Strategic Double Clicking - Page 162

kriesel · 2018-11-10, 17:09

For those who prefer to run strategic double checks over first-time bin gap LL tests, there are plenty of million range of exponent value bins (116 and up) with double check assignments available that could be reserved and run. Getting double checks matching the respective first-checks in each bin supports confidence in whatever software and hardware was used for each. Please reserve and run from any of the following. Note these will definitely each be more time consuming than usual double checks. (Time is proportional to a bit higher than exponent squared. M112m is a little over 8 days on a GTX1080.)
116
118
122
123
124
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
134
137
138
141
144
145
146
148
149
151
152
153
155
157
164
165
167
176
177
188
189
(end of post)

GP2 · 2018-11-10, 17:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by nofaith628

Haven't seen this post updated for a while. Pinging Madpoo, any double checks that need churning?

I'm not madpoo, but here's a few suggestions if anyone wants to try them:

Code:

DoubleCheck=46883119,73,1
DoubleCheck=52598239,73,1
DoubleCheck=75619127,75,1
DoubleCheck=75619177,75,1
DoubleCheck=75619429,75,1
DoubleCheck=77942911,75,1
DoubleCheck=80631689,75,1
DoubleCheck=81384757,75,1
DoubleCheck=82459973,75,1
DoubleCheck=82608247,75,1
DoubleCheck=82946557,75,1
DoubleCheck=83600753,76,1

The 75.6 M exponents have a first-time test with shift count 0, so they should only be done with mprime or CUDAlucas and not with Mlucas or other software that doesn't do shift counts.

Madpoo · 2018-11-11, 06:47

New list... this one is the top 100 as ranked by their bad/good ratios, no limit on the exponent size. There are some machines out there doing first time tests that have terrible track records (lifetime records of 7 bad, zero good, etc). The bad/good #'s I show are their totals for the year that result was recorded, but I'm actually taking into account their lifetime bad/good ratios as the first sort, and then their per-year ratio as a secondary sort.

Code:

