14 2009  removing 1223534 relations and 823534 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 07:55:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 07:58:10 2009  begin with 346997135 relations and 206400582 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 08:11:20 2009  reduce to 346994367 relations and 205574269 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 08:11:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 08:23:09 2009  removing 1237231 relations and 837231 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 08:23:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 08:26:06 2009  begin with 345757136 relations and 205574269 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 08:39:12 2009  reduce to 345754664 relations and 204734560 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 08:39:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 08:51:01 2009  removing 1218904 relations and 818904 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 08:51:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 08:53:56 2009  begin with 344535760 relations and 204734560 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 09:07:03 2009  reduce to 344533047 relations and 203912936 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 09:07:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 09:18:44 2009  removing 1217685 relations and 817685 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 09:19:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 09:21:40 2009  begin with 343315362 relations and 203912936 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 09:34:38 2009  reduce to 343312798 relations and 203092685 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 09:34:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 09:46:21 2009  removing 1213610 relations and 813610 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 09:46:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 09:49:16 2009  begin with 342099188 relations and 203092685 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 10:02:11 2009  reduce to 342096638 relations and 202276521 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 10:02:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 10:13:51 2009  removing 1197330 relations and 797330 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 10:14:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 10:16:44 2009  begin with 340899308 relations and 202276521 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 10:29:37 2009  reduce to 340896462 relations and 201476341 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 10:29:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 10:41:13 2009  removing 1176639 relations and 776639 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 10:41:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 10:44:07 2009  begin with 339719823 relations and 201476341 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 10:57:00 2009  reduce to 339716639 relations and 200696510 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 10:57:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 11:08:36 2009  removing 1225715 relations and 825715 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 11:08:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 11:11:29 2009  begin with 338490924 relations and 200696510 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 11:24:17 2009  reduce to 338488748 relations and 199868614 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 11:24:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 11:35:38 2009  removing 1206601 relations and 806601 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 11:35:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 11:38:29 2009  begin with 337282147 relations and 199868614 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 11:51:01 2009  reduce to 337280076 relations and 199059937 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 11:51:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 12:02:21 2009  removing 1199947 relations and 799947 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 12:02:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 12:05:11 2009  begin with 336080129 relations and 199059937 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 12:17:45 2009  reduce to 336078028 relations and 198257885 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 12:17:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 12:29:03 2009  removing 1188171 relations and 788171 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 12:29:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 12:31:52 2009  begin with 334889857 relations and 198257885 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 12:41:13 2009  reduce to 334887516 relations and 197467370 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 12:41:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 12:52:27 2009  removing 1153057 relations and 753057 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 12:52:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 12:55:16 2009  begin with 333734459 relations and 197467370 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 13:07:43 2009  reduce to 333731494 relations and 196711338 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 13:07:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 13:18:56 2009  removing 1204208 relations and 804208 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 13:19:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 13:21:44 2009  begin with 332527286 relations and 196711338 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 13:31:05 2009  reduce to 332524999 relations and 195904833 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 13:31:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 13:42:15 2009  removing 1192854 relations and 792854 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 13:42:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 13:45:01 2009  begin with 331332145 relations and 195904833 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 13:57:21 2009  reduce to 331329802 relations and 195109628 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 13:57:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 14:08:31 2009  removing 1169980 relations and 769980 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 14:08:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 14:11:16 2009  begin with 330159822 relations and 195109628 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 14:20:30 2009  reduce to 330157201 relations and 194337016 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 14:20:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 14:31:26 2009  removing 1164358 relations and 764358 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 14:31:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 14:34:09 2009  begin with 328992843 relations and 194337016 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 14:46:15 2009  reduce to 328990075 relations and 193569880 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 14:46:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 14:57:07 2009  removing 1177820 relations and 777820 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 14:57:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 14:59:50 2009  begin with 327812255 relations and 193569880 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 15:11:56 2009  reduce to 327809485 relations and 192789279 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 15:11:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 15:22:47 2009  removing 1144188 relations and 744188 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 15:23:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 15:25:30 2009  begin with 326665297 relations and 192789279 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 15:37:30 2009  reduce to 326662158 relations and 192041946 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 15:37:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 15:48:20 2009  removing 1168686 relations and 768686 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 15:48:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 15:51:01 2009  begin with 325493472 relations and 192041946 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 16:02:59 2009  reduce to 325490431 relations and 191270204 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 16:02:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 16:13:44 2009  removing 1136776 relations and 736776 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 16:13:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 16:16:24 2009  begin with 324353655 relations and 191270204 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 16:28:19 2009  reduce to 324350257 relations and 190530018 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 16:28:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 16:39:00 2009  removing 1132555 relations and 732555 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 16:39:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 16:41:40 2009  begin with 323217702 relations and 190530018 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 16:53:30 2009  reduce to 323214020 relations and 189793760 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 16:53:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 17:04:08 2009  removing 1115973 relations and 715973 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 17:04:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 17:06:48 2009  begin with 322098047 relations and 189793760 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 17:15:37 2009  reduce to 322093954 relations and 189073675 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 17:15:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 17:26:14 2009  removing 1075510 relations and 675510 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 17:26:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 17:28:53 2009  begin with 321018444 relations and 189073675 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 17:40:38 2009  reduce to 321013407 relations and 188393095 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 17:40:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 17:51:12 2009  removing 1183386 relations and 783386 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 17:51:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 17:53:50 2009  begin with 319830021 relations and 188393095 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 18:05:34 2009  reduce to 319827700 relations and 187607361 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 18:05:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 18:16:09 2009  removing 1133039 relations and 733039 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 18:16:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 18:18:48 2009  begin with 318694661 relations and 187607361 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 18:27:38 2009  reduce to 318692313 relations and 186871954 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 18:27:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 18:38:07 2009  removing 1121333 relations and 721333 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 18:38:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 18:40:45 2009  begin with 317570980 relations and 186871954 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 18:49:28 2009  reduce to 317568518 relations and 186148141 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 18:49:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 19:00:00 2009  removing 1097662 relations and 697662 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 19:00:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 19:02:38 2009  begin with 316470856 relations and 186148141 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 19:14:20 2009  reduce to 316468279 relations and 185447887 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 19:14:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 19:24:40 2009  removing 1049420 relations and 649420 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 19:24:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 19:27:17 2009  begin with 315418859 relations and 185447887 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 19:38:42 2009  reduce to 315415508 relations and 184795100 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 19:38:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 19:49:05 2009  removing 1143325 relations and 743325 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 19:49:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 19:51:38 2009  begin with 314272183 relations and 184795100 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 20:00:10 2009  reduce to 314269772 relations and 184049347 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 20:00:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 20:10:23 2009  removing 1109354 relations and 709354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 20:10:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 20:12:56 2009  begin with 313160418 relations and 184049347 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 20:21:26 2009  reduce to 313158376 relations and 183337933 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 20:21:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 20:31:36 2009  removing 1081593 relations and 681593 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 20:31:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 20:34:07 2009  begin with 312076783 relations and 183337933 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 20:42:36 2009  reduce to 312074425 relations and 182653964 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 20:42:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 20:52:42 2009  removing 1075596 relations and 675596 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 20:52:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 20:55:15 2009  begin with 310998829 relations and 182653964 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 21:03:39 2009  reduce to 310996342 relations and 181975874 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 21:03:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 21:13:41 2009  removing 1100257 relations and 700257 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 21:13:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 21:16:13 2009  begin with 309896085 relations and 181975874 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 21:27:24 2009  reduce to 309893839 relations and 181273353 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 21:27:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 21:37:24 2009  removing 1062891 relations and 662891 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 21:37:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 21:39:54 2009  begin with 308830948 relations and 181273353 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 21:48:14 2009  reduce to 308828313 relations and 180607812 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 21:48:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 21:58:12 2009  removing 1079880 relations and 679880 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 21:58:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 22:00:41 2009  begin with 307748433 relations and 180607812 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 22:08:51 2009  reduce to 307746088 relations and 179925575 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 22:08:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 22:18:46 2009  removing 1059149 relations and 659149 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 22:19:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 22:21:15 2009  begin with 306686939 relations and 179925575 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 22:32:16 2009  reduce to 306684250 relations and 179263727 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 22:32:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 22:42:10 2009  removing 1061859 relations and 661859 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 22:42:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 22:44:39 2009  begin with 305622391 relations and 179263727 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 22:52:54 2009  reduce to 305619796 relations and 178599262 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 22:52:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 23:02:45 2009  removing 1042123 relations and 642123 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 23:02:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 23:05:13 2009  begin with 304577673 relations and 178599262 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 23:13:28 2009  reduce to 304574625 relations and 177954083 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 23:13:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 23:23:14 2009  removing 1039876 relations and 639876 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 23:23:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 23:25:40 2009  begin with 303534749 relations and 177954083 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 23:36:46 2009  reduce to 303531615 relations and 177311060 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 24 23:36:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sat Jan 24 23:47:04 2009  removing 1023376 relations and 623376 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 24 23:47:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 24 23:49:39 2009  begin with 302508239 relations and 177311060 unique ideals
Sat Jan 24 23:58:15 2009  reduce to 302504676 relations and 176684112 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 24 23:58:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 00:08:29 2009  removing 1036317 relations and 636317 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 00:08:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 00:11:00 2009  begin with 301468359 relations and 176684112 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 00:19:33 2009  reduce to 301464932 relations and 176044351 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 00:19:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 00:29:42 2009  removing 1109206 relations and 709206 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 00:29:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 00:32:15 2009  begin with 300355726 relations and 176044351 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 00:40:48 2009  reduce to 300353637 relations and 175333053 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 00:40:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 00:50:54 2009  removing 1083725 relations and 683725 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 00:51:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 00:53:25 2009  begin with 299269912 relations and 175333053 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 01:01:55 2009  reduce to 299268171 relations and 174647583 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 01:01:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 01:12:00 2009  removing 1035843 relations and 635843 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 01:12:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 01:14:30 2009  begin with 298232328 relations and 174647583 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 01:22:56 2009  reduce to 298230020 relations and 174009424 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 01:22:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 01:32:57 2009  removing 1088278 relations and 688278 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 01:33:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 01:35:29 2009  begin with 297141742 relations and 174009424 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 01:43:55 2009  reduce to 297139843 relations and 173319239 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 01:43:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 01:53:54 2009  removing 1062055 relations and 662055 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 01:54:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 01:56:24 2009  begin with 296077788 relations and 173319239 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 02:04:48 2009  reduce to 296075675 relations and 172655062 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 02:04:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 02:14:42 2009  removing 1039963 relations and 639963 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 02:14:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 02:17:12 2009  begin with 295035712 relations and 172655062 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 02:25:33 2009  reduce to 295033322 relations and 172012701 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 02:25:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 02:35:23 2009  removing 1056284 relations and 656284 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 02:35:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 02:37:51 2009  begin with 293977038 relations and 172012701 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 02:48:55 2009  reduce to 293974562 relations and 171353928 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 02:48:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 02:58:46 2009  removing 1032403 relations and 632403 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 02:58:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 03:01:13 2009  begin with 292942159 relations and 171353928 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 03:09:28 2009  reduce to 292939328 relations and 170718680 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 03:09:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 03:19:13 2009  removing 1029452 relations and 629452 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 03:19:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 03:21:41 2009  begin with 291909876 relations and 170718680 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 03:32:38 2009  reduce to 291906765 relations and 170086104 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 03:32:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 03:42:21 2009  removing 1020136 relations and 620136 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 03:42:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 03:44:47 2009  begin with 290886629 relations and 170086104 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 03:52:57 2009  reduce to 290883392 relations and 169462709 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 03:52:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 04:02:38 2009  removing 1003726 relations and 603726 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 04:02:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 04:05:04 2009  begin with 289879666 relations and 169462709 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 04:15:58 2009  reduce to 289875985 relations and 168855283 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 04:15:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 04:25:40 2009  removing 1029438 relations and 629438 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 04:25:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 04:28:08 2009  begin with 288846547 relations and 168855283 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 04:36:19 2009  reduce to 288843064 relations and 168222340 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 04:36:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 04:45:57 2009  removing 1065100 relations and 665100 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 04:46:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 04:48:22 2009  begin with 287777964 relations and 168222340 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 04:56:30 2009  reduce to 287774933 relations and 167554173 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 04:56:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 05:06:04 2009  removing 1028709 relations and 628709 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 05:06:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 05:08:29 2009  begin with 286746224 relations and 167554173 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 05:16:33 2009  reduce to 286743272 relations and 166922490 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 05:16:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 05:26:06 2009  removing 1053663 relations and 653663 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 05:26:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 05:28:29 2009  begin with 285689609 relations and 166922490 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 05:36:34 2009  reduce to 285686811 relations and 166266006 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 05:36:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 05:46:04 2009  removing 1013020 relations and 613020 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 05:46:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 05:48:26 2009  begin with 284673791 relations and 166266006 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 05:56:26 2009  reduce to 284670413 relations and 165649583 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 05:56:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 06:05:53 2009  removing 1041925 relations and 641925 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 06:06:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 06:08:16 2009  begin with 283628488 relations and 165649583 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 06:16:13 2009  reduce to 283625128 relations and 165004277 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 06:16:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 06:25:37 2009  removing 1008462 relations and 608462 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 06:25:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 06:27:59 2009  begin with 282616666 relations and 165004277 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 06:35:54 2009  reduce to 282612998 relations and 164392122 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 06:35:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 06:45:16 2009  removing 1007375 relations and 607375 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 06:45:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 06:47:36 2009  begin with 281605623 relations and 164392122 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 06:58:04 2009  reduce to 281601441 relations and 163780529 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 06:58:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 07:07:18 2009  removing 989785 relations and 589785 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 07:07:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 07:09:39 2009  begin with 280611656 relations and 163780529 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 07:20:04 2009  reduce to 280606962 relations and 163186009 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 07:20:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 07:29:17 2009  removing 1032591 relations and 632591 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 07:29:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 07:31:34 2009  begin with 279574371 relations and 163186009 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 07:39:22 2009  reduce to 279570133 relations and 162549132 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 07:39:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 07:48:31 2009  removing 1022118 relations and 622118 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 07:48:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 07:50:49 2009  begin with 278548015 relations and 162549132 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 07:58:32 2009  reduce to 278543911 relations and 161922863 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 07:58:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 08:07:40 2009  removing 1022614 relations and 622614 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 08:07:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 08:09:56 2009  begin with 277521297 relations and 161922863 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 08:17:34 2009  reduce to 277517485 relations and 161296398 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 08:17:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 08:26:37 2009  removing 1005043 relations and 605043 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 08:26:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 08:28:53 2009  begin with 276512442 relations and 161296398 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 08:36:31 2009  reduce to 276507972 relations and 160686842 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 08:36:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 08:45:32 2009  removing 1002780 relations and 602780 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 08:45:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 08:47:47 2009  begin with 275505192 relations and 160686842 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 08:55:25 2009  reduce to 275500564 relations and 160079379 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 08:55:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 09:04:21 2009  removing 990145 relations and 590145 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 09:04:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 09:06:35 2009  begin with 274510419 relations and 160079379 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 09:14:06 2009  reduce to 274505091 relations and 159483855 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 09:14:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 09:23:00 2009  removing 985353 relations and 585353 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 09:23:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 09:25:14 2009  begin with 273519738 relations and 159483855 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 09:35:19 2009  reduce to 273514254 relations and 158892948 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 09:35:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 09:44:14 2009  removing 1019468 relations and 619468 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 09:44:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 09:46:28 2009  begin with 272494786 relations and 158892948 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 09:54:01 2009  reduce to 272489388 relations and 158268000 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 09:54:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 10:02:53 2009  removing 995411 relations and 595411 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 10:03:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 10:05:07 2009  begin with 271493977 relations and 158268000 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 10:15:04 2009  reduce to 271488814 relations and 157667343 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 10:15:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 10:23:54 2009  removing 990779 relations and 590779 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 10:24:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 10:26:07 2009  begin with 270498035 relations and 157667343 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 10:33:32 2009  reduce to 270492551 relations and 157071000 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 10:33:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 10:42:19 2009  removing 982109 relations and 582109 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 10:42:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 10:44:31 2009  begin with 269510442 relations and 157071000 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 10:51:56 2009  reduce to 269504442 relations and 156482807 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 10:51:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 11:00:40 2009  removing 985843 relations and 585843 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 11:00:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 11:02:52 2009  begin with 268518599 relations and 156482807 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 11:10:13 2009  reduce to 268512499 relations and 155890758 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 11:10:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 11:18:54 2009  removing 987628 relations and 587628 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 11:19:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 11:21:04 2009  begin with 267524871 relations and 155890758 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 11:28:23 2009  reduce to 267518501 relations and 155296648 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 11:28:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 11:37:02 2009  removing 979049 relations and 579049 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 11:37:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 11:39:13 2009  begin with 266539452 relations and 155296648 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 11:48:53 2009  reduce to 266533232 relations and 154711268 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 11:48:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 11:57:31 2009  removing 973251 relations and 573251 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 11:57:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 11:59:39 2009  begin with 265559981 relations and 154711268 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 12:06:55 2009  reduce to 265553274 relations and 154131199 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 12:06:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 12:15:29 2009  removing 977074 relations and 577074 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 12:15:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 12:17:37 2009  begin with 264576200 relations and 154131199 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 12:24:49 2009  reduce to 264569139 relations and 153546946 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 12:24:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 12:33:20 2009  removing 966958 relations and 566958 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 12:33:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 12:35:29 2009  begin with 263602181 relations and 153546946 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 12:45:02 2009  reduce to 263595150 relations and 152972825 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 12:45:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 12:53:31 2009  removing 967202 relations and 567202 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 12:53:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 12:55:37 2009  begin with 262627948 relations and 152972825 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 13:02:45 2009  reduce to 262620455 relations and 152398000 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 13:02:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 13:11:12 2009  removing 964043 relations and 564043 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 13:11:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 13:13:18 2009  begin with 261656412 relations and 152398000 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 13:22:45 2009  reduce to 261648869 relations and 151826270 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 13:22:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 13:31:10 2009  removing 959315 relations and 559315 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 13:31:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 13:33:16 2009  begin with 260689554 relations and 151826270 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 13:40:20 2009  reduce to 260681850 relations and 151259107 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 13:40:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 13:48:45 2009  removing 953918 relations and 553918 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 13:48:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 13:50:49 2009  begin with 259727932 relations and 151259107 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 13:57:53 2009  reduce to 259719928 relations and 150697031 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 13:57:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 14:06:14 2009  removing 947257 relations and 547257 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 14:06:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 14:08:19 2009  begin with 258772671 relations and 150697031 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 14:15:18 2009  reduce to 258764635 relations and 150141594 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 14:15:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 14:23:35 2009  removing 933321 relations and 533321 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 14:23:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 14:25:38 2009  begin with 257831314 relations and 150141594 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 14:32:36 2009  reduce to 257822982 relations and 149599783 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 14:32:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 14:40:49 2009  removing 935494 relations and 535494 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 14:41:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 14:42:54 2009  begin with 256887488 relations and 149599783 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 14:52:07 2009  reduce to 256878940 relations and 149055558 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 14:52:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 15:00:20 2009  removing 935003 relations and 535003 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 15:00:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 15:02:22 2009  begin with 255943937 relations and 149055558 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 15:11:34 2009  reduce to 255935635 relations and 148512067 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 15:11:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 15:19:45 2009  removing 933373 relations and 533373 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 15:19:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 15:21:47 2009  begin with 255002262 relations and 148512067 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 15:30:58 2009  reduce to 254993707 relations and 147969952 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 15:30:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 15:39:04 2009  removing 933164 relations and 533164 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 15:39:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 15:41:08 2009  begin with 254060543 relations and 147969952 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 15:47:59 2009  reduce to 254052233 relations and 147428299 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 15:47:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 15:55:59 2009  removing 931443 relations and 531443 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 15:56:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 15:58:00 2009  begin with 253120790 relations and 147428299 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 16:04:46 2009  reduce to 253112235 relations and 146888113 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 16:04:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 16:12:56 2009  removing 930733 relations and 530733 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 16:13:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 16:14:57 2009  begin with 252181502 relations and 146888113 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 16:23:55 2009  reduce to 252173053 relations and 146348733 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 16:23:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 16:31:54 2009  removing 930827 relations and 530827 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 