Attachments - Page 3

MisterBitcoin · 2017-02-02, 20:39

Make .npg great again!

If its no hard work for the admins please add NPG as allowed extension.

Oh, and pls make the file size limit a big greater. (2048 KB for examble)

pepi37 · 2017-02-02, 20:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by S485122

[(heavy]sarcasm] Indeed in the 21st century one does not bother about saving bandwidth, disk space or whatever any more, especially when others pay for it.

Then not limiting the allowed file extensions does not have the least impact on security.[/sarcasm]

Jacob

What malicious software cannot be packed in txt extension, rather then npg extension? Or in reverse order... Security is not reason here. Packing files and saving bandwidth when other pays: that is another story from extension story

rogue · 2017-02-02, 21:28

Compressing data files is not a hardship.

pepi37 · 2017-02-02, 21:40

Ok: it is not easy to change anything here: even one extension.

Drop my request, forget it...

Xyzzy · 2017-02-03, 00:20

The .npg file extension has been added.

S485122 · 2017-02-03, 00:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by pepi37

What malicious software cannot be packed in txt extension, rather then npg extension? Or in reverse order... Security is not reason here
...

My point about security was that it is good practice not to allow too many extensions (having a limited list of permitted extensions) rather than allowing any extension except those that are on an exclusion list. I do not dispute the fact that text and npg (or whatever) files can not be executed as such and thus do not pose a direct problem at the moment.

All in all, little used extensions can be modified by using a standard compression format, making it unnecessary to modify the forum settings. Of course some OS's do not rely on extensions.

Jacob

pepi37 · 2017-02-03, 08:24

Quote:

Originally Posted by Xyzzy

The .npg file extension has been added.

Thanks Xyzzy!

Mark Rose · 2017-02-03, 19:43

The extension really shouldn't matter, but there is a possibility the forum software is saving the file with the same extension in a web-accessible directory. That makes uploading .php files, for instance, problematic.

Xyzzy · 2017-02-04, 01:16

The forum software changes the name (and extension) of the file when it saves it.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
request for additional filetypes for attachments	mdettweiler	Forum Feedback	16	2009-08-12 05:57
Please post results as attachments from now on.	jasong	Octoproth Search	3	2007-06-10 21:08
Attachments!	Xyzzy	Lounge	5	2002-10-21 00:03

2017-02-02, 20:39	#23
MisterBitcoin "Nuri, the dragon :P" Jul 2016 Good old Germany 329₁₆ Posts	Make .npg great again! If its no hard work for the admins please add NPG as allowed extension. Oh, and pls make the file size limit a big greater. (2048 KB for examble)

2017-02-02, 21:28	#25
rogue "Mark" Apr 2003 Between here and the 11×577 Posts	Compressing data files is not a hardship.

2017-02-02, 21:40	#26
pepi37 Dec 2011 After milion nines:) 5·17² Posts	Ok: it is not easy to change anything here: even one extension. Drop my request, forget it...

2017-02-03, 00:20	#27
Xyzzy "Mike" Aug 2002 8224₁₀ Posts	The .npg file extension has been added.

2017-02-03, 19:43	#30
Mark Rose "/X\(‘-‘)/X\" Jan 2013 2²×733 Posts	The extension really shouldn't matter, but there is a possibility the forum software is saving the file with the same extension in a web-accessible directory. That makes uploading .php files, for instance, problematic.

2017-02-04, 01:16	#31
Xyzzy "Mike" Aug 2002 2⁵×257 Posts	The forum software changes the name (and extension) of the file when it saves it.