exponent	Bad	Good	worktodo
79192753	1	0	DoubleCheck=79192753,75,1
79387531	1	0	DoubleCheck=79387531,75,1
79388899	1	0	DoubleCheck=79388899,75,1
79439443	1	0	DoubleCheck=79439443,75,1
79503751	7	1	DoubleCheck=79503751,75,1
79821853	7	1	DoubleCheck=79821853,75,1
80658197	7	1	DoubleCheck=80658197,75,1
80901703	5	1	DoubleCheck=80901703,75,1
81008069	5	1	DoubleCheck=81008069,75,1
81160369	5	1	DoubleCheck=81160369,75,1
81727967	2	0	DoubleCheck=81727967,75,1
81932677	2	0	DoubleCheck=81932677,75,1
82700687	2	0	DoubleCheck=82700687,76,1
82773133	2	0	DoubleCheck=82773133,75,1
83082589	2	0	DoubleCheck=83082589,76,1
83413117	2	0	DoubleCheck=83413117,76,1
83911159	2	0	DoubleCheck=83911159,76,1
84149003	2	0	DoubleCheck=84149003,76,1
84312323	2	0	DoubleCheck=84312323,76,1
84461743	2	0	DoubleCheck=84461743,76,1
80793373	5	0	DoubleCheck=80793373,75,1
81474143	5	0	DoubleCheck=81474143,75,1
79970881	3	0	DoubleCheck=79970881,75,1
79978963	3	0	DoubleCheck=79978963,75,1
76583567	5	1	DoubleCheck=76583567,75,1
79329781	5	1	DoubleCheck=79329781,75,1
79461209	5	1	DoubleCheck=79461209,75,1
81145417	5	1	DoubleCheck=81145417,75,1
78441703	4	2	DoubleCheck=78441703,75,1
78453721	4	2	DoubleCheck=78453721,75,1
79096727	4	2	DoubleCheck=79096727,75,1
79176359	4	2	DoubleCheck=79176359,75,1
79444987	4	2	DoubleCheck=79444987,75,1
79465693	4	2	DoubleCheck=79465693,75,1
80287133	4	2	DoubleCheck=80287133,75,1
80474599	4	2	DoubleCheck=80474599,75,1
80897771	0	0	DoubleCheck=80897771,75,1
80963833	0	0	DoubleCheck=80963833,75,1
79461373	8	2	DoubleCheck=79461373,75,1
79662641	8	2	DoubleCheck=79662641,75,1
79725799	8	2	DoubleCheck=79725799,75,1
78769081	4	0	DoubleCheck=78769081,75,1
57025753	1	0	DoubleCheck=57025753,73,1
81083059	4	1	DoubleCheck=81083059,75,1
78918677	2	0	DoubleCheck=78918677,75,1
80086553	2	0	DoubleCheck=80086553,75,1
80199569	2	1	DoubleCheck=80199569,75,1
80643691	2	1	DoubleCheck=80643691,75,1
81339199	2	1	DoubleCheck=81339199,75,1
82227571	2	1	DoubleCheck=82227571,75,1
82948039	2	1	DoubleCheck=82948039,76,1
83155747	2	0	DoubleCheck=83155747,76,1
83357597	2	1	DoubleCheck=83357597,76,1
84081341	2	0	DoubleCheck=84081341,76,1
84149843	2	1	DoubleCheck=84149843,76,1
84436007	2	0	DoubleCheck=84436007,76,1
84466973	2	1	DoubleCheck=84466973,76,1
85034359	2	1	DoubleCheck=85034359,76,1
80036111	0	1	DoubleCheck=80036111,75,1
80059927	0	1	DoubleCheck=80059927,75,1
80090809	0	1	DoubleCheck=80090809,75,1
79225789	5	2	DoubleCheck=79225789,75,1
79344277	5	2	DoubleCheck=79344277,75,1
80956769	5	2	DoubleCheck=80956769,75,1
81019927	5	2	DoubleCheck=81019927,75,1
81492409	5	2	DoubleCheck=81492409,75,1
81779771	2	0	DoubleCheck=81779771,75,1
81931133	2	0	DoubleCheck=81931133,76,1
82669403	2	0	DoubleCheck=82669403,75,1
82952587	2	0	DoubleCheck=82952587,76,1
83089729	2	0	DoubleCheck=83089729,76,1
84082027	2	0	DoubleCheck=84082027,76,1
84231919	2	0	DoubleCheck=84231919,76,1
84473933	2	0	DoubleCheck=84473933,76,1
84557723	2	0	DoubleCheck=84557723,76,1
84995717	2	0	DoubleCheck=84995717,76,1
81848131	0	1	DoubleCheck=81848131,75,1
84129949	0	1	DoubleCheck=84129949,76,1
84210359	0	1	DoubleCheck=84210359,76,1
81250891	3	0	DoubleCheck=81250891,75,1
79607023	1	0	DoubleCheck=79607023,75,1
76523653	3	1	DoubleCheck=76523653,75,1
76799647	3	1	DoubleCheck=76799647,75,1
78527623	3	1	DoubleCheck=78527623,75,1
78970819	3	1	DoubleCheck=78970819,75,1
79037461	3	1	DoubleCheck=79037461,75,1
79096763	3	1	DoubleCheck=79096763,75,1
79399267	3	1	DoubleCheck=79399267,75,1
79475129	3	1	DoubleCheck=79475129,75,1
79501943	3	1	DoubleCheck=79501943,75,1
79516421	3	1	DoubleCheck=79516421,75,1
79567613	3	1	DoubleCheck=79567613,75,1
79629169	3	1	DoubleCheck=79629169,75,1
79651189	3	1	DoubleCheck=79651189,75,1
79680749	3	1	DoubleCheck=79680749,75,1
79696711	3	1	DoubleCheck=79696711,75,1
79697143	3	1	DoubleCheck=79697143,75,1
79795663	3	1	DoubleCheck=79795663,75,1
79827173	3	1	DoubleCheck=79827173,75,1
79893883	3	1	DoubleCheck=79893883,75,1

Madpoo · 2018-11-11, 06:50

And this is another list where I limited the exponent size to < 58M. The first one on the list actually shows up in the previous list (4 bad, zero good lifetime ratio) but that's the only overlap. These might be good if people are looking for more bite-size exponents to speculatively double-check.

Code:

exponent	Bad	Good	worktodo
57025753	1	0	DoubleCheck=57025753,73,1
57089849	0	1	DoubleCheck=57089849,73,1
53016083	12	11	DoubleCheck=53016083,73,1
53351911	12	11	DoubleCheck=53351911,73,1
54918671	12	11	DoubleCheck=54918671,73,1
54994363	12	11	DoubleCheck=54994363,73,1
55395607	12	11	DoubleCheck=55395607,73,1
55425943	12	11	DoubleCheck=55425943,73,1
55664387	12	11	DoubleCheck=55664387,73,1
56091569	12	11	DoubleCheck=56091569,73,1
56112317	12	11	DoubleCheck=56112317,74,1
56180669	12	11	DoubleCheck=56180669,74,1
57442519	12	11	DoubleCheck=57442519,74,1
57566147	12	11	DoubleCheck=57566147,73,1
57566239	12	11	DoubleCheck=57566239,73,1
57840049	12	11	DoubleCheck=57840049,73,1
57076927	1	0	DoubleCheck=57076927,73,1
57076499	0	0	DoubleCheck=57076499,73,1
57076577	0	0	DoubleCheck=57076577,73,1
57140123	0	1	DoubleCheck=57140123,73,1
51129479	1	0	DoubleCheck=51129479,73,1
51746509	1	0	DoubleCheck=51746509,73,1
52228751	1	0	DoubleCheck=52228751,73,1
52229707	1	0	DoubleCheck=52229707,73,1
52550627	1	0	DoubleCheck=52550627,73,1
54329549	1	0	DoubleCheck=54329549,73,1
55338823	1	0	DoubleCheck=55338823,73,1
55971287	1	0	DoubleCheck=55971287,74,1
57465407	1	0	DoubleCheck=57465407,74,1
52121599	0	0	DoubleCheck=52121599,73,1
54144901	0	0	DoubleCheck=54144901,73,1
54886759	0	0	DoubleCheck=54886759,73,1
56540711	0	0	DoubleCheck=56540711,74,1
57943741	1	1	DoubleCheck=57943741,73,1
52581167	0	1	DoubleCheck=52581167,73,1
57129329	0	1	DoubleCheck=57129329,73,1
57364129	0	0	DoubleCheck=57364129,73,1
56311001	0	13	DoubleCheck=56311001,74,1
57385249	0	13	DoubleCheck=57385249,73,1
57095561	9	4	DoubleCheck=57095561,73,1
51890849	40	50	DoubleCheck=51890849,73,1
51980959	40	50	DoubleCheck=51980959,73,1
52733207	40	50	DoubleCheck=52733207,73,1
46482367	10	12	DoubleCheck=46482367,73,1
57830683	0	1	DoubleCheck=57830683,73,1
51255637	1	1	DoubleCheck=51255637,73,1
52054069	1	1	DoubleCheck=52054069,73,1
52234961	1	1	DoubleCheck=52234961,73,1
54861283	1	1	DoubleCheck=54861283,73,1
54919021	1	1	DoubleCheck=54919021,73,1
54947063	1	1	DoubleCheck=54947063,73,1
55337207	1	1	DoubleCheck=55337207,73,1
55353227	1	1	DoubleCheck=55353227,75,1
55821011	1	1	DoubleCheck=55821011,73,1
55880711	1	1	DoubleCheck=55880711,73,1
55995971	1	1	DoubleCheck=55995971,74,1
57200953	1	1	DoubleCheck=57200953,73,1
57295267	4	5	DoubleCheck=57295267,73,1
49111229	3	4	DoubleCheck=49111229,73,1
49111519	3	4	DoubleCheck=49111519,73,1
49112053	3	4	DoubleCheck=49112053,73,1
49112071	3	4	DoubleCheck=49112071,73,1
49413929	3	4	DoubleCheck=49413929,73,1
49414271	3	4	DoubleCheck=49414271,73,1
49901167	3	4	DoubleCheck=49901167,73,1
54004051	0	0	DoubleCheck=54004051,73,1
54023513	0	0	DoubleCheck=54023513,73,1
54025339	0	0	DoubleCheck=54025339,74,1
54784801	0	0	DoubleCheck=54784801,73,1
55659047	0	0	DoubleCheck=55659047,73,1
55663999	0	0	DoubleCheck=55663999,73,1
55672153	0	0	DoubleCheck=55672153,74,1
55677481	0	0	DoubleCheck=55677481,74,1
56607413	0	1	DoubleCheck=56607413,74,1
57934139	0	0	DoubleCheck=57934139,73,1
56193937	0	0	DoubleCheck=56193937,74,1
56194981	0	0	DoubleCheck=56194981,74,1
56202719	0	0	DoubleCheck=56202719,73,1
56223533	0	0	DoubleCheck=56223533,73,1
54978067	8	13	DoubleCheck=54978067,73,1
55169113	8	13	DoubleCheck=55169113,73,1
55169291	8	13	DoubleCheck=55169291,73,1
55174201	8	13	DoubleCheck=55174201,73,1
55178381	8	13	DoubleCheck=55178381,73,1
55179437	8	13	DoubleCheck=55179437,73,1
55185563	8	13	DoubleCheck=55185563,73,1
57100891	8	13	DoubleCheck=57100891,73,1
54715939	0	0	DoubleCheck=54715939,73,1
55759801	0	0	DoubleCheck=55759801,73,1
48631321	6	38	DoubleCheck=48631321,73,1
51833449	6	8	DoubleCheck=51833449,73,1
51922289	6	8	DoubleCheck=51922289,73,1
56033161	6	8	DoubleCheck=56033161,73,1
51663749	3	4	DoubleCheck=51663749,73,1
51789541	3	4	DoubleCheck=51789541,73,1
52088381	3	4	DoubleCheck=52088381,73,1
55385023	3	4	DoubleCheck=55385023,73,1
55869239	3	4	DoubleCheck=55869239,73,1
57580681	3	4	DoubleCheck=57580681,73,1
54936667	1	3	DoubleCheck=54936667,73,1