16:32:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 16:33:52 2009  begin with 251242226 relations and 146348733 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 16:42:45 2009  reduce to 251233891 relations and 145809387 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 16:42:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 16:50:43 2009  removing 929297 relations and 529297 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 16:50:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 16:52:42 2009  begin with 250304594 relations and 145809387 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 16:59:25 2009  reduce to 250296188 relations and 145271496 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 16:59:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 17:07:20 2009  removing 928260 relations and 528260 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 17:07:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 17:09:20 2009  begin with 249367928 relations and 145271496 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 17:18:14 2009  reduce to 249359614 relations and 144734727 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 17:18:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 17:26:11 2009  removing 928185 relations and 528185 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 17:26:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 17:28:09 2009  begin with 248431429 relations and 144734727 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 17:36:59 2009  reduce to 248423284 relations and 144198225 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 17:36:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 17:44:46 2009  removing 926858 relations and 526858 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 17:44:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 17:46:45 2009  begin with 247496426 relations and 144198225 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 17:53:21 2009  reduce to 247487922 relations and 143662692 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 17:53:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 18:01:09 2009  removing 926902 relations and 526902 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 18:01:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 18:03:04 2009  begin with 246561020 relations and 143662692 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 18:09:34 2009  reduce to 246552530 relations and 143127127 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 18:09:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 18:17:24 2009  removing 925071 relations and 525071 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 18:17:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 18:19:18 2009  begin with 245627459 relations and 143127127 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 18:25:46 2009  reduce to 245619225 relations and 142593631 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 18:25:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 18:33:29 2009  removing 924924 relations and 524924 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 18:33:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 18:35:26 2009  begin with 244694301 relations and 142593631 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 18:44:01 2009  reduce to 244686015 relations and 142060257 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 18:44:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 18:51:45 2009  removing 923456 relations and 523456 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 18:51:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 18:53:39 2009  begin with 243762559 relations and 142060257 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 19:00:12 2009  reduce to 243754165 relations and 141528232 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 19:00:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 19:07:49 2009  removing 924992 relations and 524992 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 19:08:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 19:09:41 2009  begin with 242829173 relations and 141528232 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 19:16:03 2009  reduce to 242820954 relations and 140994815 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 19:16:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 19:23:45 2009  removing 923233 relations and 523233 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 19:23:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 19:25:38 2009  begin with 241897721 relations and 140994815 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 19:34:05 2009  reduce to 241889581 relations and 140463266 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 19:34:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 19:41:40 2009  removing 922065 relations and 522065 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 19:41:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 19:43:32 2009  begin with 240967516 relations and 140463266 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 19:49:54 2009  reduce to 240959553 relations and 139933064 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 19:49:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 19:57:30 2009  removing 921097 relations and 521097 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 19:57:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 19:59:24 2009  begin with 240038456 relations and 139933064 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 20:05:44 2009  reduce to 240030489 relations and 139403842 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 20:05:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 20:13:14 2009  removing 921142 relations and 521142 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 20:13:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 20:15:05 2009  begin with 239109347 relations and 139403842 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 20:21:23 2009  reduce to 239101319 relations and 138874502 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 20:21:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 20:28:51 2009  removing 921067 relations and 521067 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 20:29:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 20:30:44 2009  begin with 238180252 relations and 138874502 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 20:36:57 2009  reduce to 238172296 relations and 138345289 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 20:36:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 20:44:22 2009  removing 918205 relations and 518205 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 20:44:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 20:46:12 2009  begin with 237254091 relations and 138345289 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 20:54:27 2009  reduce to 237246023 relations and 137818859 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 20:54:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 21:01:47 2009  removing 919321 relations and 519321 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 21:01:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 21:03:38 2009  begin with 236326702 relations and 137818859 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 21:11:46 2009  reduce to 236318719 relations and 137291383 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 21:11:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 21:19:06 2009  removing 918330 relations and 518330 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 21:19:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 21:20:55 2009  begin with 235400389 relations and 137291383 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 21:29:04 2009  reduce to 235392406 relations and 136764891 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 21:29:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 21:36:24 2009  removing 918198 relations and 518198 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 21:36:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 21:38:13 2009  begin with 234474208 relations and 136764891 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 21:44:20 2009  reduce to 234466321 relations and 136238629 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 21:44:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 21:51:36 2009  removing 917099 relations and 517099 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 21:51:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 21:53:25 2009  begin with 233549222 relations and 136238629 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 21:59:31 2009  reduce to 233541396 relations and 135713523 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 21:59:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 22:06:51 2009  removing 916081 relations and 516081 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 22:07:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 22:08:38 2009  begin with 232625315 relations and 135713523 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 22:14:43 2009  reduce to 232617476 relations and 135189421 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 22:14:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 22:21:58 2009  removing 915827 relations and 515827 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 22:22:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 22:23:46 2009  begin with 231701649 relations and 135189421 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 22:31:48 2009  reduce to 231693802 relations and 134665594 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 22:31:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 22:39:00 2009  removing 914383 relations and 514383 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 22:39:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 22:40:48 2009  begin with 230779419 relations and 134665594 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 22:48:47 2009  reduce to 230771446 relations and 134143063 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 22:48:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 22:55:57 2009  removing 913939 relations and 513939 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 22:56:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 22:57:43 2009  begin with 229857507 relations and 134143063 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 23:03:37 2009  reduce to 229849561 relations and 133621018 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 23:03:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 23:10:45 2009  removing 915127 relations and 515127 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 23:10:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 23:12:30 2009  begin with 228934434 relations and 133621018 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 23:18:24 2009  reduce to 228926672 relations and 133097930 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Jan 25 23:18:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 23:25:26 2009  removing 914474 relations and 514474 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 23:25:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 23:27:10 2009  begin with 228012198 relations and 133097930 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 23:34:56 2009  reduce to 228004168 relations and 132575253 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 23:34:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 23:41:56 2009  removing 912415 relations and 512415 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 23:42:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Jan 25 23:43:39 2009  begin with 227091753 relations and 132575253 unique ideals
Sun Jan 25 23:51:23 2009  reduce to 227083868 relations and 132054791 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Jan 25 23:51:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Jan 25 23:58:21 2009  removing 912975 relations and 512975 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Jan 25 23:58:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 00:00:03 2009  begin with 226170893 relations and 132054791 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 00:07:46 2009  reduce to 226163001 relations and 131533744 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 00:07:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 00:14:41 2009  removing 911970 relations and 511970 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 00:14:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 00:16:22 2009  begin with 225251031 relations and 131533744 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 00:24:04 2009  reduce to 225243025 relations and 131013599 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 00:24:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 00:30:58 2009  removing 911201 relations and 511201 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 00:31:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 00:32:42 2009  begin with 224331824 relations and 131013599 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 00:38:29 2009  reduce to 224323900 relations and 130494299 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 00:38:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 00:45:24 2009  removing 910603 relations and 510603 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 00:45:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 00:47:05 2009  begin with 223413297 relations and 130494299 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 00:52:47 2009  reduce to 223405411 relations and 129975635 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 00:52:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 00:59:42 2009  removing 911040 relations and 511040 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 00:59:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 01:01:25 2009  begin with 222494371 relations and 129975635 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 01:07:09 2009  reduce to 222486655 relations and 129456714 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 01:07:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 01:13:59 2009  removing 909456 relations and 509456 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 01:14:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 01:15:40 2009  begin with 221577199 relations and 129456714 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 01:23:13 2009  reduce to 221569262 relations and 128939140 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 01:23:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 01:30:01 2009  removing 909508 relations and 509508 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 01:30:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 01:31:41 2009  begin with 220659754 relations and 128939140 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 01:37:19 2009  reduce to 220651936 relations and 128421655 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 01:37:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 01:44:02 2009  removing 907838 relations and 507838 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 01:44:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 01:45:42 2009  begin with 219744098 relations and 128421655 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 01:51:18 2009  reduce to 219736279 relations and 127905822 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 01:51:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 01:58:01 2009  removing 907638 relations and 507638 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 01:58:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 01:59:40 2009  begin with 218828641 relations and 127905822 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 02:05:15 2009  reduce to 218820905 relations and 127390268 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 02:05:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 02:11:58 2009  removing 907641 relations and 507641 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 02:12:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 02:13:37 2009  begin with 217913264 relations and 127390268 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 02:20:59 2009  reduce to 217905323 relations and 126874505 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 02:20:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 02:27:38 2009  removing 907598 relations and 507598 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 02:27:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 02:29:16 2009  begin with 216997725 relations and 126874505 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 02:34:46 2009  reduce to 216989761 relations and 126358758 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 02:34:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 02:41:22 2009  removing 907144 relations and 507144 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 02:41:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 02:42:59 2009  begin with 216082617 relations and 126358758 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 02:50:17 2009  reduce to 216074651 relations and 125843467 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 02:50:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 02:56:50 2009  removing 906621 relations and 506621 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 02:57:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 02:58:28 2009  begin with 215168030 relations and 125843467 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 03:03:55 2009  reduce to 215160188 relations and 125328830 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 03:03:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 03:10:24 2009  removing 905798 relations and 505798 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 03:10:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 03:12:00 2009  begin with 214254390 relations and 125328830 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 03:19:12 2009  reduce to 214246599 relations and 124815071 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 03:19:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 03:25:41 2009  removing 905196 relations and 505196 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 03:25:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 03:27:16 2009  begin with 213341403 relations and 124815071 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 03:34:24 2009  reduce to 213333583 relations and 124301887 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 03:34:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 03:40:50 2009  removing 904639 relations and 504639 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 03:41:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 03:42:26 2009  begin with 212428944 relations and 124301887 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 03:47:46 2009  reduce to 212421127 relations and 123789249 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 03:47:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 03:54:11 2009  removing 904497 relations and 504497 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 03:54:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 03:55:45 2009  begin with 211516630 relations and 123789249 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 04:02:50 2009  reduce to 211508722 relations and 123276672 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 04:02:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 04:09:15 2009  removing 903489 relations and 503489 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 04:09:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 04:10:48 2009  begin with 210605233 relations and 123276672 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 04:16:02 2009  reduce to 210597378 relations and 122765163 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 04:16:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 04:22:24 2009  removing 902824 relations and 502824 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 04:22:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 04:23:57 2009  begin with 209694554 relations and 122765163 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 04:30:55 2009  reduce to 209686536 relations and 122254136 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 04:30:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 04:37:17 2009  removing 902880 relations and 502880 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 04:37:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 04:38:50 2009  begin with 208783656 relations and 122254136 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 04:45:48 2009  reduce to 208775783 relations and 121743229 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 04:45:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 04:52:04 2009  removing 902661 relations and 502661 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 04:52:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 04:53:36 2009  begin with 207873122 relations and 121743229 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 04:58:46 2009  reduce to 207865114 relations and 121232385 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 04:58:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 05:05:01 2009  removing 902156 relations and 502156 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 05:05:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 05:06:32 2009  begin with 206962958 relations and 121232385 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 05:11:43 2009  reduce to 206955153 relations and 120722241 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 05:11:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 05:17:54 2009  removing 902022 relations and 502022 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 05:18:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 05:19:26 2009  begin with 206053131 relations and 120722241 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 05:26:17 2009  reduce to 206045336 relations and 120212248 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 05:26:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 05:32:27 2009  removing 900850 relations and 500850 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 05:32:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 05:33:58 2009  begin with 205144486 relations and 120212248 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 05:39:03 2009  reduce to 205136485 relations and 119703231 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 05:39:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 05:45:12 2009  removing 900572 relations and 500572 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 05:45:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 05:46:41 2009  begin with 204235913 relations and 119703231 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 05:51:44 2009  reduce to 204227800 relations and 119194361 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 05:51:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 05:57:52 2009  removing 900692 relations and 500692 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 05:58:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 05:59:21 2009  begin with 203327108 relations and 119194361 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 06:04:26 2009  reduce to 203319170 relations and 118685555 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 06:04:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 06:10:28 2009  removing 900228 relations and 500228 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 06:10:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 06:11:58 2009  begin with 202418942 relations and 118685555 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 06:16:59 2009  reduce to 202410875 relations and 118177087 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 06:16:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 06:23:01 2009  removing 899613 relations and 499613 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 06:23:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 06:24:30 2009  begin with 201511262 relations and 118177087 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 06:29:28 2009  reduce to 201503220 relations and 117669239 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 06:29:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 06:35:26 2009  removing 898921 relations and 498921 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 06:35:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 06:36:53 2009  begin with 200604299 relations and 117669239 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 06:43:28 2009  reduce to 200596276 relations and 117162110 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 06:43:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 06:49:24 2009  removing 898694 relations and 498694 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 06:49:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 06:50:51 2009  begin with 199697582 relations and 117162110 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 06:55:46 2009  reduce to 199689582 relations and 116655240 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 06:55:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 07:01:42 2009  removing 898980 relations and 498980 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 07:01:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 07:03:08 2009  begin with 198790602 relations and 116655240 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 07:08:01 2009  reduce to 198782439 relations and 116147921 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 07:08:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 07:13:53 2009  removing 897873 relations and 497873 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 07:14:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 07:15:19 2009  begin with 197884566 relations and 116147921 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 07:20:11 2009  reduce to 197876533 relations and 115641827 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 07:20:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 07:26:03 2009  removing 897662 relations and 497662 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 07:26:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 07:27:29 2009  begin with 196978871 relations and 115641827 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 07:33:54 2009  reduce to 196970852 relations and 115135940 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 07:33:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 07:39:41 2009  removing 897253 relations and 497253 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 07:39:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 07:41:05 2009  begin with 196073599 relations and 115135940 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 07:47:27 2009  reduce to 196065159 relations and 114630060 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 07:47:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 07:53:15 2009  removing 896579 relations and 496579 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 07:53:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 07:54:40 2009  begin with 195168580 relations and 114630060 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 08:01:00 2009  reduce to 195160454 relations and 114125191 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 08:01:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 08:06:46 2009  removing 896131 relations and 496131 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 08:06:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 08:08:11 2009  begin with 194264323 relations and 114125191 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 08:14:30 2009  reduce to 194256136 relations and 113620670 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 08:14:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 08:20:15 2009  removing 895778 relations and 495778 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 08:20:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 08:21:39 2009  begin with 193360358 relations and 113620670 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 08:26:22 2009  reduce to 193352354 relations and 113116686 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 08:26:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 08:32:04 2009  removing 895727 relations and 495727 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 08:32:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 08:33:27 2009  begin with 192456627 relations and 113116686 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 08:38:10 2009  reduce to 192448576 relations and 112612717 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 08:38:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 08:43:51 2009  removing 894883 relations and 494883 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 08:44:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 08:45:13 2009  begin with 191553693 relations and 112612717 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 08:49:54 2009  reduce to 191545258 relations and 112109216 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 08:49:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 08:55:31 2009  removing 895286 relations and 495286 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 08:55:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 08:56:53 2009  begin with 190649972 relations and 112109216 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 09:03:04 2009  reduce to 190641595 relations and 111605377 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 09:03:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 09:08:40 2009  removing 895092 relations and 495092 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 09:08:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 09:10:02 2009  begin with 189746503 relations and 111605377 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 09:14:37 2009  reduce to 189738072 relations and 111101655 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 09:14:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 09:20:10 2009  removing 894124 relations and 494124 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 09:20:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 09:21:32 2009  begin with 188843948 relations and 111101655 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 09:26:07 2009  reduce to 188835714 relations and 110599105 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 09:26:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 09:31:40 2009  removing 894285 relations and 494285 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 09:31:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 09:33:00 2009  begin with 187941429 relations and 110599105 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 09:39:04 2009  reduce to 187933492 relations and 110096705 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 09:39:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 09:44:34 2009  removing 893858 relations and 493858 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 09:44:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 09:45:54 2009  begin with 187039634 relations and 110096705 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 09:50:24 2009  reduce to 187031459 relations and 109594490 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 09:50:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 09:55:51 2009  removing 893595 relations and 493595 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 09:56:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 09:57:10 2009  begin with 186137864 relations and 109594490 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 10:03:08 2009  reduce to 186129441 relations and 109092288 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 10:03:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 10:08:34 2009  removing 892750 relations and 492750 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 10:08:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 10:09:53 2009  begin with 185236691 relations and 109092288 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 10:15:50 2009  reduce to 185228252 relations and 108590895 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 10:15:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 10:21:12 2009  removing 892944 relations and 492944 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 10:21:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 10:22:30 2009  begin with 184335308 relations and 108590895 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 10:26:54 2009  reduce to 184326877 relations and 108089302 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 10:26:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 10:32:15 2009  removing 892548 relations and 492548 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 10:32:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 10:33:33 2009  begin with 183434329 relations and 108089302 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 10:37:54 2009  reduce to 183425624 relations and 107587838 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 10:37:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 10:43:12 2009  removing 892004 relations and 492004 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 10:43:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 10:44:29 2009  begin with 182533620 relations and 107587838 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 10:48:50 2009  reduce to 182524886 relations and 107086891 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 10:48:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 10:54:07 2009  removing 891360 relations and 491360 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 10:54:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 10:55:23 2009  begin with 181633526 relations and 107086891 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:01:08 2009  reduce to 181624749 relations and 106586556 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:01:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 11:06:22 2009  removing 891385 relations and 491385 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 11:06:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 11:07:38 2009  begin with 180733364 relations and 106586556 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:11:56 2009  reduce to 180724296 relations and 106085869 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:11:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 11:17:09 2009  removing 890606 relations and 490606 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 11:17:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 11:18:25 2009  begin with 179833690 relations and 106085869 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:22:42 2009  reduce to 179824658 relations and 105586021 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:22:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 11:27:52 2009  removing 890994 relations and 490994 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 11:28:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 11:29:08 2009  begin with 178933664 relations and 105586021 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:34:47 2009  reduce to 178924682 relations and 105085794 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:34:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 11:39:56 2009  removing 890643 relations and 490643 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 11:40:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 11:41:11 2009  begin with 178034039 relations and 105085794 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:45:21 2009  reduce to 178024842 relations and 104585708 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:45:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 11:50:28 2009  removing 890334 relations and 490334 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 11:50:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 11:51:42 2009  begin with 177134508 relations and 104585708 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 11:57:15 2009  reduce to 177125098 relations and 104085708 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 11:57:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:02:20 2009  removing 890071 relations and 490071 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:02:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:03:33 2009  begin with 176235027 relations and 104085708 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 12:09:04 2009  reduce to 176225593 relations and 103585956 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 12:09:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:14:06 2009  removing 889117 relations and 489117 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:14:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:15:19 2009  begin with 175336476 relations and 103585956 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 12:20:48 2009  reduce to 175327098 relations and 103087216 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 12:20:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:25:48 2009  removing 890347 relations and 490347 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:25:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:27:01 2009  begin with 174436751 relations and 103087216 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 12:31:05 2009  reduce to 174427226 relations and 102587111 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 12:31:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:36:02 2009  removing 890327 relations and 490327 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:36:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:37:14 2009  begin with 173536899 relations and 102587111 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 12:41:17 2009  reduce to 173527163 relations and 102086798 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 12:41:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:46:13 2009  removing 889551 relations and 489551 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:46:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:47:25 2009  begin with 172637612 relations and 102086798 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 12:51:27 2009  reduce to 172628034 relations and 101587392 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 12:51:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 12:56:21 2009  removing 889705 relations and 489705 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 12:56:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 12:57:31 2009  begin with 171738329 relations and 101587392 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:01:32 2009  reduce to 171728627 relations and 101087739 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:01:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:06:27 2009  removing 889038 relations and 489038 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:06:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:07:37 2009  begin with 170839589 relations and 101087739 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:11:36 2009  reduce to 170829641 relations and 100588488 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:11:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:16:27 2009  removing 889177 relations and 489177 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:16:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:17:36 2009  begin with 169940464 relations and 100588488 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:22:50 2009  reduce to 169930328 relations and 100088895 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:22:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:27:37 2009  removing 889026 relations and 489026 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:27:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:28:46 2009  begin with 169041302 relations and 100088895 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:32:41 2009  reduce to 169031413 relations and 99589696 