double check server online - Page 9

opyrt · 2009-12-30, 00:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sloth

It would be interesting to see if sending PG a double check range at the same time they do one of their challenges. Lots of tests done in a short time and short run times per test.

I agree! Probably more fun for the participants as well.

BTW: the PrimeGrid progress can be seen here: http://www.primegrid.com/stats_psp_llr.php

VJS · 2009-12-30, 03:26

The short test for a challenge might be a good idea.

I am somewhat with Joe on the keeping primegrid to the firstpass tests only as a rule.

The 2-3M test is not a bad idea and am certainly for it for one reason only... the perspective of the 2-3m test is showing if our current 1 or 2K approach is working.

I would say keep PG on firstpasses unless for some reason they request the short tests... especially since they are doing their own doublechecking.

Sloth · 2009-12-30, 03:53

The long tests for the challenge are nice since it really helps move the front edge of the tests forward. Also the long tests make life easier on the PG servers. Even the short tests are still 3-4 hours so server load might not be an issue for PG. Some of their other challenges are tests that are 30 min long.

I assume PG is doing their normal double checks now so the double check stuff they are doing now will actually be triple checks. If everything works out and no major problems are found I would like to see PG stay on first pass. That way we get first and second pass done and taken care of and do not waste time on a 3rd pass test.

Vato · 2009-12-30, 10:32

PG will only do a single DC test if the residue matches, but will fire off a 3rd (and potentially more) test until a matching residue is received.

opyrt · 2009-12-30, 11:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sloth

I assume PG is doing their normal double checks now so the double check stuff they are doing now will actually be triple checks. If everything works out and no major problems are found I would like to see PG stay on first pass. That way we get first and second pass done and taken care of and do not waste time on a 3rd pass test.

As Vato said, PG is not running double tests on all these double check cadidates. They are still quorum 2, but the residues from PSP first pass have been inserted as dummy results into the PrimeGrid system. So if one test is ran and it matches the result from here, no further tests are done on that candidate.

Joe O · 2010-01-02, 18:51

What a difference a week makes:

Code:

[n Range Total Tasks 	Done Tasks 	Unprepared Tasks 	Primes Found 
2M - 3M 14215 		9516 (66.94%) 	1992 			0

opyrt · 2010-01-02, 23:41

They've done (and are doing) a really great job for the project! Absolutely fantastic!

Vato · 2010-01-04, 10:48

Moved on to 3M-4M now...

n Range Total Tasks Done Tasks Unprepared Tasks Primes Found
2M - 3M 14215 11515 (81.01%) 0 0
3M - 4M 2967 0 (0%) 2842 0

Joe O · 2010-02-10, 15:42

Code:

n Range Total Tasks Done Tasks Unprepared Tasks Primes Found 
2M - 3M 14215 14196 (99.87%) 0 0 
3M - 4M 15803 15791 (99.92%) 0 0 
4M - 5M 19905 17863 (89.74%) 444 0 
5M - 6M 10487 10487 (100%) 0 0 
6M - 7M 6877 6877 (100%) 0 0 
7M - 8M 11702 11702 (100%) 0 0 
8M - 9M 9626 9608 (99.81%) 0 0 
9M - 10M 974 541 (55.54%) 416 0 
Total:   860 0

Joe O · 2010-02-10, 15:47

Code:

Task ID
click for details Computer Sent Time reported 
or deadline 
explain  Status Run time
(sec) CPU time
(sec) Claimed credit Granted credit Application 
143850626 --- 26 Dec 2009 4:20:06 UTC 26 Dec 2009 5:20:06 UTC Completed, waiting for validation 0.00 600.00 --- pending  
143850630 116456 26 Jan 2010 4:52:52 UTC 16 Feb 2010 4:52:52 UTC In progress --- --- --- --- Prime Sierpinski Problem (LLR) v5.11

The 21 day timeout for 2M-3M has cause some serious delay, and may still do so.
Th 7 day timeout for 3M-4M has allowed it to pass 2M-3M, and may allow it to complete first.

Joe O · 2010-02-13, 14:12

Code:

n Range Total Tasks Done Tasks Unprepared Tasks Primes Found 
2M - 3M 14215 14199 (99.89%) 0 0 
3M - 4M 15803 15797 (99.96%) 0 0 
4M - 5M 19905 19133 (96.12%) 0 0 
5M - 6M 18259 10544 (57.75%) 7184 0 
6M - 7M 6877 6877 (100%) 0 0 
7M - 8M 11702 11702 (100%) 0 0 
8M - 9M 9626 9614 (99.88%) 0 0 
9M - 10M 974 544 (55.85%) 416 0 
Total:   7600 0

Only 16 left in the 2M-3M range, and only 6 left in the 3M-4M range.

2010-01-02, 18:51	#94
Joe O Aug 2002 1000001101₂ Posts	What a difference a week makes: Code: [n Range Total Tasks Done Tasks Unprepared Tasks Primes Found 2M - 3M 14215 9516 (66.94%) 1992 0

2010-01-04, 10:48	#96
Vato Jan 2009 2²×5 Posts	Moved on to 3M-4M now... n Range Total Tasks Done Tasks Unprepared Tasks Primes Found 2M - 3M 14215 11515 (81.01%) 0 0 3M - 4M 2967 0 (0%) 2842 0 Last fiddled with by Vato on 2010-01-04 at 10:50

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
New SR5 PRPnet server online	ltd	Sierpinski/Riesel Base 5	15	2013-03-19 18:03
First PSP PRPnet 4.0.6 server online	ltd	Prime Sierpinski Project	9	2011-03-15 04:58
First check and double check llrnet servers.	opyrt	Prime Sierpinski Project	3	2009-01-02 01:50
Double-check check?	M0CZY	Software	15	2008-10-30 14:20
Double Check Server	Citrix	Prime Sierpinski Project	12	2005-10-23 20:03

2009-12-30, 03:26	#90
VJS Dec 2004 100101011₂ Posts	The short test for a challenge might be a good idea. I am somewhat with Joe on the keeping primegrid to the firstpass tests only as a rule. The 2-3M test is not a bad idea and am certainly for it for one reason only... the perspective of the 2-3m test is showing if our current 1 or 2K approach is working. I would say keep PG on firstpasses unless for some reason they request the short tests... especially since they are doing their own doublechecking.

2009-12-30, 03:53	#91
Sloth Mar 2006 2·47 Posts	The long tests for the challenge are nice since it really helps move the front edge of the tests forward. Also the long tests make life easier on the PG servers. Even the short tests are still 3-4 hours so server load might not be an issue for PG. Some of their other challenges are tests that are 30 min long. I assume PG is doing their normal double checks now so the double check stuff they are doing now will actually be triple checks. If everything works out and no major problems are found I would like to see PG stay on first pass. That way we get first and second pass done and taken care of and do not waste time on a 3rd pass test.

2009-12-30, 10:32	#92
Vato Jan 2009 2²·5 Posts	PG will only do a single DC test if the residue matches, but will fire off a 3rd (and potentially more) test until a matching residue is received.

2010-01-02, 23:41	#95
opyrt Apr 2008 Oslo, Norway 11011001₂ Posts	They've done (and are doing) a really great job for the project! Absolutely fantastic!