Search For Stats

russkris · 2005-11-05, 09:17

Hellooooo.

I am trying to put together a Team Stats page for as many DC projects as possible, I was wondering if you have the time could post a few stat sites for me. If they could be in some form of auto update format like XML or TXT, that would be great but if not I can try and work with whatever your knid selves can come up with

Lone Mersenne Hunter
Factoring
15k Search
NFSNET
Prime Sierpinski Search
3*2^n-1 Search
ElevenSmooth
Sierpinski/Riesel Base 5
PSearch
Riesel Prime Search
Operation Billion Digit

Are all the Sierpinski project the one and the same or are they different projects? Same with the Riesel ones, there are so many...

Any help would be great, Thank you for taking the time to read mt post

Rusty

wblipp · 2005-11-05, 15:41

ElevenSmooth is an ECM Server based project. Most of these projects don't provide competitive statistics because nobody has figured out a reasonable and reasonably secure method of scoring. Points based on the number of ECM curves run would be trivial to fake and hard to detect. Points based on factors found would have a large luck component and, in most cases, scoring opportunities would be far apart.

William

akruppa · 2005-11-05, 16:08

It'd be easy to verify correctness of the number or curves reported by the contributors - make them submit all the end-of-stage-1 and end-of-stage-2 residues. If, say, 1% of the curves submitted are double-checked, any substantial amount of cheating would soon be detected. Once a factor of a number is found, all the end-of-stage-1 residues can be validated very quickly by using a point counting algorithm.

However, this would require considerable infrastructure on part of the project coordinator - almost all project doing ECM are probably too small to make the potential gain (more participants) worth the effort.

Alex

russkris · 2005-11-06, 04:26

Great, thank you so much for reply to my post.....
Even though I have a hole that need to be filled but then again, your help has filled that for me

Many thank yous for your time and effort to post

If ya ever in the Team Ninja area pop in and have a chat, you never know you might spark som more interest
Team Ninja Forum
RUsty

2005-11-05, 09:17	#1
russkris Nov 2005 Tasmania, Australia 2×11 Posts	Search For Stats Hellooooo. I am trying to put together a Team Stats page for as many DC projects as possible, I was wondering if you have the time could post a few stat sites for me. If they could be in some form of auto update format like XML or TXT, that would be great but if not I can try and work with whatever your knid selves can come up with Lone Mersenne Hunter Factoring 15k Search NFSNET Prime Sierpinski Search 32^n-1 Search ElevenSmooth Sierpinski/Riesel Base 5 PSearch Riesel Prime Search Operation Billion Digit Are all the Sierpinski project the one and the same or are they different projects? Same with the Riesel ones, there are so many... Any help would be great, Thank you for taking the time to read mt post Rusty Last fiddled with by russkris on 2005-11-05 at 09:18*

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Overall Stats	Fred	PrimeNet	7	2016-02-10 14:48
CSVs for stats available + New combined stats	opyrt	Prime Sierpinski Project	3	2010-05-31 08:13
Stats	em99010pepe	Sierpinski/Riesel Base 5	66	2008-02-06 19:42
stats on 15k	jocelynl	15k Search	5	2004-01-13 15:45
P4 On Stats	HiddenWarrior	Hardware	2	2003-08-13 14:39

2005-11-05, 15:41	#2
wblipp "William" May 2003 New Haven 2366₁₀ Posts	ElevenSmooth is an ECM Server based project. Most of these projects don't provide competitive statistics because nobody has figured out a reasonable and reasonably secure method of scoring. Points based on the number of ECM curves run would be trivial to fake and hard to detect. Points based on factors found would have a large luck component and, in most cases, scoring opportunities would be far apart. William

2005-11-05, 16:08	#3
akruppa "Nancy" Aug 2002 Alexandria 2,467 Posts	It'd be easy to verify correctness of the number or curves reported by the contributors - make them submit all the end-of-stage-1 and end-of-stage-2 residues. If, say, 1% of the curves submitted are double-checked, any substantial amount of cheating would soon be detected. Once a factor of a number is found, all the end-of-stage-1 residues can be validated very quickly by using a point counting algorithm. However, this would require considerable infrastructure on part of the project coordinator - almost all project doing ECM are probably too small to make the potential gain (more participants) worth the effort. Alex

2005-11-06, 04:26	#4
russkris Nov 2005 Tasmania, Australia 10110₂ Posts	Great, thank you so much for reply to my post..... Even though I have a hole that need to be filled but then again, your help has filled that for me Many thank yous for your time and effort to post If ya ever in the Team Ninja area pop in and have a chat, you never know you might spark som more interest Team Ninja Forum RUsty