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:32:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:37:26 2009  removing 889113 relations and 489113 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:37:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:38:36 2009  begin with 168142300 relations and 99589696 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:42:28 2009  reduce to 168131925 relations and 99089923 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:42:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:47:14 2009  removing 888850 relations and 488850 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:47:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:48:23 2009  begin with 167243075 relations and 99089923 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 13:53:31 2009  reduce to 167232740 relations and 98590456 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 13:53:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 13:58:14 2009  removing 888500 relations and 488500 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 13:58:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 13:59:22 2009  begin with 166344240 relations and 98590456 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:04:28 2009  reduce to 166333859 relations and 98091284 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:04:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:09:08 2009  removing 888593 relations and 488593 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:09:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:10:14 2009  begin with 165445266 relations and 98091284 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:14:01 2009  reduce to 165434979 relations and 97592086 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:14:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:18:37 2009  removing 888463 relations and 488463 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:18:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:19:44 2009  begin with 164546516 relations and 97592086 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:23:31 2009  reduce to 164535900 relations and 97092704 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:23:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:28:09 2009  removing 888256 relations and 488256 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:28:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:29:15 2009  begin with 163647644 relations and 97092704 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:33:00 2009  reduce to 163637019 relations and 96593511 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:33:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:37:34 2009  removing 888750 relations and 488750 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:37:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:38:40 2009  begin with 162748269 relations and 96593511 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:43:36 2009  reduce to 162737702 relations and 96093900 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:43:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:48:08 2009  removing 888329 relations and 488329 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:48:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:49:14 2009  begin with 161849373 relations and 96093900 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 14:52:55 2009  reduce to 161838502 relations and 95594375 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 14:52:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 14:57:26 2009  removing 888665 relations and 488665 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 14:57:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 14:58:32 2009  begin with 160949837 relations and 95594375 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:03:25 2009  reduce to 160938917 relations and 95094451 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:03:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:07:54 2009  removing 888144 relations and 488144 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:08:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:08:58 2009  begin with 160050773 relations and 95094451 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:12:37 2009  reduce to 160039808 relations and 94595012 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:12:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:17:04 2009  removing 888224 relations and 488224 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:17:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:18:08 2009  begin with 159151584 relations and 94595012 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:22:59 2009  reduce to 159140477 relations and 94095376 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:22:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:27:25 2009  removing 888188 relations and 488188 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:27:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:28:28 2009  begin with 158252289 relations and 94095376 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:33:14 2009  reduce to 158241194 relations and 93595761 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:33:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:37:38 2009  removing 888954 relations and 488954 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:37:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:38:41 2009  begin with 157352240 relations and 93595761 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:43:25 2009  reduce to 157341061 relations and 93095314 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:43:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:47:47 2009  removing 888819 relations and 488819 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:47:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:48:50 2009  begin with 156452242 relations and 93095314 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 15:52:23 2009  reduce to 156441180 relations and 92595098 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 15:52:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 15:56:41 2009  removing 888840 relations and 488840 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 15:56:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 15:57:44 2009  begin with 155552340 relations and 92595098 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:01:14 2009  reduce to 155540946 relations and 92094546 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:01:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:05:34 2009  removing 888851 relations and 488851 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:05:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:06:35 2009  begin with 154652095 relations and 92094546 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:10:04 2009  reduce to 154640811 relations and 91594105 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:10:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:14:21 2009  removing 889533 relations and 489533 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:14:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:15:24 2009  begin with 153751278 relations and 91594105 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:19:59 2009  reduce to 153740002 relations and 91093000 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:19:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:24:15 2009  removing 889754 relations and 489754 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:24:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:25:15 2009  begin with 152850248 relations and 91093000 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:28:42 2009  reduce to 152838804 relations and 90591481 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:28:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:32:55 2009  removing 889364 relations and 489364 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:33:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:33:56 2009  begin with 151949440 relations and 90591481 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:38:27 2009  reduce to 151937966 relations and 90090296 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:38:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:42:38 2009  removing 889694 relations and 489694 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:42:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:43:38 2009  begin with 151048272 relations and 90090296 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:47:00 2009  reduce to 151036659 relations and 89588631 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:47:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 16:51:12 2009  removing 890119 relations and 490119 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 16:51:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 16:52:11 2009  begin with 150146540 relations and 89588631 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 16:56:38 2009  reduce to 150135144 relations and 89086795 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 16:56:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 17:00:45 2009  removing 890717 relations and 490717 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:00:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:01:45 2009  begin with 149244427 relations and 89086795 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:05:05 2009  reduce to 149232885 relations and 88584209 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:05:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 17:09:11 2009  removing 889731 relations and 489731 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:09:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:10:09 2009  begin with 148343154 relations and 88584209 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:14:32 2009  reduce to 148331387 relations and 88082417 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:14:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Mon Jan 26 17:18:34 2009  removing 890841 relations and 490841 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:18:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:19:32 2009  begin with 147440546 relations and 88082417 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:23:52 2009  reduce to 147428887 relations and 87579591 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:23:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 17:27:52 2009  removing 891168 relations and 491168 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:27:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:28:48 2009  begin with 146537719 relations and 87579591 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:32:03 2009  reduce to 146526078 relations and 87076462 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:32:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 17:36:02 2009  removing 891193 relations and 491193 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:36:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:36:59 2009  begin with 145634885 relations and 87076462 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:41:14 2009  reduce to 145623138 relations and 86573219 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:41:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 17:45:13 2009  removing 891873 relations and 491873 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:45:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:46:10 2009  begin with 144731265 relations and 86573219 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:49:19 2009  reduce to 144719486 relations and 86069224 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:49:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 17:53:14 2009  removing 892177 relations and 492177 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 17:53:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 17:54:11 2009  begin with 143827309 relations and 86069224 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 17:58:21 2009  reduce to 143815551 relations and 85564990 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 17:58:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:02:16 2009  removing 892413 relations and 492413 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:02:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:03:11 2009  begin with 142923138 relations and 85564990 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:06:18 2009  reduce to 142911527 relations and 85060620 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:06:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:10:10 2009  removing 893171 relations and 493171 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:10:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:11:04 2009  begin with 142018356 relations and 85060620 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:14:08 2009  reduce to 142006776 relations and 84555542 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:14:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:17:58 2009  removing 893308 relations and 493308 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:18:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:18:52 2009  begin with 141113468 relations and 84555542 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:22:56 2009  reduce to 141101978 relations and 84050439 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:22:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:26:44 2009  removing 893781 relations and 493781 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:26:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:27:38 2009  begin with 140208197 relations and 84050439 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:30:41 2009  reduce to 140196661 relations and 83544825 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:30:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:34:28 2009  removing 894544 relations and 494544 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:34:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:35:22 2009  begin with 139302117 relations and 83544825 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:39:22 2009  reduce to 139290732 relations and 83038588 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:39:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:43:05 2009  removing 894709 relations and 494709 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:43:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:43:58 2009  begin with 138396023 relations and 83038588 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:47:56 2009  reduce to 138384446 relations and 82532022 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:47:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 18:51:39 2009  removing 894742 relations and 494742 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 18:51:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 18:52:31 2009  begin with 137489704 relations and 82532022 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 18:56:26 2009  reduce to 137478187 relations and 82025473 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 18:56:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:00:08 2009  removing 894927 relations and 494927 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:00:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:01:01 2009  begin with 136583260 relations and 82025473 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:03:56 2009  reduce to 136571765 relations and 81518731 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:03:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:07:35 2009  removing 896396 relations and 496396 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:07:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:08:27 2009  begin with 135675369 relations and 81518731 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:12:21 2009  reduce to 135663715 relations and 81010372 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:12:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:15:58 2009  removing 895982 relations and 495982 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:16:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:16:50 2009  begin with 134767733 relations and 81010372 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:20:38 2009  reduce to 134756042 relations and 80502375 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:20:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:24:14 2009  removing 897178 relations and 497178 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:24:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:25:06 2009  begin with 133858864 relations and 80502375 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:28:52 2009  reduce to 133847069 relations and 79993102 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:28:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:32:26 2009  removing 897189 relations and 497189 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:32:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:33:15 2009  begin with 132949880 relations and 79993102 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:37:02 2009  reduce to 132938117 relations and 79483833 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:37:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:40:34 2009  removing 897790 relations and 497790 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:40:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:41:24 2009  begin with 132040327 relations and 79483833 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:45:09 2009  reduce to 132028544 relations and 78973918 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:45:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:48:38 2009  removing 899072 relations and 499072 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:48:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:49:28 2009  begin with 131129472 relations and 78973918 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 19:52:14 2009  reduce to 131117794 relations and 78462866 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 19:52:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 19:55:44 2009  removing 898908 relations and 498908 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 19:55:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 19:56:33 2009  begin with 130218886 relations and 78462866 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:00:13 2009  reduce to 130207274 relations and 77952027 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:00:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:03:40 2009  removing 900070 relations and 500070 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:03:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:04:29 2009  begin with 129307204 relations and 77952027 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:07:12 2009  reduce to 129295385 relations and 77439825 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:07:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:10:37 2009  removing 900553 relations and 500553 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:10:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:11:25 2009  begin with 128394832 relations and 77439825 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:15:02 2009  reduce to 128382875 relations and 76927005 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:15:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:18:25 2009  removing 901501 relations and 501501 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:18:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:19:12 2009  begin with 127481374 relations and 76927005 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:22:46 2009  reduce to 127469576 relations and 76413398 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:22:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:26:07 2009  removing 901895 relations and 501895 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:26:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:26:54 2009  begin with 126567681 relations and 76413398 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:30:27 2009  reduce to 126555937 relations and 75899446 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:30:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:33:47 2009  removing 902419 relations and 502419 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:33:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:34:35 2009  begin with 125653518 relations and 75899446 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:37:13 2009  reduce to 125641774 relations and 75384968 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:37:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:40:31 2009  removing 902932 relations and 502932 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:40:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:41:18 2009  begin with 124738842 relations and 75384968 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:44:47 2009  reduce to 124726662 relations and 74869545 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:44:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:48:05 2009  removing 903947 relations and 503947 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:48:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:48:50 2009  begin with 123822715 relations and 74869545 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:52:15 2009  reduce to 123810573 relations and 74353141 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:52:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 20:55:29 2009  removing 904582 relations and 504582 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 20:55:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 20:56:15 2009  begin with 122905991 relations and 74353141 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 20:59:38 2009  reduce to 122894131 relations and 73836384 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 20:59:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:02:51 2009  removing 905915 relations and 505915 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:02:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:03:36 2009  begin with 121988216 relations and 73836384 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:06:07 2009  reduce to 121976015 relations and 73317929 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:06:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:09:18 2009  removing 906036 relations and 506036 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:09:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:10:02 2009  begin with 121069979 relations and 73317929 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:12:32 2009  reduce to 121057636 relations and 72799254 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:12:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:15:41 2009  removing 907642 relations and 507642 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:15:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:16:25 2009  begin with 120149994 relations and 72799254 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:19:40 2009  reduce to 120137686 relations and 72278960 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:19:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:22:44 2009  removing 907969 relations and 507969 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:22:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:23:28 2009  begin with 119229717 relations and 72278960 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:25:53 2009  reduce to 119217323 relations and 71758235 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:25:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:28:56 2009  removing 908970 relations and 508970 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:29:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:29:39 2009  begin with 118308353 relations and 71758235 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:32:03 2009  reduce to 118295681 relations and 71236259 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:32:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:35:04 2009  removing 910776 relations and 510776 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:35:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:35:46 2009  begin with 117384905 relations and 71236259 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:38:09 2009  reduce to 117372363 relations and 70712608 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:38:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:41:11 2009  removing 911051 relations and 511051 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:41:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:41:51 2009  begin with 116461312 relations and 70712608 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:44:59 2009  reduce to 116448565 relations and 70188454 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:44:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:47:57 2009  removing 911845 relations and 511845 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:48:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:48:39 2009  begin with 115536720 relations and 70188454 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:51:45 2009  reduce to 115523953 relations and 69663487 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:51:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 21:54:42 2009  removing 912818 relations and 512818 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 21:54:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 21:55:24 2009  begin with 114611135 relations and 69663487 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 21:58:27 2009  reduce to 114598524 relations and 69137716 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 21:58:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:01:24 2009  removing 913727 relations and 513727 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:01:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:02:05 2009  begin with 113684797 relations and 69137716 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:05:05 2009  reduce to 113672077 relations and 68610936 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:05:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:08:01 2009  removing 915433 relations and 515433 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:08:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:08:41 2009  begin with 112756644 relations and 68610936 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:11:39 2009  reduce to 112743374 relations and 68081909 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:11:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:14:33 2009  removing 916274 relations and 516274 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:14:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:15:12 2009  begin with 111827100 relations and 68081909 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:18:10 2009  reduce to 111813727 relations and 67551941 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:18:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:20:59 2009  removing 917627 relations and 517627 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:21:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:21:39 2009  begin with 110896100 relations and 67551941 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:24:34 2009  reduce to 110882729 relations and 67020621 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:24:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:27:23 2009  removing 918968 relations and 518968 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:27:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:28:03 2009  begin with 109963761 relations and 67020621 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:30:57 2009  reduce to 109950251 relations and 66487752 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:30:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Mon Jan 26 22:33:45 2009  removing 920170 relations and 520170 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:33:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:34:25 2009  begin with 109030081 relations and 66487752 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:37:17 2009  reduce to 109016387 relations and 65953530 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:37:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 22:40:03 2009  removing 921495 relations and 521495 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:40:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:40:41 2009  begin with 108094892 relations and 65953530 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:43:32 2009  reduce to 108080730 relations and 65417531 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:43:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 22:46:16 2009  removing 922701 relations and 522701 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:46:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:46:55 2009  begin with 107158029 relations and 65417531 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:49:42 2009  reduce to 107143936 relations and 64880383 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:49:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 22:52:26 2009  removing 924292 relations and 524292 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:52:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:53:05 2009  begin with 106219644 relations and 64880383 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 22:55:51 2009  reduce to 106205511 relations and 64341563 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 22:55:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 22:58:32 2009  removing 925354 relations and 525354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 22:58:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 22:59:09 2009  begin with 105280157 relations and 64341563 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:01:54 2009  reduce to 105265877 relations and 63801554 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:01:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:04:33 2009  removing 926655 relations and 526655 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:04:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:05:09 2009  begin with 104339222 relations and 63801554 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:07:52 2009  reduce to 104325221 relations and 63260472 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:07:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:10:31 2009  removing 929093 relations and 529093 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:10:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:11:06 2009  begin with 103396128 relations and 63260472 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:13:47 2009  reduce to 103381719 relations and 62716534 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:13:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:16:22 2009  removing 931082 relations and 531082 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:16:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:16:58 2009  begin with 102450637 relations and 62716534 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:19:36 2009  reduce to 102436154 relations and 62170578 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:19:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:22:11 2009  removing 931243 relations and 531243 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:22:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:22:45 2009  begin with 101504911 relations and 62170578 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:25:23 2009  reduce to 101490095 relations and 61624075 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:25:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:27:57 2009  removing 933516 relations and 533516 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:28:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:28:31 2009  begin with 100556579 relations and 61624075 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:31:06 2009  reduce to 100541541 relations and 61075113 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:31:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:33:39 2009  removing 935405 relations and 535405 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:33:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:34:13 2009  begin with 99606136 relations and 61075113 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:36:08 2009  reduce to 99591010 relations and 60524162 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:36:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Mon Jan 26 23:38:38 2009  removing 936602 relations and 536602 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:38:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:39:11 2009  begin with 98654408 relations and 60524162 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:41:41 2009  reduce to 98639216 relations and 59971948 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:41:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Mon Jan 26 23:44:10 2009  removing 938689 relations and 538689 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:44:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:44:44 2009  begin with 97700527 relations and 59971948 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:46:35 2009  reduce to 97685245 relations and 59417510 ideals in 3 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:46:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Mon Jan 26 23:49:02 2009  removing 940439 relations and 540439 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:49:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:49:35 2009  begin with 96744806 relations and 59417510 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:52:03 2009  reduce to 96728962 relations and 58860782 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:52:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Mon Jan 26 23:54:28 2009  removing 942440 relations and 542440 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:54:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Mon Jan 26 23:55:00 2009  begin with 95786522 relations and 58860782 unique ideals
Mon Jan 26 23:57:26 2009  reduce to 95770379 relations and 58301729 ideals in 4 passes
Mon Jan 26 23:57:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Mon Jan 26 23:59:49 2009  removing 943899 relations and 543899 ideals in 400000 cliques