Mark Rose · 2018-11-11, 08:16

I took the one from both lists, 57025753.

nofaith628 · 2018-11-11, 19:10

I queued the exponents from GP2.

Code:

DoubleCheck=46883119,73,1
DoubleCheck=52598239,73,1
DoubleCheck=75619127,75,1
DoubleCheck=75619177,75,1
DoubleCheck=75619429,75,1
DoubleCheck=77942911,75,1
DoubleCheck=80631689,75,1
DoubleCheck=81384757,75,1
DoubleCheck=82459973,75,1
DoubleCheck=82608247,75,1
DoubleCheck=82946557,75,1
DoubleCheck=83600753,76,1

GP2 · 2018-11-11, 21:08

Quote:

Originally Posted by nofaith628

I queued the exponents from GP2.

Someone else already grabbed 52598239 yesterday...

Dylan14 · 2018-11-11, 23:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by kriesel

Hi,

As a low priority subproject, I've been filling the double-check gaps in the work distribution map at https://www.mersenne.org/primenet/. That is, where there is a range of 1 million in exponent value (which I'll call a bin) where there's a double check assignment available but none completed, I run one. The theory is that it might possibly smoke out a reliability problem at higher fft length than the current wavefront, in time to address it, since most first checks will have been done by prime95/mprime, and the double checks I run are CUDALucas 2.06 beta. I've been doing them in ascending order, since 84M in mid 2017, so that now all bins up to 111 million have at least 1 matching doublecheck indicated. (See https://www.mersenne.org/report_ll/?...exfactor=1&B1=) 112 is under way and 114 queued. Meanwhile the wavefront of new first LL assignments is ~81M-88M.

The following bins below 200M have no first-time LL test reported, so no double check assignment available. It would be good if some volunteers collectively ran first-time checks on at least one exponent in each of these million-range bins so that double checks could become available in them. In the list below, the bins are abbreviated, for example, "115" means the exponent range 115,000,000-115,999,999. Note these will definitely each be more time consuming than usual double checks (time is proportional to a bit higher than exponent squared; M112m is a little over 8 days on a GTX1080.)
(snip a bunch of numbers)
(there are more above 199M, of course, which can wait.)

I took the smallest available exponent in the 135M block.

Uncwilly · 2018-11-26, 15:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Madpoo

And this is another list where I limited the exponent size to < 58M. The first one on the list actually shows up in the previous list (4 bad, zero good lifetime ratio) but that's the only overlap. These might be good if people are looking for more bite-size exponents to speculatively double-check.

I looked to grab the lowest off the list and found that several were already assigned. Here is an unsearched list of those that I haven't grabbed or found assigned:

Code:

DoubleCheck=51129479,73,1
DoubleCheck=51255637,73,1
DoubleCheck=51663749,73,1
DoubleCheck=51746509,73,1
DoubleCheck=51789541,73,1
DoubleCheck=51833449,73,1
DoubleCheck=51890849,73,1
DoubleCheck=51922289,73,1
DoubleCheck=51980959,73,1
DoubleCheck=52054069,73,1
DoubleCheck=52088381,73,1
DoubleCheck=52121599,73,1
DoubleCheck=52228751,73,1
DoubleCheck=52229707,73,1
DoubleCheck=52234961,73,1
DoubleCheck=52550627,73,1
DoubleCheck=52581167,73,1
DoubleCheck=52733207,73,1
DoubleCheck=53016083,73,1
DoubleCheck=53351911,73,1
DoubleCheck=54004051,73,1
DoubleCheck=54023513,73,1
DoubleCheck=54025339,74,1
DoubleCheck=54144901,73,1
DoubleCheck=54329549,73,1
DoubleCheck=54715939,73,1
DoubleCheck=54784801,73,1
DoubleCheck=54861283,73,1
DoubleCheck=54886759,73,1
DoubleCheck=54918671,73,1
DoubleCheck=54919021,73,1
DoubleCheck=54936667,73,1
DoubleCheck=54947063,73,1
DoubleCheck=54978067,73,1
DoubleCheck=54994363,73,1
DoubleCheck=55169113,73,1
DoubleCheck=55169291,73,1
DoubleCheck=55174201,73,1
DoubleCheck=55178381,73,1
DoubleCheck=55179437,73,1
DoubleCheck=55185563,73,1
DoubleCheck=55337207,73,1
DoubleCheck=55338823,73,1
DoubleCheck=55353227,75,1
DoubleCheck=55385023,73,1
DoubleCheck=55395607,73,1
DoubleCheck=55425943,73,1
DoubleCheck=55659047,73,1
DoubleCheck=55663999,73,1
DoubleCheck=55664387,73,1
DoubleCheck=55672153,74,1
DoubleCheck=55677481,74,1
DoubleCheck=55759801,73,1
DoubleCheck=55821011,73,1
DoubleCheck=55869239,73,1
DoubleCheck=55880711,73,1
DoubleCheck=55971287,74,1
DoubleCheck=55995971,74,1
DoubleCheck=56033161,73,1
DoubleCheck=56091569,73,1
DoubleCheck=56112317,74,1
DoubleCheck=56180669,74,1
DoubleCheck=56193937,74,1
DoubleCheck=56194981,74,1
DoubleCheck=56202719,73,1
DoubleCheck=56223533,73,1
DoubleCheck=56311001,74,1
DoubleCheck=56540711,74,1
DoubleCheck=56607413,74,1
DoubleCheck=57025753,73,1
DoubleCheck=57076499,73,1
DoubleCheck=57076577,73,1
DoubleCheck=57076927,73,1
DoubleCheck=57089849,73,1
DoubleCheck=57095561,73,1
DoubleCheck=57100891,73,1
DoubleCheck=57129329,73,1
DoubleCheck=57140123,73,1
DoubleCheck=57200953,73,1
DoubleCheck=57295267,73,1
DoubleCheck=57364129,73,1
DoubleCheck=57385249,73,1
DoubleCheck=57442519,74,1
DoubleCheck=57465407,74,1
DoubleCheck=57566147,73,1
DoubleCheck=57566239,73,1
DoubleCheck=57580681,73,1
DoubleCheck=57830683,73,1
DoubleCheck=57840049,73,1
DoubleCheck=57934139,73,1
DoubleCheck=57943741,73,1

ET_ · 2018-11-26, 19:02

These are mine!

Code:

DoubleCheck=51129479,73,1
DoubleCheck=51255637,73,1

Luigi

GP2 · 2018-11-26, 21:04

Quote:

Originally Posted by ET_

These are mine!

Code:

DoubleCheck=51129479,73,1
DoubleCheck=51255637,73,1

Check again, I think Uncwilly was mistaken with his list, these were already assigned on 2018-11-12

2018-11-10, 17:09	#1772
kriesel "TF79LL86GIMPS96gpu17" Mar 2017 US midwest 3×7×257 Posts	Start bins with no individual double checks yet For those who prefer to run strategic double checks over first-time bin gap LL tests, there are plenty of million range of exponent value bins (116 and up) with double check assignments available that could be reserved and run. Getting double checks matching the respective first-checks in each bin supports confidence in whatever software and hardware was used for each. Please reserve and run from any of the following. Note these will definitely each be more time consuming than usual double checks. (Time is proportional to a bit higher than exponent squared. M112m is a little over 8 days on a GTX1080.) 116 118 122 123 124 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 134 137 138 141 144 145 146 148 149 151 152 153 155 157 164 165 167 176 177 188 189 (end of post) Last fiddled with by kriesel on 2018-11-10 at 17:36

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Double-Double Arithmetic	Mysticial	Software	52	2021-04-23 06:51
Clicking an exponent leads to 404 page	marigonzes	Information & Answers	2	2017-02-14 16:56
x.265 half the size, double the computation; so if you double again? 1/4th?	jasong	jasong	7	2015-08-17 10:56
What about double-checking TF/P-1?	137ben	PrimeNet	6	2012-03-13 04:01
Double the area, Double the volume.	Uncwilly	Puzzles	8	2006-07-03 16:02

2018-11-11, 08:16	#1776
Mark Rose "/X\(‘-‘)/X\" Jan 2013 2·5·293 Posts	I took the one from both lists, 57025753.

2018-11-26, 19:02	#1781
ET_ Banned "Luigi" Aug 2002 Team Italia 4816₁₀ Posts	These are mine! Code: DoubleCheck=51129479,73,1 DoubleCheck=51255637,73,1 Luigi