Mon Jan 26 23:59:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:00:22 2009  begin with 94826480 relations and 58301729 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:02:44 2009  reduce to 94810239 relations and 57741106 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:02:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:05:06 2009  removing 946232 relations and 546232 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:05:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:05:38 2009  begin with 93864007 relations and 57741106 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:07:59 2009  reduce to 93847527 relations and 57177922 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:07:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:10:18 2009  removing 948751 relations and 548751 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:10:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:10:49 2009  begin with 92898776 relations and 57177922 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:13:09 2009  reduce to 92881744 relations and 56611647 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:13:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:15:28 2009  removing 950111 relations and 550111 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:15:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:15:58 2009  begin with 91931633 relations and 56611647 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:18:15 2009  reduce to 91914477 relations and 56043895 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:18:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:20:31 2009  removing 952766 relations and 552766 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:20:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:21:02 2009  begin with 90961711 relations and 56043895 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:23:18 2009  reduce to 90944320 relations and 55473271 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:23:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:25:32 2009  removing 955345 relations and 555345 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:25:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:26:03 2009  begin with 89988975 relations and 55473271 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:28:16 2009  reduce to 89971569 relations and 54899997 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:28:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:30:30 2009  removing 957699 relations and 557699 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:30:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:30:59 2009  begin with 89013870 relations and 54899997 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:33:11 2009  reduce to 88996167 relations and 54324046 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:33:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Tue Jan 27 00:35:22 2009  removing 959346 relations and 559346 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:35:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:35:52 2009  begin with 88036821 relations and 54324046 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:38:31 2009  reduce to 88018576 relations and 53745925 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:38:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 00:40:42 2009  removing 962269 relations and 562269 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:40:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:41:11 2009  begin with 87056307 relations and 53745925 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:43:18 2009  reduce to 87037790 relations and 53164598 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:43:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 00:45:26 2009  removing 964300 relations and 564300 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:45:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:45:54 2009  begin with 86073490 relations and 53164598 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:48:00 2009  reduce to 86054992 relations and 52581250 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:48:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 00:50:06 2009  removing 967560 relations and 567560 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:50:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:50:33 2009  begin with 85087432 relations and 52581250 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:52:39 2009  reduce to 85068886 relations and 51994600 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:52:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 00:54:44 2009  removing 968777 relations and 568777 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:54:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:55:12 2009  begin with 84100109 relations and 51994600 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 00:57:13 2009  reduce to 84081478 relations and 51406674 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 00:57:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 00:59:16 2009  removing 971002 relations and 571002 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 00:59:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 00:59:44 2009  begin with 83110476 relations and 51406674 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:01:45 2009  reduce to 83092205 relations and 50816880 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:01:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:03:47 2009  removing 973633 relations and 573633 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:03:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:04:15 2009  begin with 82118572 relations and 50816880 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:06:12 2009  reduce to 82100467 relations and 50224639 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:06:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:08:14 2009  removing 976894 relations and 576894 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:08:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:08:42 2009  begin with 81123573 relations and 50224639 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:10:37 2009  reduce to 81105399 relations and 49629115 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:10:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:12:36 2009  removing 978839 relations and 578839 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:12:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:13:02 2009  begin with 80126560 relations and 49629115 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:14:56 2009  reduce to 80108538 relations and 49031769 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:14:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:16:54 2009  removing 982274 relations and 582274 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:16:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:17:20 2009  begin with 79126264 relations and 49031769 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:19:12 2009  reduce to 79107981 relations and 48430738 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:19:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:21:09 2009  removing 983916 relations and 583916 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:21:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:21:34 2009  begin with 78124065 relations and 48430738 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:23:25 2009  reduce to 78105325 relations and 47827548 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:23:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:25:19 2009  removing 986361 relations and 586361 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:25:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:25:44 2009  begin with 77118964 relations and 47827548 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:27:32 2009  reduce to 77100340 relations and 47222045 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:27:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:29:25 2009  removing 989055 relations and 589055 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:29:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:29:49 2009  begin with 76111285 relations and 47222045 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:31:37 2009  reduce to 76092303 relations and 46613512 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:31:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:33:28 2009  removing 991723 relations and 591723 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:33:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:33:52 2009  begin with 75100580 relations and 46613512 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:36:04 2009  reduce to 75081704 relations and 46002421 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:36:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:37:52 2009  removing 993994 relations and 593994 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:37:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:38:16 2009  begin with 74087710 relations and 46002421 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:39:57 2009  reduce to 74068851 relations and 45389107 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:39:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:41:45 2009  removing 998167 relations and 598167 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:41:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:42:09 2009  begin with 73070684 relations and 45389107 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:44:15 2009  reduce to 73051464 relations and 44771302 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:44:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:46:00 2009  removing 1000423 relations and 600423 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:46:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:46:23 2009  begin with 72051041 relations and 44771302 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:48:03 2009  reduce to 72031468 relations and 44150828 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:48:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:49:48 2009  removing 1004174 relations and 604174 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:49:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:50:10 2009  begin with 71027294 relations and 44150828 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:51:47 2009  reduce to 71008278 relations and 43527168 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:51:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:53:30 2009  removing 1009080 relations and 609080 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:53:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:53:51 2009  begin with 69999198 relations and 43527168 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:55:25 2009  reduce to 69980385 relations and 42898867 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:55:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 01:57:04 2009  removing 1012549 relations and 612549 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 01:57:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 01:57:26 2009  begin with 68967836 relations and 42898867 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 01:59:00 2009  reduce to 68948389 relations and 42266451 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 01:59:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:00:40 2009  removing 1015332 relations and 615332 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:00:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:01:00 2009  begin with 67933057 relations and 42266451 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:02:31 2009  reduce to 67913490 relations and 41631104 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:02:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:04:09 2009  removing 1020012 relations and 620012 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:04:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:04:30 2009  begin with 66893478 relations and 41631104 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:05:59 2009  reduce to 66874082 relations and 40991294 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:05:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:07:35 2009  removing 1024128 relations and 624128 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:07:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:07:55 2009  begin with 65849954 relations and 40991294 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:09:44 2009  reduce to 65830950 relations and 40347777 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:09:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:11:18 2009  removing 1029496 relations and 629496 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:11:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:11:38 2009  begin with 64801454 relations and 40347777 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:13:04 2009  reduce to 64782435 relations and 39698880 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:13:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:14:36 2009  removing 1033722 relations and 633722 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:14:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:14:55 2009  begin with 63748713 relations and 39698880 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:16:19 2009  reduce to 63729660 relations and 39045747 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:16:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:17:50 2009  removing 1039909 relations and 639909 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:17:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:18:09 2009  begin with 62689751 relations and 39045747 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:19:32 2009  reduce to 62670720 relations and 38386474 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:19:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 16
Tue Jan 27 02:21:00 2009  removing 1044196 relations and 644196 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:21:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:21:19 2009  begin with 61626524 relations and 38386474 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:22:59 2009  reduce to 61606900 relations and 37722272 ideals in 5 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:22:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
Tue Jan 27 02:24:26 2009  removing 1049718 relations and 649718 ideals in 400000 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:24:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:24:45 2009  begin with 60557182 relations and 37722272 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:26:03 2009  reduce to 60537441 relations and 37052481 ideals in 4 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:26:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
Tue Jan 27 02:27:28 2009  removing 485956 relations and 330716 ideals in 155240 cliques
Tue Jan 27 02:27:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Tue Jan 27 02:27:46 2009  begin with 60051485 relations and 37052481 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:28:45 2009  reduce to 60049768 relations and 36720047 ideals in 3 passes
Tue Jan 27 02:28:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 15
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 3656775
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 14820211
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 22560584
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 14449667
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 4021398
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 466776
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 50334
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 24023
Tue Jan 27 02:29:05 2009  commencing 2-way merge
Tue Jan 27 02:30:50 2009  reduce to 47152923 relation sets and 23823202 unique ideals
Tue Jan 27 02:30:50 2009  commencing full merge
Tue Jan 27 02:45:51 2009  memory use: 2189.6 MB
Tue Jan 27 02:46:12 2009  found 25359525 cycles, need 22143402
Tue Jan 27 02:46:43 2009  weight of 22143402 cycles is about 1550521731 (70.02/cycle)
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  1 relations: 3730993
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  2 relations: 2475454
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  3 relations: 2589105
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  4 relations: 2555397
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  5 relations: 2510406
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  6 relations: 2286072
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  7 relations: 2015382
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  8 relations: 1691810
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  9 relations: 1285662
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  10+ relations: 1003121
Tue Jan 27 02:46:47 2009  heaviest cycle: 13 relations
Tue Jan 27 02:46:51 2009  matrix can improve, retrying
Tue Jan 27 02:47:44 2009  reading rational ideals above 720000
Tue Jan 27 02:47:44 2009  reading algebraic ideals above 720000
Tue Jan 27 02:47:44 2009  commencing singleton removal, final pass
Thu Jan 29 01:15:54 2009  keeping 242458404 ideals with weight <= 25, new excess is 15257159
Thu Jan 29 01:39:16 2009  memory use: 9915.6 MB
Thu Jan 29 01:39:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 01:42:57 2009  begin with 390223714 relations and 242458404 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 02:00:11 2009  reduce to 390223674 relations and 242458364 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 02:00:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 02:15:37 2009  removing 2754733 relations and 2354733 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 02:15:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 02:19:29 2009  begin with 387468941 relations and 242458364 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 02:40:53 2009  reduce to 387461501 relations and 240096180 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 02:40:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 02:56:15 2009  removing 2189688 relations and 1789688 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 02:56:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 03:00:04 2009  begin with 385271813 relations and 240096180 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 03:21:21 2009  reduce to 385266277 relations and 238300947 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 03:21:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 03:36:33 2009  removing 1991867 relations and 1591867 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 03:36:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 03:40:19 2009  begin with 383274410 relations and 238300947 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 04:01:18 2009  reduce to 383269793 relations and 236704459 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 04:01:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 04:16:26 2009  removing 1872288 relations and 1472288 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 04:16:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 04:20:13 2009  begin with 381397505 relations and 236704459 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 04:41:11 2009  reduce to 381393624 relations and 235228283 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 04:41:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 04:56:13 2009  removing 1785119 relations and 1385119 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 04:56:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 05:00:00 2009  begin with 379608505 relations and 235228283 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 05:20:49 2009  reduce to 379604289 relations and 233838946 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 05:20:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 05:35:50 2009  removing 1717012 relations and 1317012 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 05:36:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 05:39:35 2009  begin with 377887277 relations and 233838946 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 06:00:24 2009  reduce to 377883816 relations and 232518471 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 06:00:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 06:15:12 2009  removing 1654587 relations and 1254587 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 06:15:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 06:18:56 2009  begin with 376229229 relations and 232518471 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 06:35:24 2009  reduce to 376225445 relations and 231260094 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 06:35:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 06:50:06 2009  removing 1620029 relations and 1220029 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 06:50:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 06:53:47 2009  begin with 374605416 relations and 231260094 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 07:13:58 2009  reduce to 374601718 relations and 230036366 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 07:13:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 07:28:33 2009  removing 1569987 relations and 1169987 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 07:28:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 07:32:13 2009  begin with 373031731 relations and 230036366 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 07:52:41 2009  reduce to 373028718 relations and 228863366 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 07:52:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 08:07:10 2009  removing 1551213 relations and 1151213 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 08:07:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 08:10:52 2009  begin with 371477505 relations and 228863366 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 08:31:12 2009  reduce to 371474964 relations and 227709610 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 08:31:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 08:45:41 2009  removing 1516601 relations and 1116601 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 08:45:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 08:49:18 2009  begin with 369958363 relations and 227709610 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 09:05:20 2009  reduce to 369955348 relations and 226589991 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 09:05:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 09:19:43 2009  removing 1502480 relations and 1102480 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 09:20:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 09:23:20 2009  begin with 368452868 relations and 226589991 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 09:39:22 2009  reduce to 368449961 relations and 225484600 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 09:39:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 09:53:40 2009  removing 1484215 relations and 1084215 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 09:53:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 09:57:14 2009  begin with 366965746 relations and 225484600 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 10:13:06 2009  reduce to 366962846 relations and 224397484 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 10:13:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 10:27:20 2009  removing 1426162 relations and 1026162 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 10:27:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 10:30:55 2009  begin with 365536684 relations and 224397484 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 10:46:52 2009  reduce to 365532784 relations and 223367420 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 10:46:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 11:01:02 2009  removing 1446733 relations and 1046733 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 11:01:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 11:04:35 2009  begin with 364086051 relations and 223367420 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 11:20:10 2009  reduce to 364084078 relations and 222318713 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 11:20:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 11:34:14 2009  removing 1397020 relations and 997020 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 11:34:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 11:37:45 2009  begin with 362687058 relations and 222318713 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 11:53:26 2009  reduce to 362684757 relations and 221319390 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 11:53:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 12:07:24 2009  removing 1375462 relations and 975462 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 12:07:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 12:10:55 2009  begin with 361309295 relations and 221319390 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 12:26:39 2009  reduce to 361306670 relations and 220341298 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 12:26:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 12:40:33 2009  removing 1342014 relations and 942014 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 12:40:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 12:44:02 2009  begin with 359964656 relations and 220341298 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 12:59:37 2009  reduce to 359961535 relations and 219396159 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 12:59:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 13:13:26 2009  removing 1367335 relations and 967335 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 13:13:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 13:16:53 2009  begin with 358594200 relations and 219396159 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 13:32:25 2009  reduce to 358591576 relations and 218426196 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 13:32:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 13:46:16 2009  removing 1345154 relations and 945154 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 13:46:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 13:49:45 2009  begin with 357246422 relations and 218426196 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 14:05:11 2009  reduce to 357243776 relations and 217478394 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 14:05:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 14:18:53 2009  removing 1318758 relations and 918758 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 14:19:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 14:22:18 2009  begin with 355925018 relations and 217478394 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 14:37:45 2009  reduce to 355921981 relations and 216556596 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 14:37:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 14:51:20 2009  removing 1320781 relations and 920781 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 14:51:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 14:54:47 2009  begin with 354601200 relations and 216556596 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 15:10:03 2009  reduce to 354598162 relations and 215632773 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 15:10:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 15:23:38 2009  removing 1308353 relations and 908353 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 15:23:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 15:27:03 2009  begin with 353289809 relations and 215632773 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 15:42:14 2009  reduce to 353286670 relations and 214721278 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 15:42:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 15:55:43 2009  removing 1287494 relations and 887494 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 15:56:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 15:59:07 2009  begin with 351999176 relations and 214721278 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 16:14:07 2009  reduce to 351995692 relations and 213830294 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 16:14:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 16:27:35 2009  removing 1268020 relations and 868020 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 16:27:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 16:30:57 2009  begin with 350727672 relations and 213830294 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 16:46:07 2009  reduce to 350723801 relations and 212958394 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 16:46:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 16:59:34 2009  removing 1248264 relations and 848264 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 16:59:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 17:02:55 2009  begin with 349475537 relations and 212958394 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 17:17:58 2009  reduce to 349472417 relations and 212107006 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 17:17:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 17:31:18 2009  removing 1249266 relations and 849266 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 17:31:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 17:34:39 2009  begin with 348223151 relations and 212107006 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 17:53:18 2009  reduce to 348220647 relations and 211255228 ideals in 5 passes
Thu Jan 29 17:53:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 18:06:31 2009  removing 1223493 relations and 823493 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 18:06:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 18:09:52 2009  begin with 346997154 relations and 211255228 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 18:24:34 2009  reduce to 346994380 relations and 210428950 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 18:24:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 18:37:47 2009  removing 1237243 relations and 837243 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 18:38:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 18:41:05 2009  begin with 345757137 relations and 210428950 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 18:55:44 2009  reduce to 345754665 relations and 209589229 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 18:55:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 19:08:51 2009  removing 1218925 relations and 818925 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 19:09:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 19:12:10 2009  begin with 344535740 relations and 209589229 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 19:26:54 2009  reduce to 344533026 relations and 208767583 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 19:26:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 19:39:59 2009  removing 1217665 relations and 817665 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 19:40:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 19:43:17 2009  begin with 343315361 relations and 208767583 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 19:58:00 2009  reduce to 343312800 relations and 207947355 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 19:58:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 20:10:59 2009  removing 1213612 relations and 813612 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 20:11:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 20:14:17 2009  begin with 342099188 relations and 207947355 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 20:28:51 2009  reduce to 342096638 relations and 207131189 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 20:28:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 20:41:47 2009  removing 1197336 relations and 797336 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 20:42:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 20:45:03 2009  begin with 340899302 relations and 207131189 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 20:59:30 2009  reduce to 340896456 relations and 206331003 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 20:59:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 21:12:20 2009  removing 1176634 relations and 776634 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 21:12:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 21:15:34 2009  begin with 339719822 relations and 206331003 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 21:30:05 2009  reduce to 339716634 relations and 205551173 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 21:30:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 21:42:48 2009  removing 1225714 relations and 825714 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 21:43:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 21:45:59 2009  begin with 338490920 relations and 205551173 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 22:00:21 2009  reduce to 338488744 relations and 204723278 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 22:00:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 22:13:03 2009  removing 1206589 relations and 806589 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 22:13:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 22:16:14 2009  begin with 337282155 relations and 204723278 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 22:30:35 2009  reduce to 337280083 relations and 203914612 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 22:30:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 22:43:17 2009  removing 1199953 relations and 799953 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 22:43:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 22:46:29 2009  begin with 336080130 relations and 203914612 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 23:00:48 2009  reduce to 336078031 relations and 203112556 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 23:00:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 23:13:29 2009  removing 1188177 relations and 788177 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 23:13:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 23:16:39 2009  begin with 334889854 relations and 203112556 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 23:27:21 2009  reduce to 334887515 relations and 202322037 ideals in 3 passes
Thu Jan 29 23:27:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Thu Jan 29 23:39:55 2009  removing 1153065 relations and 753065 ideals in 400000 cliques
Thu Jan 29 23:40:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Thu Jan 29 23:43:05 2009  begin with 333734450 relations and 202322037 unique ideals
Thu Jan 29 23:57:14 2009  reduce to 333731484 relations and 201565996 ideals in 4 passes
Thu Jan 29 23:57:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 00:09:46 2009  removing 1204197 relations and 804197 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 00:10:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 00:12:54 2009  begin with 332527287 relations and 201565996 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 00:23:33 2009  reduce to 332525000 relations and 200759502 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 00:23:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 00:36:02 2009  removing 1192866 relations and 792866 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 00:36:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 00:39:09 2009  begin with 331332134 relations and 200759502 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 00:53:05 2009  reduce to 331329793 relations and 199964287 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 00:53:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 01:05:28 2009  removing 1169988 relations and 769988 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 01:05:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 01:08:35 2009  begin with 330159805 relations and 199964287 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 01:19:05 2009  reduce to 330157186 relations and 199191669 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 01:19:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 01:31:27 2009  removing 1164350 relations and 764350 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 01:31:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 01:34:34 2009  begin with 328992836 relations and 199191669 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 01:48:16 2009  reduce to 328990075 relations and 198424548 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 01:48:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 02:00:29 2009  removing 1177829 relations and 777829 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 02:00:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 02:03:34 2009  begin with 327812246 relations and 198424548 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 02:17:19 2009  reduce to 327809474 relations and 197643936 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 02:17:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 02:29:27 2009  removing 1144166 relations and 744166 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 02:29:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 02:32:29 2009  begin with 326665308 relations and 197643936 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 02:46:13 2009  reduce to 326662173 relations and 196896629 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 02:46:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 02:58:20 2009  removing 1168717 relations and 768717 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 02:58:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 03:01:22 2009  begin with 325493456 relations and 196896629 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 03:14:58 2009  reduce to 325490411 relations and 196124853 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 03:14:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 03:27:00 2009  removing 1136759 relations and 736759 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 03:27:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 03:30:03 2009  begin with 324353652 relations and 196124853 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 03:43:42 2009  reduce to 324350255 relations and 195384685 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 03:43:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 03:55:40 2009  removing 1132537 relations and 732537 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 03:55:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 03:58:44 2009  begin with 323217718 relations and 195384685 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 04:12:18 2009  reduce to 323214026 relations and 194648435 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 04:12:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 04:24:19 2009  removing 1115999 relations and 715999 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 04:24:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 04:27:22 2009  begin with 322098027 relations and 194648435 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 04:37:28 2009  reduce to 322093934 relations and 193928324 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 04:37:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 04:49:25 2009  removing 1075505 relations and 675505 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 04:49:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 04:52:25 2009  begin with 321018429 relations and 193928324 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 05:05:56 2009  reduce to 321013390 relations and 193247746 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 05:05:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 05:17:49 2009  removing 1183388 relations and 783388 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 05:18:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 05:20:51 2009  begin with 319830002 relations and 193247746 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 05:34:14 2009  reduce to 319827679 relations and 192462008 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 05:34:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 05:46:02 2009  removing 1133032 relations and 733032 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 05:46:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 05:48:59 2009  begin with 318694647 relations and 192462008 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 05:58:57 2009  reduce to 318692299 relations and 191726608 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 05:58:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 06:10:43 2009  removing 1121347 relations and 721347 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 06:10:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 06:13:40 2009  begin with 317570952 relations and 191726608 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 06:23:35 2009  reduce to 317568491 relations and 191002782 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 06:23:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 06:35:15 2009  removing 1097638 relations and 697638 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 06:35:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 06:38:11 2009  begin with 316470853 relations and 191002782 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 06:51:20 2009  reduce to 316468273 relations and 190302549 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 06:51:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 07:02:56 2009  removing 1049398 relations and 649398 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 07:03:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 07:05:52 2009  begin with 315418875 relations and 190302549 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 07:18:48 2009  reduce to 315415528 relations and 189649788 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 07:18:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 07:30:20 2009  removing 1143354 relations and 743354 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 07:30:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 07:33:13 2009  begin with 314272174 relations and 189649788 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 07:43:04 2009  reduce to 314269761 relations and 188904004 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 07:43:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 07:54:36 2009  removing 1109348 relations and 709348 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 07:54:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 07:57:30 2009  begin with 313160413 relations and 188904004 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 08:07:19 2009  reduce to 313158373 relations and 188192598 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 08:07:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 08:18:50 2009  removing 1081569 relations and 681569 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 08:19:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 08:21:45 2009  begin with 312076804 relations and 188192598 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 08:31:28 2009  reduce to 312074439 relations and 187508646 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 08:31:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 08:42:52 2009  removing 1075612 relations and 675612 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 08:43:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 08:45:44 2009  begin with 310998827 relations and 187508646 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 08:55:26 2009  reduce to 310996341 relations and 186830541 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 08:55:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 09:06:47 2009  removing 1100295 relations and 700295 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 09:07:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 09:09:40 2009  begin with 309896046 relations and 186830541 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 09:22:30 2009  reduce to 309893796 relations and 186127978 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 09:22:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 09:33:45 2009  removing 1062863 relations and 662863 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 09:34:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 09:36:35 2009  begin with 308830933 relations and 186127978 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 09:46:12 2009  reduce to 308828308 relations and 185462475 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 09:46:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 09:57:25 2009  removing 1079882 relations and 679882 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 09:57:41 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 10:00:17 2009  begin with 307748426 relations and 185462475 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 10:09:50 2009  reduce to 307746096 relations and 184780251 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 10:09:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 10:21:02 2009  removing 1059190 relations and 659190 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 10:21:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 10:23:50 2009  begin with 306686906 relations and 184780251 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 10:36:31 2009  reduce to 306684202 relations and 184118347 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 10:36:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 10:47:37 2009  removing 1061819 relations and 661819 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 10:47:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 10:50:25 2009  begin with 305622383 relations and 184118347 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 10:59:54 2009  reduce to 305619770 relations and 183453904 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 10:59:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 11:10:58 2009  removing 1042102 relations and 642102 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 11:11:13 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 11:13:46 2009  begin with 304577668 relations and 183453904 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 11:23:08 2009  reduce to 304574625 relations and 182808751 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 11:23:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 11:34:07 2009  removing 1039951 relations and 639951 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 11:34:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 11:36:53 2009  begin with 303534674 relations and 182808751 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 11:49:23 2009  reduce to 303531529 relations and 182165643 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 11:49:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 12:00:20 2009  removing 1023396 relations and 623396 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 12:00:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 12:03:06 2009  begin with 302508133 relations and 182165643 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 12:12:28 2009  reduce to 302504589 relations and 181538694 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 12:12:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 12:23:23 2009  removing 1036290 relations and 636290 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 12:23:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 12:26:08 2009  begin with 301468299 relations and 181538694 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 12:35:24 2009  reduce to 301464891 relations and 180898979 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 12:35:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 12:46:15 2009  removing 1109191 relations and 709191 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 12:46:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 12:48:57 2009  begin with 300355700 relations and 180898979 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 12:58:13 2009  reduce to 300353619 relations and 180187703 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 12:58:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 13:09:01 2009  removing 1083722 relations and 683722 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 13:09:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 13:11:45 2009  begin with 299269897 relations and 180187703 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 13:20:56 2009  reduce to 299268158 relations and 179502238 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 13:20:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 13:31:40 2009  removing 1035907 relations and 635907 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 13:31:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 13:34:23 2009  begin with 298232251 relations and 179502238 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 13:43:33 2009  reduce to 298229922 relations and 178863995 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 13:43:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 13:54:17 2009  removing 1088183 relations and 688183 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 13:54:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 13:56:58 2009  begin with 297141739 relations and 178863995 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 14:06:06 2009  reduce to 297139831 relations and 178173896 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 14:06:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 14:16:41 2009  removing 1062067 relations and 662067 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 14:16:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 14:19:23 2009  begin with 296077764 relations and 178173896 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 14:28:29 2009  reduce to 296075638 relations and 177509693 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 14:28:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 14:39:04 2009  removing 1040006 relations and 640006 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 14:39:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 14:41:45 2009  begin with 295035632 relations and 177509693 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 14:50:44 2009  reduce to 295033243 relations and 176867291 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 14:50:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 15:01:13 2009  removing 1056389 relations and 656389 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 15:01:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 15:03:51 2009  begin with 293976854 relations and 176867291 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 15:15:51 2009  reduce to 293974380 relations and 176208414 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 15:15:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 15:26:18 2009  removing 1032270 relations and 632270 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 15:26:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 15:28:55 2009  begin with 292942110 relations and 176208414 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 15:37:47 2009  reduce to 292939275 relations and 175573295 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 15:37:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 15:48:12 2009  removing 1029457 relations and 629457 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 15:48:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 15:50:50 2009  begin with 291909818 relations and 175573295 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 16:02:41 2009  reduce to 291906712 relations and 174940719 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 16:02:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 16:13:03 2009  removing 1020286 relations and 620286 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 16:13:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 16:15:39 2009  begin with 290886426 relations and 174940719 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 16:24:27 2009  reduce to 290883182 relations and 174317167 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 16:24:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 16:34:49 2009  removing 1003555 relations and 603555 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 16:35:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 16:37:26 2009  begin with 289879627 relations and 174317167 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 16:49:16 2009  reduce to 289875932 relations and 173709900 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 16:49:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 16:59:35 2009  removing 1029394 relations and 629394 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 16:59:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 17:02:12 2009  begin with 288846538 relations and 173709900 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 17:10:57 2009  reduce to 288843058 relations and 173077004 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 17:10:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 17:21:10 2009  removing 1065062 relations and 665062 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 17:21:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 17:23:45 2009  begin with 287777996 relations and 173077004 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 17:32:30 2009  reduce to 287774943 relations and 172408854 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 17:32:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 17:42:38 2009  removing 1028935 relations and 628935 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 17:42:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 17:45:13 2009  begin with 286746008 relations and 172408854 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 17:53:54 2009  reduce to 286743023 relations and 171776910 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 17:53:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 18:04:05 2009  removing 1053660 relations and 653660 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 18:04:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 18:06:38 2009  begin with 285689363 relations and 171776910 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 18:15:16 2009  reduce to 285686573 relations and 171120437 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 18:15:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 18:25:21 2009  removing 1012831 relations and 612831 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 18:25:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 18:27:53 2009  begin with 284673742 relations and 171120437 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 18:36:25 2009  reduce to 284670382 relations and 170504219 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 18:36:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 18:46:30 2009  removing 1041973 relations and 641973 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 18:46:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 18:49:01 2009  begin with 283628409 relations and 170504219 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 18:57:35 2009  reduce to 283625050 relations and 169858868 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 18:57:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 19:07:35 2009  removing 1008799 relations and 608799 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 19:07:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 19:10:09 2009  begin with 282616251 relations and 169858868 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 19:18:43 2009  reduce to 282612598 relations and 169246390 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 19:18:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 19:28:41 2009  removing 1007381 relations and 607381 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 19:28:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 19:31:11 2009  begin with 281605217 relations and 169246390 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 19:42:23 2009  reduce to 281601085 relations and 168634844 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 19:42:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 19:52:20 2009  removing 989447 relations and 589447 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 19:52:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 19:54:52 2009  begin with 280611638 relations and 168634844 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 20:06:06 2009  reduce to 280606911 relations and 168040627 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 20:06:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 20:16:01 2009  removing 1032693 relations and 632693 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 20:16:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 20:18:32 2009  begin with 279574218 relations and 168040627 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 20:26:54 2009  reduce to 279569982 relations and 167403650 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 20:26:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 20:36:45 2009  removing 1022366 relations and 622366 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 20:36:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 20:39:16 2009  begin with 278547616 relations and 167403650 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 20:47:41 2009  reduce to 278543482 relations and 166777104 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 20:47:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 20:57:29 2009  removing 1022500 relations and 622500 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 20:57:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 20:59:58 2009  begin with 277520982 relations and 166777104 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 21:08:19 2009  reduce to 277517160 relations and 166150743 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 21:08:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 21:18:04 2009  removing 1004855 relations and 604855 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 21:18:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 21:20:32 2009  begin with 276512305 relations and 166150743 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 21:28:54 2009  reduce to 276507771 relations and 165541313 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 21:28:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 21:38:37 2009  removing 1003138 relations and 603138 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 21:38:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 21:41:04 2009  begin with 275504633 relations and 165541313 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 21:49:21 2009  reduce to 275500006 relations and 164933491 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 21:49:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 21:59:03 2009  removing 989787 relations and 589787 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 21:59:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 22:01:29 2009  begin with 274510219 relations and 164933491 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 22:09:41 2009  reduce to 274504917 relations and 164338351 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 22:09:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 22:19:20 2009  removing 985217 relations and 585217 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 22:19:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 22:21:45 2009  begin with 273519700 relations and 164338351 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 22:32:46 2009  reduce to 273514191 relations and 163747554 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 22:32:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 22:42:22 2009  removing 1019572 relations and 619572 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 22:42:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 22:44:46 2009  begin with 272494619 relations and 163747554 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 22:52:58 2009  reduce to 272489238 relations and 163122520 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 22:52:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 23:02:33 2009  removing 995950 relations and 595950 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 23:02:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 23:04:57 2009  begin with 271493288 relations and 163122520 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 23:15:51 2009  reduce to 271488114 relations and 162521316 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 23:15:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 23:25:18 2009  removing 990063 relations and 590063 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 23:25:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 23:27:45 2009  begin with 270498051 relations and 162521316 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 23:35:55 2009  reduce to 270492608 relations and 161925731 ideals in 3 passes
Fri Jan 30 23:35:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Fri Jan 30 23:45:22 2009  removing 982481 relations and 582481 ideals in 400000 cliques
Fri Jan 30 23:45:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Fri Jan 30 23:47:44 2009  begin with 269510127 relations and 161925731 unique ideals
Fri Jan 30 23:58:28 2009  reduce to 269504057 relations and 161337097 ideals in 4 passes
Fri Jan 30 23:58:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 00:07:53 2009  removing 986028 relations and 586028 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 00:08:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 00:10:14 2009  begin with 268518029 relations and 161337097 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 00:18:12 2009  reduce to 268511938 relations and 160744869 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 00:18:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 00:27:33 2009  removing 987471 relations and 587471 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 00:27:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 00:30:03 2009  begin with 267524467 relations and 160744869 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 00:38:44 2009  reduce to 267518037 relations and 160150861 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 00:38:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 00:48:43 2009  removing 978904 relations and 578904 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 00:48:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 00:51:08 2009  begin with 266539133 relations and 160150861 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 00:59:10 2009  reduce to 266532971 relations and 159565682 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 00:59:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 01:09:15 2009  removing 973197 relations and 573197 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 01:09:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 01:11:59 2009  begin with 265559774 relations and 159565682 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 01:21:06 2009  reduce to 265553100 relations and 158985705 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 01:21:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 01:31:55 2009  removing 977203 relations and 577203 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 01:32:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 01:34:36 2009  begin with 264575897 relations and 158985705 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 01:43:53 2009  reduce to 264568770 relations and 158401246 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 01:43:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 01:54:38 2009  removing 966909 relations and 566909 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 01:54:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 01:57:19 2009  begin with 263601861 relations and 158401246 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 02:09:18 2009  reduce to 263594830 relations and 157827173 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 02:09:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 02:19:55 2009  removing 967214 relations and 567214 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 02:20:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 02:22:33 2009  begin with 262627616 relations and 157827173 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 02:31:41 2009  reduce to 262620143 relations and 157252353 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 02:31:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 02:42:20 2009  removing 963676 relations and 563676 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 02:42:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 02:45:00 2009  begin with 261656467 relations and 157252353 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 02:57:04 2009  reduce to 261648853 relations and 156680924 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 02:57:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 03:07:36 2009  removing 959400 relations and 559400 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 03:07:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 03:10:16 2009  begin with 260689453 relations and 156680924 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 03:19:12 2009  reduce to 260681643 relations and 156113568 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 03:19:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 03:29:45 2009  removing 954692 relations and 554692 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 03:29:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 03:32:22 2009  begin with 259726951 relations and 156113568 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 03:41:15 2009  reduce to 259718999 relations and 155550776 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 03:41:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 03:51:44 2009  removing 945594 relations and 545594 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 03:51:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 03:54:22 2009  begin with 258773405 relations and 155550776 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 04:06:02 2009  reduce to 258765307 relations and 154996935 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 04:06:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 04:16:25 2009  removing 933981 relations and 533981 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 04:16:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 04:19:00 2009  begin with 257831326 relations and 154996935 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 04:27:45 2009  reduce to 257822901 relations and 154454375 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 04:27:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 04:38:10 2009  removing 935562 relations and 535562 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 04:38:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 04:40:45 2009  begin with 256887339 relations and 154454375 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 04:52:19 2009  reduce to 256878902 relations and 153910190 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 04:52:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 05:02:35 2009  removing 934964 relations and 534964 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 05:02:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 05:05:11 2009  begin with 255943938 relations and 153910190 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 05:13:56 2009  reduce to 255935610 relations and 153366715 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 05:13:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 05:24:15 2009  removing 933443 relations and 533443 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 05:24:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 05:26:50 2009  begin with 255002167 relations and 153366715 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 05:38:36 2009  reduce to 254993597 relations and 152824518 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 05:38:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 05:48:51 2009  removing 933008 relations and 533008 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 05:49:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 05:51:26 2009  begin with 254060589 relations and 152824518 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 06:00:10 2009  reduce to 254052273 relations and 152283014 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 06:00:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 06:10:23 2009  removing 931541 relations and 531541 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 06:10:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 06:12:54 2009  begin with 253120732 relations and 152283014 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 06:21:25 2009  reduce to 253112199 relations and 151742749 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 06:21:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 06:31:33 2009  removing 930591 relations and 530591 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 06:31:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 06:34:04 2009  begin with 252181608 relations and 151742749 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 06:45:25 2009  reduce to 252173164 relations and 151203516 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 06:45:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 06:55:30 2009  removing 931000 relations and 531000 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 06:55:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 06:58:00 2009  begin with 251242164 relations and 151203516 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 07:09:25 2009  reduce to 251233835 relations and 150664003 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 07:09:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 07:19:26 2009  removing 929339 relations and 529339 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 07:19:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 07:21:57 2009  begin with 250304496 relations and 150664003 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 07:30:30 2009  reduce to 250296117 relations and 150126098 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 07:30:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 07:40:28 2009  removing 928170 relations and 528170 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 07:40:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 07:42:57 2009  begin with 249367947 relations and 150126098 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 07:54:14 2009  reduce to 249359673 relations and 149589458 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 07:54:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 08:04:10 2009  removing 928059 relations and 528059 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 08:04:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 08:06:41 2009  begin with 248431614 relations and 149589458 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 08:15:00 2009  reduce to 248423361 relations and 149052978 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 08:15:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 08:24:55 2009  removing 927082 relations and 527082 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 08:25:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 08:27:24 2009  begin with 247496279 relations and 149052978 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 08:35:44 2009  reduce to 247487861 relations and 148517307 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 08:35:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 08:45:38 2009  removing 926751 relations and 526751 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 08:45:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 08:48:05 2009  begin with 246561110 relations and 148517307 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 08:56:27 2009  reduce to 246552570 relations and 147981841 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 08:56:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 09:06:18 2009  removing 925394 relations and 525394 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 09:06:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 09:08:46 2009  begin with 245627176 relations and 147981841 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 09:17:07 2009  reduce to 245618944 relations and 147448016 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 09:17:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 09:26:51 2009  removing 924563 relations and 524563 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 09:27:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 09:29:17 2009  begin with 244694381 relations and 147448016 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 09:37:34 2009  reduce to 244685993 relations and 146914895 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 09:37:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 09:47:21 2009  removing 923192 relations and 523192 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 09:47:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 09:49:45 2009  begin with 243762801 relations and 146914895 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 09:58:01 2009  reduce to 243754410 relations and 146383143 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 09:58:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 10:07:39 2009  removing 925175 relations and 525175 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 10:07:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 10:10:02 2009  begin with 242829235 relations and 146383143 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 10:18:14 2009  reduce to 242820974 relations and 145849502 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 10:18:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 10:27:52 2009  removing 923419 relations and 523419 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 10:28:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 10:30:16 2009  begin with 241897555 relations and 145849502 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 10:41:09 2009  reduce to 241889535 relations and 145317883 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 10:41:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 10:50:43 2009  removing 921929 relations and 521929 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 10:50:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 10:53:07 2009  begin with 240967606 relations and 145317883 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 11:01:12 2009  reduce to 240959562 relations and 144787746 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 11:01:12 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 11:10:44 2009  removing 921066 relations and 521066 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 11:10:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 11:13:07 2009  begin with 240038496 relations and 144787746 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 11:21:10 2009  reduce to 240030522 relations and 144258541 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 11:21:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 11:30:33 2009  removing 921152 relations and 521152 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 11:30:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 11:32:54 2009  begin with 239109370 relations and 144258541 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 11:40:57 2009  reduce to 239101349 relations and 143729195 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 11:40:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 11:50:24 2009  removing 921071 relations and 521071 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 11:50:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 11:52:45 2009  begin with 238180278 relations and 143729195 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 12:00:46 2009  reduce to 238172366 relations and 143200022 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 12:00:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 12:10:12 2009  removing 918235 relations and 518235 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 12:10:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 12:12:29 2009  begin with 237254131 relations and 143200022 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 12:22:49 2009  reduce to 237246024 relations and 142673520 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 12:22:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 12:32:08 2009  removing 919227 relations and 519227 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 12:32:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 12:34:27 2009  begin with 236326797 relations and 142673520 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 12:44:55 2009  reduce to 236318849 relations and 142146169 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 12:44:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 12:54:10 2009  removing 918540 relations and 518540 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 12:54:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 12:56:26 2009  begin with 235400309 relations and 142146169 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 13:06:44 2009  reduce to 235392235 relations and 141619374 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 13:06:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 13:15:55 2009  removing 917825 relations and 517825 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 13:16:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 13:18:14 2009  begin with 234474410 relations and 141619374 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 13:26:03 2009  reduce to 234466437 relations and 141093397 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 13:26:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 13:35:13 2009  removing 917350 relations and 517350 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 13:35:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 13:37:29 2009  begin with 233549087 relations and 141093397 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 13:45:09 2009  reduce to 233541287 relations and 140568064 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 13:45:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 13:54:13 2009  removing 915822 relations and 515822 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 13:54:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 13:56:27 2009  begin with 232625465 relations and 140568064 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 14:04:09 2009  reduce to 232617657 relations and 140044268 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 14:04:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 14:13:12 2009  removing 915930 relations and 515930 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 14:13:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 14:15:27 2009  begin with 231701727 relations and 140044268 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 14:25:37 2009  reduce to 231693832 relations and 139520272 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 14:25:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 14:34:35 2009  removing 914497 relations and 514497 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 14:34:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 14:36:49 2009  begin with 230779335 relations and 139520272 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 14:46:55 2009  reduce to 230771425 relations and 138997688 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 14:46:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 14:55:52 2009  removing 913814 relations and 513814 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 14:56:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 14:58:05 2009  begin with 229857611 relations and 138997688 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 15:05:43 2009  reduce to 229849769 relations and 138475876 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 15:05:43 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 15:14:33 2009  removing 915542 relations and 515542 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 15:14:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 15:16:46 2009  begin with 228934227 relations and 138475876 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 15:24:17 2009  reduce to 228926360 relations and 137952288 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 15:24:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 15:33:05 2009  removing 913981 relations and 513981 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 15:33:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 15:35:16 2009  begin with 228012379 relations and 137952288 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 15:45:09 2009  reduce to 228004362 relations and 137430106 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 15:45:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 15:53:55 2009  removing 912885 relations and 512885 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 15:54:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 15:56:05 2009  begin with 227091477 relations and 137430106 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 16:03:28 2009  reduce to 227083715 relations and 136909295 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 16:03:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 16:12:11 2009  removing 912737 relations and 512737 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 16:12:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 16:14:22 2009  begin with 226170978 relations and 136909295 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 16:21:42 2009  reduce to 226162897 relations and 136388286 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 16:21:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 16:30:23 2009  removing 912137 relations and 512137 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 16:30:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 16:32:30 2009  begin with 225250760 relations and 136388286 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 16:39:48 2009  reduce to 225242763 relations and 135867982 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 16:39:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 16:48:23 2009  removing 910896 relations and 510896 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 16:48:36 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 16:50:32 2009  begin with 224331867 relations and 135867982 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 16:57:47 2009  reduce to 224324007 relations and 135349057 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 16:57:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 17:06:23 2009  removing 910789 relations and 510789 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 17:06:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 17:08:31 2009  begin with 223413218 relations and 135349057 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 17:18:08 2009  reduce to 223405263 relations and 134830135 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 17:18:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 17:26:40 2009  removing 910713 relations and 510713 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 17:26:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 17:28:47 2009  begin with 222494550 relations and 134830135 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 17:38:24 2009  reduce to 222486690 relations and 134311403 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 17:38:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 17:46:52 2009  removing 909728 relations and 509728 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 17:47:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 17:48:57 2009  begin with 221576962 relations and 134311403 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 17:58:31 2009  reduce to 221569163 relations and 133793689 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 17:58:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 18:06:59 2009  removing 909275 relations and 509275 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 18:07:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 18:09:05 2009  begin with 220659888 relations and 133793689 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 18:18:29 2009  reduce to 220651979 relations and 133276341 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 18:18:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 18:26:55 2009  removing 908260 relations and 508260 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 18:27:06 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 18:29:00 2009  begin with 219743719 relations and 133276341 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 18:36:05 2009  reduce to 219736039 relations and 132760246 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 18:36:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 18:44:28 2009  removing 908081 relations and 508081 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 18:44:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 18:46:33 2009  begin with 218827958 relations and 132760246 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 18:53:34 2009  reduce to 218820273 relations and 132244293 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 18:53:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 19:01:55 2009  removing 906896 relations and 506896 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 19:02:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 19:03:57 2009  begin with 217913377 relations and 132244293 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 19:13:18 2009  reduce to 217905552 relations and 131729393 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 19:13:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 19:21:37 2009  removing 907871 relations and 507871 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 19:21:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 19:23:39 2009  begin with 216997681 relations and 131729393 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 19:33:01 2009  reduce to 216989727 relations and 131213387 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 19:33:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 19:41:19 2009  removing 907398 relations and 507398 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 19:41:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 19:43:21 2009  begin with 216082329 relations and 131213387 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 19:50:17 2009  reduce to 216074393 relations and 130697873 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 19:50:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 19:58:36 2009  removing 906372 relations and 506372 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 19:58:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 20:00:37 2009  begin with 215168021 relations and 130697873 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 20:07:31 2009  reduce to 215160122 relations and 130183427 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 20:07:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 20:15:39 2009  removing 905430 relations and 505430 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 20:15:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 20:17:40 2009  begin with 214254692 relations and 130183427 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 20:26:41 2009  reduce to 214246767 relations and 129669906 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 20:26:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 20:34:45 2009  removing 905630 relations and 505630 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 20:34:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 20:36:46 2009  begin with 213341137 relations and 129669906 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 20:45:48 2009  reduce to 213333313 relations and 129156280 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 20:45:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 20:53:52 2009  removing 904488 relations and 504488 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 20:54:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 20:55:51 2009  begin with 212428825 relations and 129156280 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 21:02:34 2009  reduce to 212421003 relations and 128643788 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 21:02:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 21:10:32 2009  removing 904455 relations and 504455 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 21:10:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 21:12:31 2009  begin with 211516548 relations and 128643788 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 21:19:14 2009  reduce to 211508683 relations and 128131294 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 21:19:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 21:27:13 2009  removing 903859 relations and 503859 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 21:27:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 21:29:10 2009  begin with 210604824 relations and 128131294 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 21:38:00 2009  reduce to 210596882 relations and 127619310 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 21:38:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 21:45:57 2009  removing 902209 relations and 502209 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 21:46:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 21:47:56 2009  begin with 209694673 relations and 127619310 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 21:56:46 2009  reduce to 209686721 relations and 127108968 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 21:56:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 22:04:38 2009  removing 903032 relations and 503032 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 22:04:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 22:06:34 2009  begin with 208783689 relations and 127108968 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 22:13:13 2009  reduce to 208775811 relations and 126597901 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 22:13:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 22:21:02 2009  removing 902856 relations and 502856 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 22:21:14 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 22:22:57 2009  begin with 207872955 relations and 126597901 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 22:31:42 2009  reduce to 207865043 relations and 126086963 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 22:31:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 22:39:31 2009  removing 902382 relations and 502382 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 22:39:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 22:41:26 2009  begin with 206962661 relations and 126086963 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 22:47:58 2009  reduce to 206954856 relations and 125576577 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 22:47:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 22:55:44 2009  removing 901735 relations and 501735 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 22:55:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 22:57:39 2009  begin with 206053121 relations and 125576577 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 23:06:11 2009  reduce to 206045283 relations and 125066827 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 23:06:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 23:13:56 2009  removing 901363 relations and 501363 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 23:14:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 23:15:49 2009  begin with 205143920 relations and 125066827 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 23:22:18 2009  reduce to 205135874 relations and 124557258 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 23:22:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 23:29:58 2009  removing 900401 relations and 500401 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 23:30:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 23:31:52 2009  begin with 204235473 relations and 124557258 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 23:38:15 2009  reduce to 204227498 relations and 124048707 ideals in 3 passes
Sat Jan 31 23:38:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sat Jan 31 23:45:52 2009  removing 900175 relations and 500175 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sat Jan 31 23:46:03 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sat Jan 31 23:47:43 2009  begin with 203327323 relations and 124048707 unique ideals
Sat Jan 31 23:56:16 2009  reduce to 203319360 relations and 123540398 ideals in 4 passes
Sat Jan 31 23:56:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 00:03:53 2009  removing 899938 relations and 499938 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 00:04:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 00:05:44 2009  begin with 202419422 relations and 123540398 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 00:14:10 2009  reduce to 202411278 relations and 123032150 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 00:14:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 00:21:44 2009  removing 899662 relations and 499662 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 00:21:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 00:23:33 2009  begin with 201511616 relations and 123032150 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 00:29:51 2009  reduce to 201503580 relations and 122524269 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 00:29:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 00:37:23 2009  removing 898933 relations and 498933 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 00:37:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 00:39:12 2009  begin with 200604647 relations and 122524269 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 00:45:27 2009  reduce to 200596566 relations and 122017069 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 00:45:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 00:52:54 2009  removing 898877 relations and 498877 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 00:53:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 00:54:44 2009  begin with 199697689 relations and 122017069 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 01:00:54 2009  reduce to 199689596 relations and 121509918 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 01:00:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 01:08:19 2009  removing 898948 relations and 498948 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 01:08:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 01:10:08 2009  begin with 198790648 relations and 121509918 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 01:16:20 2009  reduce to 198782773 relations and 121002924 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 01:16:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 01:23:41 2009  removing 898214 relations and 498214 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 01:23:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 01:25:30 2009  begin with 197884559 relations and 121002924 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 01:31:41 2009  reduce to 197876303 relations and 120496267 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 01:31:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 01:39:01 2009  removing 897863 relations and 497863 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 01:39:12 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 01:40:48 2009  begin with 196978440 relations and 120496267 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 01:48:55 2009  reduce to 196970498 relations and 119990270 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 01:48:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 01:56:12 2009  removing 896972 relations and 496972 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 01:56:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 01:57:59 2009  begin with 196073526 relations and 119990270 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 02:05:59 2009  reduce to 196065345 relations and 119484916 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 02:05:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 02:13:14 2009  removing 897009 relations and 497009 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 02:13:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 02:15:01 2009  begin with 195168336 relations and 119484916 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 02:21:05 2009  reduce to 195160035 relations and 118979436 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 02:21:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 02:28:18 2009  removing 895853 relations and 495853 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 02:28:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 02:30:04 2009  begin with 194264182 relations and 118979436 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 02:38:04 2009  reduce to 194255987 relations and 118475197 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 02:38:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 02:45:15 2009  removing 895974 relations and 495974 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 02:45:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 02:47:01 2009  begin with 193360013 relations and 118475197 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 02:52:58 2009  reduce to 193351780 relations and 117970762 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 02:52:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 03:00:04 2009  removing 895981 relations and 495981 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 03:00:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 03:01:50 2009  begin with 192455799 relations and 117970762 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 03:09:42 2009  reduce to 192447579 relations and 117466368 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 03:09:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 03:16:48 2009  removing 895177 relations and 495177 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 03:16:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 03:18:31 2009  begin with 191552402 relations and 117466368 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 03:26:15 2009  reduce to 191544107 relations and 116962715 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 03:26:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 03:33:17 2009  removing 894710 relations and 494710 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 03:33:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 03:35:01 2009  begin with 190649397 relations and 116962715 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 03:40:55 2009  reduce to 190641142 relations and 116459561 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 03:40:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 03:47:51 2009  removing 894836 relations and 494836 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 03:48:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 03:49:34 2009  begin with 189746306 relations and 116459561 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 03:55:24 2009  reduce to 189737956 relations and 115956171 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 03:55:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 25
Sun Feb  1 04:02:21 2009  removing 893920 relations and 493920 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 04:02:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 04:04:03 2009  begin with 188844036 relations and 115956171 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 04:09:50 2009  reduce to 188835729 relations and 115453748 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 04:09:50 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 04:16:46 2009  removing 894415 relations and 494415 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 04:16:56 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 04:18:27 2009  begin with 187941314 relations and 115453748 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 04:26:14 2009  reduce to 187933333 relations and 114951175 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 04:26:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 04:33:08 2009  removing 893485 relations and 493485 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 04:33:19 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 04:34:47 2009  begin with 187039848 relations and 114951175 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 04:42:23 2009  reduce to 187031792 relations and 114449443 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 04:42:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 04:49:09 2009  removing 893315 relations and 493315 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 04:49:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 04:50:50 2009  begin with 186138477 relations and 114449443 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 04:56:32 2009  reduce to 186130100 relations and 113947555 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 04:56:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 05:03:19 2009  removing 893698 relations and 493698 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 05:03:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 05:04:59 2009  begin with 185236402 relations and 113947555 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 05:10:35 2009  reduce to 185227925 relations and 113445158 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 05:10:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 05:17:20 2009  removing 893136 relations and 493136 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 05:17:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 05:18:57 2009  begin with 184334789 relations and 113445158 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 05:26:22 2009  reduce to 184326310 relations and 112943328 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 05:26:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 05:33:01 2009  removing 892223 relations and 492223 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 05:33:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 05:34:38 2009  begin with 183434087 relations and 112943328 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 05:42:00 2009  reduce to 183425615 relations and 112442428 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 05:42:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 05:48:42 2009  removing 891748 relations and 491748 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 05:48:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 05:50:18 2009  begin with 182533867 relations and 112442428 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 05:57:39 2009  reduce to 182525100 relations and 111941698 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 05:57:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 06:04:11 2009  removing 892004 relations and 492004 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 06:04:21 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 06:05:49 2009  begin with 181633096 relations and 111941698 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 06:11:17 2009  reduce to 181624407 relations and 111440795 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 06:11:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 06:17:50 2009  removing 890926 relations and 490926 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 06:18:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 06:19:28 2009  begin with 180733481 relations and 111440795 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 06:25:00 2009  reduce to 180724405 relations and 110940562 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 06:25:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 06:31:34 2009  removing 890788 relations and 490788 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 06:31:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 06:33:07 2009  begin with 179833617 relations and 110940562 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 06:38:34 2009  reduce to 179824582 relations and 110440506 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 06:38:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 06:45:06 2009  removing 890900 relations and 490900 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 06:45:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 06:46:40 2009  begin with 178933682 relations and 110440506 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 06:53:52 2009  reduce to 178924621 relations and 109940318 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 06:53:52 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 07:00:21 2009  removing 890999 relations and 490999 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 07:00:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 07:01:54 2009  begin with 178033622 relations and 109940318 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 07:07:16 2009  reduce to 178024503 relations and 109439963 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 07:07:16 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 07:13:42 2009  removing 890371 relations and 490371 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 07:13:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 07:15:15 2009  begin with 177134132 relations and 109439963 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 07:22:09 2009  reduce to 177124709 relations and 108939945 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 07:22:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 07:28:33 2009  removing 890098 relations and 490098 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 07:28:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 07:30:04 2009  begin with 176234611 relations and 108939945 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 07:35:18 2009  reduce to 176225365 relations and 108440346 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 07:35:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 07:41:38 2009  removing 890133 relations and 490133 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 07:41:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 07:43:10 2009  begin with 175335232 relations and 108440346 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 07:48:24 2009  reduce to 175325756 relations and 107940494 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 07:48:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 07:54:42 2009  removing 889630 relations and 489630 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 07:54:51 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 07:56:12 2009  begin with 174436126 relations and 107940494 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 08:03:03 2009  reduce to 174426672 relations and 107441176 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 08:03:03 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 08:09:18 2009  removing 889811 relations and 489811 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 08:09:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 08:10:48 2009  begin with 173536861 relations and 107441176 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 08:17:37 2009  reduce to 173527277 relations and 106941503 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 08:17:37 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 08:23:50 2009  removing 889161 relations and 489161 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 08:23:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 08:25:19 2009  begin with 172638116 relations and 106941503 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 08:30:27 2009  reduce to 172628257 relations and 106442234 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 08:30:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 08:36:36 2009  removing 890092 relations and 490092 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 08:36:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 08:38:05 2009  begin with 171738165 relations and 106442234 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 08:44:51 2009  reduce to 171728432 relations and 105942129 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 08:44:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 08:50:57 2009  removing 889516 relations and 489516 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 08:51:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 08:52:27 2009  begin with 170838916 relations and 105942129 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 08:57:30 2009  reduce to 170829001 relations and 105442418 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 08:57:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 09:03:34 2009  removing 888833 relations and 488833 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 09:03:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 09:05:02 2009  begin with 169940168 relations and 105442418 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 09:11:44 2009  reduce to 169929978 relations and 104943120 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 09:11:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 09:17:46 2009  removing 888824 relations and 488824 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 09:17:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 09:19:15 2009  begin with 169041154 relations and 104943120 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 09:24:18 2009  reduce to 169030909 relations and 104443803 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 09:24:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 09:30:18 2009  removing 888911 relations and 488911 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 09:30:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 09:31:45 2009  begin with 168141998 relations and 104443803 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 09:38:19 2009  reduce to 168131912 relations and 103944523 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 09:38:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 09:44:15 2009  removing 888396 relations and 488396 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 09:44:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 09:45:42 2009  begin with 167243516 relations and 103944523 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 09:52:15 2009  reduce to 167233331 relations and 103445650 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 09:52:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 09:58:08 2009  removing 889052 relations and 489052 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 09:58:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 09:59:32 2009  begin with 166344279 relations and 103445650 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 10:06:04 2009  reduce to 166333889 relations and 102945922 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 10:06:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 10:11:59 2009  removing 888709 relations and 488709 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 10:12:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 10:13:25 2009  begin with 165445180 relations and 102945922 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 10:19:51 2009  reduce to 165434721 relations and 102446461 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 10:19:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 10:25:40 2009  removing 888776 relations and 488776 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 10:25:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 10:27:04 2009  begin with 164545945 relations and 102446461 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 10:31:51 2009  reduce to 164535551 relations and 101946961 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 10:31:51 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 10:37:39 2009  removing 888573 relations and 488573 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 10:37:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 10:39:03 2009  begin with 163646978 relations and 101946961 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 10:43:49 2009  reduce to 163636281 relations and 101447408 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 10:43:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 10:49:36 2009  removing 888351 relations and 488351 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 10:49:45 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 10:50:59 2009  begin with 162747930 relations and 101447408 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 10:55:45 2009  reduce to 162737174 relations and 100947998 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 10:55:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 11:01:25 2009  removing 888668 relations and 488668 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 11:01:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 11:02:48 2009  begin with 161848506 relations and 100947998 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 11:08:59 2009  reduce to 161837817 relations and 100448329 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 11:08:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 11:14:41 2009  removing 888337 relations and 488337 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 11:14:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 11:16:04 2009  begin with 160949480 relations and 100448329 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 11:20:41 2009  reduce to 160938573 relations and 99948770 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 11:20:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 11:26:19 2009  removing 888499 relations and 488499 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 11:26:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 11:27:41 2009  begin with 160050074 relations and 99948770 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 11:32:18 2009  reduce to 160039191 relations and 99449048 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 11:32:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 11:37:53 2009  removing 888241 relations and 488241 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 11:38:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 11:39:15 2009  begin with 159150950 relations and 99449048 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 11:45:17 2009  reduce to 159139964 relations and 98949496 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 11:45:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 11:50:18 2009  removing 888546 relations and 488546 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 11:50:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 11:51:23 2009  begin with 158251418 relations and 98949496 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 11:56:27 2009  reduce to 158240440 relations and 98449648 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 11:56:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:01:01 2009  removing 888494 relations and 488494 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:01:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:02:08 2009  begin with 157351946 relations and 98449648 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:05:55 2009  reduce to 157340824 relations and 97949718 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:05:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:10:30 2009  removing 889101 relations and 489101 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:10:37 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:11:35 2009  begin with 156451723 relations and 97949718 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:15:20 2009  reduce to 156440619 relations and 97449169 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:15:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:19:51 2009  removing 889446 relations and 489446 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:19:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:20:58 2009  begin with 155551173 relations and 97449169 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:25:54 2009  reduce to 155539996 relations and 96948213 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:25:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:30:24 2009  removing 889510 relations and 489510 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:30:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:31:31 2009  begin with 154650486 relations and 96948213 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:35:11 2009  reduce to 154639095 relations and 96446981 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:35:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:39:40 2009  removing 889450 relations and 489450 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:39:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:40:45 2009  begin with 153749645 relations and 96446981 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:44:25 2009  reduce to 153738486 relations and 95946065 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:44:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:48:52 2009  removing 889991 relations and 489991 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:48:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 12:49:56 2009  begin with 152848495 relations and 95946065 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 12:54:46 2009  reduce to 152837085 relations and 95444334 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 12:54:46 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 12:59:10 2009  removing 889439 relations and 489439 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 12:59:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:00:12 2009  begin with 151947646 relations and 95444334 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:05:02 2009  reduce to 151935986 relations and 94942916 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:05:02 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:09:25 2009  removing 889752 relations and 489752 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:09:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:10:28 2009  begin with 151046234 relations and 94942916 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:15:17 2009  reduce to 151034655 relations and 94441226 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:15:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:19:38 2009  removing 890246 relations and 490246 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:19:44 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:20:41 2009  begin with 150144409 relations and 94441226 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:24:14 2009  reduce to 150132898 relations and 93939154 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:24:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:28:33 2009  removing 889819 relations and 489819 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:28:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:29:36 2009  begin with 149243079 relations and 93939154 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:33:07 2009  reduce to 149231554 relations and 93437453 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:33:07 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:37:26 2009  removing 890583 relations and 490583 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:37:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:38:28 2009  begin with 148340971 relations and 93437453 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:43:10 2009  reduce to 148329423 relations and 92934998 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:43:10 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:47:27 2009  removing 891098 relations and 491098 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:47:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:48:29 2009  begin with 147438325 relations and 92934998 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 13:51:59 2009  reduce to 147426887 relations and 92432161 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 13:51:59 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 13:56:16 2009  removing 891133 relations and 491133 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 13:56:23 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 13:57:16 2009  begin with 146535754 relations and 92432161 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:00:45 2009  reduce to 146524147 relations and 91929084 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:00:45 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 24
Sun Feb  1 14:04:58 2009  removing 891277 relations and 491277 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:05:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:05:56 2009  begin with 145632870 relations and 91929084 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:09:15 2009  reduce to 145621095 relations and 91425722 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:09:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:13:23 2009  removing 891681 relations and 491681 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:13:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:14:24 2009  begin with 144729414 relations and 91425722 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:17:47 2009  reduce to 144717711 relations and 90922008 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:17:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:21:51 2009  removing 892278 relations and 492278 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:21:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:22:51 2009  begin with 143825433 relations and 90922008 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:27:21 2009  reduce to 143813563 relations and 90417543 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:27:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:31:27 2009  removing 892738 relations and 492738 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:31:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:32:26 2009  begin with 142920825 relations and 90417543 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:36:49 2009  reduce to 142909121 relations and 89912808 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:36:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:40:51 2009  removing 893605 relations and 493605 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:40:58 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:41:49 2009  begin with 142015516 relations and 89912808 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:45:06 2009  reduce to 142003887 relations and 89407265 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:45:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:49:10 2009  removing 893670 relations and 493670 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:49:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:50:09 2009  begin with 141110217 relations and 89407265 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 14:54:33 2009  reduce to 141098729 relations and 88901809 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 14:54:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 14:58:33 2009  removing 894126 relations and 494126 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 14:58:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 14:59:31 2009  begin with 140204603 relations and 88901809 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:03:54 2009  reduce to 140192939 relations and 88395686 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:03:54 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:07:54 2009  removing 894555 relations and 494555 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:08:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:08:52 2009  begin with 139298384 relations and 88395686 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:13:11 2009  reduce to 139286644 relations and 87889068 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:13:11 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:17:08 2009  removing 894542 relations and 494542 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:17:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:18:04 2009  begin with 138392102 relations and 87889068 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:22:23 2009  reduce to 138380494 relations and 87382606 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:22:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:26:22 2009  removing 895576 relations and 495576 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:26:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:27:16 2009  begin with 137484918 relations and 87382606 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:31:31 2009  reduce to 137473396 relations and 86875170 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:31:31 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:35:26 2009  removing 895338 relations and 495338 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:35:32 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:36:20 2009  begin with 136578058 relations and 86875170 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:40:26 2009  reduce to 136566403 relations and 86367872 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:40:26 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:44:12 2009  removing 895899 relations and 495899 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:44:18 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:45:08 2009  begin with 135670504 relations and 86367872 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:49:13 2009  reduce to 135658697 relations and 85859845 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:49:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 15:53:02 2009  removing 896707 relations and 496707 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 15:53:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 15:53:57 2009  begin with 134761990 relations and 85859845 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 15:58:00 2009  reduce to 134750337 relations and 85351171 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 15:58:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 16:01:44 2009  removing 897178 relations and 497178 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:01:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:02:39 2009  begin with 133853159 relations and 85351171 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:05:42 2009  reduce to 133841490 relations and 84842012 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:05:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 16:09:28 2009  removing 898316 relations and 498316 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:09:34 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:10:24 2009  begin with 132943174 relations and 84842012 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:13:23 2009  reduce to 132931305 relations and 84331514 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:13:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 23
Sun Feb  1 16:17:02 2009  removing 898140 relations and 498140 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:17:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:17:55 2009  begin with 132033165 relations and 84331514 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:21:53 2009  reduce to 132021417 relations and 83821323 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:21:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 16:25:36 2009  removing 899074 relations and 499074 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:25:42 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:26:27 2009  begin with 131122343 relations and 83821323 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:30:25 2009  reduce to 131110692 relations and 83310289 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:30:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 16:34:04 2009  removing 899614 relations and 499614 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:34:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:34:57 2009  begin with 130211078 relations and 83310289 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:37:55 2009  reduce to 130199204 relations and 82798473 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:37:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 16:41:33 2009  removing 900306 relations and 500306 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:41:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:42:24 2009  begin with 129298898 relations and 82798473 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:45:19 2009  reduce to 129287212 relations and 82286163 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:45:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 16:48:56 2009  removing 900900 relations and 500900 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:49:02 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:49:47 2009  begin with 128386312 relations and 82286163 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 16:52:38 2009  reduce to 128374563 relations and 81773186 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 16:52:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 16:56:11 2009  removing 901363 relations and 501363 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 16:56:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 16:57:02 2009  begin with 127473200 relations and 81773186 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:00:55 2009  reduce to 127461357 relations and 81259677 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:00:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:04:29 2009  removing 902179 relations and 502179 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:04:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:05:20 2009  begin with 126559178 relations and 81259677 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:09:09 2009  reduce to 126547525 relations and 80745527 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:09:09 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:12:42 2009  removing 903584 relations and 503584 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:12:48 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:13:32 2009  begin with 125643941 relations and 80745527 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:17:19 2009  reduce to 125632004 relations and 80229688 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:17:19 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:20:48 2009  removing 903650 relations and 503650 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:20:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:21:37 2009  begin with 124728354 relations and 80229688 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:24:25 2009  reduce to 124716292 relations and 79713693 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:24:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:27:54 2009  removing 904577 relations and 504577 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:28:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:28:42 2009  begin with 123811715 relations and 79713693 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:31:28 2009  reduce to 123799463 relations and 79196550 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:31:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:34:54 2009  removing 905547 relations and 505547 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:35:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:35:42 2009  begin with 122893916 relations and 79196550 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:38:29 2009  reduce to 122881721 relations and 78678513 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:38:29 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:41:56 2009  removing 906048 relations and 506048 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:42:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:42:46 2009  begin with 121975673 relations and 78678513 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:46:22 2009  reduce to 121963282 relations and 78159735 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:46:22 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:49:45 2009  removing 906516 relations and 506516 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:49:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:50:32 2009  begin with 121056766 relations and 78159735 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 17:53:14 2009  reduce to 121044563 relations and 77640654 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 17:53:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 17:56:37 2009  removing 907970 relations and 507970 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 17:56:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 17:57:24 2009  begin with 120136593 relations and 77640654 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:00:05 2009  reduce to 120124283 relations and 77120036 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:00:05 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:03:24 2009  removing 909045 relations and 509045 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:03:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:04:09 2009  begin with 119215238 relations and 77120036 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:07:40 2009  reduce to 119202840 relations and 76598285 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:07:40 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:10:59 2009  removing 909278 relations and 509278 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:11:04 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:11:46 2009  begin with 118293562 relations and 76598285 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:15:14 2009  reduce to 118280846 relations and 76075973 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:15:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:18:27 2009  removing 910844 relations and 510844 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:18:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:19:14 2009  begin with 117370002 relations and 76075973 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:22:35 2009  reduce to 117357445 relations and 75552243 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:22:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:25:44 2009  removing 912306 relations and 512306 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:25:50 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:26:30 2009  begin with 116445139 relations and 75552243 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:29:53 2009  reduce to 116432267 relations and 75026716 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:29:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:33:01 2009  removing 913697 relations and 513697 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:33:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:33:46 2009  begin with 115518570 relations and 75026716 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:37:08 2009  reduce to 115505677 relations and 74499778 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:37:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:40:19 2009  removing 914660 relations and 514660 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:40:24 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:41:03 2009  begin with 114591017 relations and 74499778 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:44:23 2009  reduce to 114577826 relations and 73971576 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:44:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:47:30 2009  removing 915265 relations and 515265 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:47:35 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:48:13 2009  begin with 113662561 relations and 73971576 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:50:41 2009  reduce to 113649559 relations and 73442951 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:50:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 18:53:49 2009  removing 916586 relations and 516586 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 18:53:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 18:54:31 2009  begin with 112732973 relations and 73442951 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 18:57:49 2009  reduce to 112719709 relations and 72912740 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 18:57:49 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 19:00:53 2009  removing 918059 relations and 518059 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:00:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:01:35 2009  begin with 111801650 relations and 72912740 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:04:47 2009  reduce to 111788399 relations and 72381085 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:04:47 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 19:07:48 2009  removing 919478 relations and 519478 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:07:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:08:31 2009  begin with 110868921 relations and 72381085 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:11:42 2009  reduce to 110855153 relations and 71847502 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:11:42 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 19:14:43 2009  removing 919614 relations and 519614 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:14:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:15:25 2009  begin with 109935539 relations and 71847502 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:18:35 2009  reduce to 109921778 relations and 71313713 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:18:35 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 19:21:35 2009  removing 921586 relations and 521586 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:21:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:22:16 2009  begin with 109000192 relations and 71313713 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:25:23 2009  reduce to 108986070 relations and 70777605 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:25:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 22
Sun Feb  1 19:28:21 2009  removing 922987 relations and 522987 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:28:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:29:02 2009  begin with 108063083 relations and 70777605 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:32:08 2009  reduce to 108048958 relations and 70240124 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:32:08 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 19:35:03 2009  removing 924425 relations and 524425 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:35:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:35:44 2009  begin with 107124533 relations and 70240124 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:38:48 2009  reduce to 107110543 relations and 69701321 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:38:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 19:41:42 2009  removing 926182 relations and 526182 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:41:47 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:42:23 2009  begin with 106184361 relations and 69701321 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:45:27 2009  reduce to 106170133 relations and 69160514 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:45:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 19:48:20 2009  removing 927620 relations and 527620 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:48:26 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:48:59 2009  begin with 105242513 relations and 69160514 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:52:01 2009  reduce to 105228194 relations and 68618179 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:52:01 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 19:54:51 2009  removing 928779 relations and 528779 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 19:54:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 19:55:32 2009  begin with 104299415 relations and 68618179 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 19:58:30 2009  reduce to 104284881 relations and 68074475 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 19:58:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:01:15 2009  removing 931654 relations and 531654 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:01:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:01:54 2009  begin with 103353227 relations and 68074475 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:04:48 2009  reduce to 103338421 relations and 67527662 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:04:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:07:34 2009  removing 932427 relations and 532427 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:07:38 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:08:12 2009  begin with 102405994 relations and 67527662 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:11:04 2009  reduce to 102391307 relations and 66980136 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:11:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:13:18 2009  removing 934135 relations and 534135 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:13:22 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:13:48 2009  begin with 101457172 relations and 66980136 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:15:58 2009  reduce to 101442292 relations and 66430686 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:15:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:18:04 2009  removing 936626 relations and 536626 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:18:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:18:33 2009  begin with 100505666 relations and 66430686 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:20:41 2009  reduce to 100490318 relations and 65878301 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:20:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:22:45 2009  removing 938559 relations and 538559 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:22:49 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:23:15 2009  begin with 99551759 relations and 65878301 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:25:23 2009  reduce to 99536284 relations and 65323876 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:25:23 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:27:25 2009  removing 939628 relations and 539628 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:27:29 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:27:53 2009  begin with 98596656 relations and 65323876 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:29:58 2009  reduce to 98580945 relations and 64768106 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:29:58 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:31:58 2009  removing 942007 relations and 542007 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:32:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:32:26 2009  begin with 97638938 relations and 64768106 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:34:28 2009  reduce to 97623044 relations and 64209753 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:34:28 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:36:27 2009  removing 944140 relations and 544140 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:36:30 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:36:54 2009  begin with 96678904 relations and 64209753 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:38:56 2009  reduce to 96662722 relations and 63648964 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:38:56 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:40:54 2009  removing 945774 relations and 545774 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:40:57 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:41:21 2009  begin with 95716948 relations and 63648964 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:43:21 2009  reduce to 95700604 relations and 63086409 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:43:21 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:45:17 2009  removing 948346 relations and 548346 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:45:20 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:45:43 2009  begin with 94752258 relations and 63086409 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:47:41 2009  reduce to 94735298 relations and 62520610 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:47:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:49:35 2009  removing 950205 relations and 550205 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:49:39 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:50:01 2009  begin with 93785093 relations and 62520610 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:51:57 2009  reduce to 93768283 relations and 61953078 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:51:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:53:51 2009  removing 953068 relations and 553068 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:53:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:54:18 2009  begin with 92815215 relations and 61953078 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 20:56:13 2009  reduce to 92797909 relations and 61382197 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 20:56:13 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 20:58:04 2009  removing 955543 relations and 555543 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 20:58:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 20:58:30 2009  begin with 91842366 relations and 61382197 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:00:24 2009  reduce to 91825078 relations and 60808859 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:00:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 21:02:14 2009  removing 958121 relations and 558121 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:02:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:02:39 2009  begin with 90866957 relations and 60808859 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:04:33 2009  reduce to 90849243 relations and 60232463 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:04:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 21:06:23 2009  removing 960337 relations and 560337 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:06:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:06:49 2009  begin with 89888906 relations and 60232463 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:08:41 2009  reduce to 89871226 relations and 59653940 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:08:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 21
Sun Feb  1 21:10:30 2009  removing 963559 relations and 563559 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:10:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:10:55 2009  begin with 88907667 relations and 59653940 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:12:18 2009  reduce to 88890210 relations and 59072454 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:12:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:14:06 2009  removing 964871 relations and 564871 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:14:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:14:31 2009  begin with 87925339 relations and 59072454 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:16:20 2009  reduce to 87907682 relations and 58489427 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:16:20 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:18:07 2009  removing 967778 relations and 567778 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:18:10 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:18:31 2009  begin with 86939904 relations and 58489427 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:20:18 2009  reduce to 86922221 relations and 57903479 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:20:18 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:22:04 2009  removing 969519 relations and 569519 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:22:07 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:22:27 2009  begin with 85952702 relations and 57903479 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:24:14 2009  reduce to 85934667 relations and 57315427 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:24:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:25:58 2009  removing 971459 relations and 571459 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:26:01 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:26:21 2009  begin with 84963208 relations and 57315427 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:28:06 2009  reduce to 84945306 relations and 56725621 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:28:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:29:49 2009  removing 974937 relations and 574937 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:29:52 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:30:12 2009  begin with 83970369 relations and 56725621 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:31:55 2009  reduce to 83952613 relations and 56132442 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:31:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:33:37 2009  removing 978030 relations and 578030 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:33:40 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:34:00 2009  begin with 82974583 relations and 56132442 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:35:41 2009  reduce to 82956691 relations and 55536097 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:35:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:37:22 2009  removing 980462 relations and 580462 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:37:25 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:37:44 2009  begin with 81976229 relations and 55536097 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:39:24 2009  reduce to 81958342 relations and 54937260 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:39:24 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:41:02 2009  removing 982411 relations and 582411 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:41:05 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:41:24 2009  begin with 80975931 relations and 54937260 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:43:27 2009  reduce to 80958211 relations and 54336667 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:43:27 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:45:05 2009  removing 985186 relations and 585186 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:45:08 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:45:27 2009  begin with 79973025 relations and 54336667 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:47:04 2009  reduce to 79954994 relations and 53732981 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:47:04 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:48:40 2009  removing 989455 relations and 589455 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:48:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:49:02 2009  begin with 78965539 relations and 53732981 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:50:36 2009  reduce to 78947353 relations and 53124927 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:50:36 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:52:12 2009  removing 992879 relations and 592879 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:52:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:52:33 2009  begin with 77954474 relations and 53124927 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:54:06 2009  reduce to 77936312 relations and 52513479 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:54:06 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:55:41 2009  removing 996156 relations and 596156 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:55:43 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:56:01 2009  begin with 76940156 relations and 52513479 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 21:57:33 2009  reduce to 76922162 relations and 51898924 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 21:57:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 21:59:06 2009  removing 998577 relations and 598577 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 21:59:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 21:59:26 2009  begin with 75923585 relations and 51898924 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:00:57 2009  reduce to 75905399 relations and 51281743 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:00:57 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:02:28 2009  removing 1003485 relations and 603485 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:02:31 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:02:48 2009  begin with 74901914 relations and 51281743 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:04:39 2009  reduce to 74884152 relations and 50660089 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:04:39 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:06:09 2009  removing 1008363 relations and 608363 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:06:11 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:06:28 2009  begin with 73875789 relations and 50660089 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:07:55 2009  reduce to 73858205 relations and 50033756 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:07:55 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:09:24 2009  removing 1012676 relations and 612676 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:09:27 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:09:43 2009  begin with 72845529 relations and 50033756 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:11:30 2009  reduce to 72827262 relations and 49402415 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:11:30 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:12:57 2009  removing 1016504 relations and 616504 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:13:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:13:17 2009  begin with 71810758 relations and 49402415 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:14:41 2009  reduce to 71792547 relations and 48767297 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:14:41 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:16:06 2009  removing 1020668 relations and 620668 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:16:09 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:16:25 2009  begin with 70771879 relations and 48767297 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:17:48 2009  reduce to 70753629 relations and 48128034 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:17:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:19:13 2009  removing 1025882 relations and 625882 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:19:15 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:19:31 2009  begin with 69727747 relations and 48128034 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:21:33 2009  reduce to 69709497 relations and 47483574 ideals in 6 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:21:33 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:22:57 2009  removing 1031222 relations and 631222 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:22:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:23:15 2009  begin with 68678275 relations and 47483574 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:24:34 2009  reduce to 68660019 relations and 46833758 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:24:34 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:25:56 2009  removing 1036534 relations and 636534 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:25:59 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:26:14 2009  begin with 67623485 relations and 46833758 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:27:32 2009  reduce to 67605230 relations and 46178650 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:27:32 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:28:52 2009  removing 1041735 relations and 641735 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:28:55 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:29:10 2009  begin with 66563495 relations and 46178650 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:30:25 2009  reduce to 66545605 relations and 45518727 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:30:25 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:31:43 2009  removing 1049040 relations and 649040 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:31:46 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:32:00 2009  begin with 65496565 relations and 45518727 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:33:14 2009  reduce to 65478880 relations and 44851696 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:33:14 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:34:30 2009  removing 1054549 relations and 654549 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:34:33 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:34:47 2009  begin with 64424331 relations and 44851696 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:36:00 2009  reduce to 64406830 relations and 44179388 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:36:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:37:15 2009  removing 1061147 relations and 661147 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:37:17 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:37:31 2009  begin with 63345683 relations and 44179388 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:39:00 2009  reduce to 63327886 relations and 43500179 ideals in 5 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:39:00 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:40:14 2009  removing 1067388 relations and 667388 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:40:16 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:40:30 2009  begin with 62260498 relations and 43500179 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:41:38 2009  reduce to 62242919 relations and 42814958 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:41:38 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 20
Sun Feb  1 22:42:51 2009  removing 1073113 relations and 673113 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:42:53 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:43:07 2009  begin with 61169806 relations and 42814958 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:44:15 2009  reduce to 61151873 relations and 42123638 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:44:15 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 19
Sun Feb  1 22:45:26 2009  removing 1080407 relations and 680407 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:45:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:45:41 2009  begin with 60071466 relations and 42123638 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:46:48 2009  reduce to 60053299 relations and 41424834 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:46:48 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Feb  1 22:47:57 2009  removing 1088132 relations and 688132 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:48:00 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:48:12 2009  begin with 58965167 relations and 41424834 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:49:17 2009  reduce to 58946826 relations and 40718130 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:49:17 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Feb  1 22:50:26 2009  removing 1093898 relations and 693898 ideals in 400000 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:50:28 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:50:41 2009  begin with 57852928 relations and 40718130 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:51:44 2009  reduce to 57834256 relations and 40005293 ideals in 4 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:51:44 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 18
Sun Feb  1 22:52:52 2009  removing 436353 relations and 305695 ideals in 130658 cliques
Sun Feb  1 22:52:54 2009  commencing in-memory singleton removal
Sun Feb  1 22:53:06 2009  begin with 57397903 relations and 40005293 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:53:53 2009  reduce to 57396290 relations and 39697984 ideals in 3 passes
Sun Feb  1 22:53:53 2009  max relations containing the same ideal: 17
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 0 large ideals: 1928236
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 1 large ideals: 9270275
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 2 large ideals: 19342283
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 3 large ideals: 17893528
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 4 large ideals: 7505002
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 5 large ideals: 1279863
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 6 large ideals: 82167
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  relations with 7+ large ideals: 94936
Sun Feb  1 22:54:11 2009  commencing 2-way merge
Sun Feb  1 22:55:34 2009  reduce to 44604102 relation sets and 26905796 unique ideals
Sun Feb  1 22:55:34 2009  commencing full merge
Sun Feb  1 23:07:37 2009  memory use: 2382.7 MB
Sun Feb  1 23:07:55 2009  found 23278883 cycles, need 20837996
Sun Feb  1 23:08:18 2009  weight of 20837996 cycles is about 1458949995 (70.01/cycle)
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  1 relations: 2335885
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  2 relations: 2315391
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  3 relations: 2817061
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  4 relations: 2873939
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  5 relations: 2817359
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  6 relations: 2485857
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  7 relations: 2099823
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  8 relations: 1624290
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  9 relations: 1194075
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  10+ relations: 274316
Sun Feb  1 23:08:20 2009  heaviest cycle: 12 relations
Sun Feb  1 23:08:24 2009  commencing cycle optimization
Sun Feb  1 23:13:07 2009  start with 97103058 relations
Sun Feb  1 23:20:05 2009  pruned 3907703 relations
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  memory use: 3185.7 MB
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  distribution of cycle lengths:
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  1 relations: 2335885
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  2 relations: 2417242
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  3 relations: 3018928
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  4 relations: 3085775
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  5 relations: 3029267
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  6 relations: 2579681
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  7 relations: 2048652
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  8 relations: 1389575
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  9 relations: 788398
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  10+ relations: 144593
Sun Feb  1 23:20:07 2009  heaviest cycle: 12 relations
Sun Feb  1 23:21:31 2009  
Sun Feb  1 23:21:53 2009  commencing linear algebra
Sun Feb  1 23:21:58 2009  read 20837996 cycles
Sun Feb  1 23:32:25 2009  cycles contain 52144944 unique relations
Mon Feb  2 00:03:05 2009  read 52144944 relations
Mon Feb  2 00:07:23 2009  using 20 quadratic characters above 4294965230
Mon Feb  2 00:15:50 2009  building initial matrix
Mon Feb  2 01:35:31 2009  memory use: 7023.4 MB
Mon Feb  2 01:35:56 2009  read 20837996 cycles
Mon Feb  2 01:36:58 2009  matrix is 20831243 x 20837996 (6070.8 MB) with weight 1762636812 (84.59/col)
Mon Feb  2 01:36:58 2009  sparse part has weight 1383052206 (66.37/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:03:44 2009  filtering completed in 3 passes
Mon Feb  2 02:03:54 2009  matrix is 20719215 x 20719414 (6052.3 MB) with weight 1756998246 (84.80/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:03:54 2009  sparse part has weight 1379387651 (66.57/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:06:22 2009  read 20719414 cycles
Mon Feb  2 02:06:47 2009  matrix is 20719215 x 20719414 (6052.3 MB) with weight 1756998246 (84.80/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:06:47 2009  sparse part has weight 1379387651 (66.57/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:06:48 2009  saving the first 48 matrix rows for later
Mon Feb  2 02:07:09 2009  matrix is 20719167 x 20719414 (5823.3 MB) with weight 1403447496 (67.74/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:07:11 2009  sparse part has weight 1319341229 (63.68/col)
Mon Feb  2 02:07:11 2009  matrix includes 64 packed rows
Mon Feb  2 02:07:11 2009  using block size 65536 for processor cache size 2048 kB
Mon Feb  2 02:10:26 2009  commencing Lanczos iteration (8 threads)
Mon Feb  2 02:10:26 2009  memory use: 6880.1 MB

Batalov · 2009-02-13, 20:29

Did you by any chance test it with the dump.c ?

this may tell you if 2.5 months will do any good (1.39 should build better matrices in this sense than 1.38, however it doesn't hurt to test the final matrix, the one after the -nc3 did some cleaning on it and started BL).

Just as a reminder dump.c doesn't do all the job; you'd need some other trivial tools to post-process.
./dump -n will raise a red flag right away if there are empty columns, but for a fine analysis, you may want to dump all matrix into a file and then
sort |uniq -c | awk '$1>1' |wc -l

bdodson · 2009-02-23, 18:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by frmky

Just realized that I forgot to post an update. I trimmed the total relations to just under 487M, effectively throwing the rest away, and ran with msieve 1.39. This produced the best matrix yet, 20.7M x 20.7M. ...

This was after

Code:

found 2889 duplicates and 559633687 unique relations

and an extended, difficult effort on Greg's part. Is this still our
current best practice for snfs with double 32-bit large primes?
Stop sieving < 500M unique?

How difficult would it be to have msieve detect that there aren't
going to be enough cliques, and delete the heaviest relations
(above 720K, would seem to fit best; but a larger value, like 200M
or so, if needed)?

-Bruce (The number in question is/was 2,908+ C268,
of difficulty 274.)

jasonp · 2009-02-23, 19:47

I've been thinking about this problem a lot. Believe me, nobody should have to try to get a good matrix over and over again from a huge dataset, at 2 weeks for each filtering run. It's easy to detect when there is too much excess (the cliques run out :) and would also be easy to discard relations. But even then you get a situation like Greg had, where extreme excess causes too many duplicate columns anyway, which the code cannot deal with short of deliberately asking for too much excess and then pruning it off when building the matrix.

The whole reason this process is painful is because the filtering deliberately hides information about the dataset from itself, in order to make it easier to fit the whole job into memory. If there was an easy way to spill excess data to disk and read it back when needed, then that hiding wouldn't be necessary. I realized that a hashtable-based data structure that uses disk as backing store, caches lookups, and allows different data views has a shorter name: a database. The more complex the code for providing all these features becomes, the more the right way to proceed should be to use something like Berkeley DB to store all the factors of all relations, then pull out whatever part of the current set of relations is needed. That's ironic, because GGNFS is going the opposite way right now (relations are deposited in binary files to save disk space, but disk space is cheap so Chris is going to store them as text now :)

R.D. Silverman · 2009-02-23, 20:37

Quote:

Originally Posted by jasonp

The whole reason this process is painful is because the filtering deliberately hides information about the dataset from itself, in order to make it easier to fit the whole job into memory. If there was an easy way to spill excess data to disk and read it back when needed)

The CWI filter does spill the data to disk........

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Bug/oddity reports	fivemack	NFS@Home	1	2015-01-30 11:34
Attempts vs. Successes oddity	Rodrigo	GPU Computing	8	2014-09-19 08:44
Another server(?) oddity	Graff	PrimeNet	2	2010-01-25 17:00
Smaller filtering run oddity	10metreh	Msieve	17	2009-01-05 14:58
Self-test oddity	JuanTutors	Software	1	2007-03-16 12:33

2009-01-04, 15:40	#12
jasonp Tribal Bullet Oct 2004 3,541 Posts	Jeez, you have so many excess relations that you ran out of cliques with size < 8, and still had too much excess (only by a little though). You can force the merge phase to run by changing the 'exit(-1);' call on line 654 of gnfs/filter/clique.c to 'break;'. But the target excess is ~14.8M, about 1M smaller than with 2 clique passes, so I don't expect the final matrix to be of size < 22.5M if you got 25.6M before. It looks like one should not give up if there are no cliques left, but instead should start deleting relations. Presumably they should get deleted in order of decreasing weight, but if there's too much excess now then you shouldn't have to worry much about preserving sparsity. As a quick fix, you can change the following at line 133 of gnfs/filter.c: Code: filtmin_r = filtmin_a = nfs_purge_duplicates(obj, &fb, 0); if (obj->nfs_lower) filtmin_r = obj->nfs_lower; if (obj->nfs_upper) filtmin_a = obj->nfs_upper; into Code: filtmin_r = filtmin_a = nfs_purge_duplicates(obj, &fb, obj->nfs_upper); and then run the filtering using '-nc1 0,X' where X is the number of relations you want to keep. This saves having to manually generate hard-drive-size data files over and over again. Sucks that filtering runs will still take a week though; if you want to save lots of time, we can modify the code to output temporary files after clique processing, and start from those files as long as X only increases. That should save having to run most of the clique processing every time. Is the 22.5M matrix running now, or are you waiting to get a better matrix? I realize it's painful to ask that you do stuff like this.

2009-01-20, 15:14	#17
jasonp Tribal Bullet Oct 2004 3,541 Posts	My guess is that the matrix has too many columns that would be empty after the matrix was preprocessed. If that's true, then v1.38 would give you a usable matrix but the linear algebra would fail. The only solution would be to have more cycles when the filtering completed; you did, but the code throws them away because it has no clue how much excess the matrix would really need. The easiest way to get those cycles back would be to run the filtering with a large value of NUM_EXTRA_RELATIONS in gnfs/gnfs.h, maybe 100000. Of course, the fact that you need such a huge amount of excess means the filtering did a crappy job to begin with. Not sure what to do.

2009-02-13, 20:29	#19
Batalov "Serge" Mar 2008 Phi(4,2^7658614+1)/2 2505₁₆ Posts	Did you by any chance test it with the dump.c ? this may tell you if 2.5 months will do any good (1.39 should build better matrices in this sense than 1.38, however it doesn't hurt to test the final matrix, the one after the -nc3 did some cleaning on it and started BL). Just as a reminder dump.c doesn't do all the job; you'd need some other trivial tools to post-process. ./dump -n will raise a red flag right away if there are empty columns, but for a fine analysis, you may want to dump all matrix into a file and then sort \|uniq -c \| awk '$1>1' \|wc -l

2009-02-23, 19:47	#21
jasonp Tribal Bullet Oct 2004 3,541 Posts	I've been thinking about this problem a lot. Believe me, nobody should have to try to get a good matrix over and over again from a huge dataset, at 2 weeks for each filtering run. It's easy to detect when there is too much excess (the cliques run out :) and would also be easy to discard relations. But even then you get a situation like Greg had, where extreme excess causes too many duplicate columns anyway, which the code cannot deal with short of deliberately asking for too much excess and then pruning it off when building the matrix. The whole reason this process is painful is because the filtering deliberately hides information about the dataset from itself, in order to make it easier to fit the whole job into memory. If there was an easy way to spill excess data to disk and read it back when needed, then that hiding wouldn't be necessary. I realized that a hashtable-based data structure that uses disk as backing store, caches lookups, and allows different data views has a shorter name: a database. The more complex the code for providing all these features becomes, the more the right way to proceed should be to use something like Berkeley DB to store all the factors of all relations, then pull out whatever part of the current set of relations is needed. That's ironic, because GGNFS is going the opposite way right now (relations are deposited in binary files to save disk space, but disk space is cheap so Chris is going to store them as text now :)