mersenneforum.org

mersenneforum.org (https://www.mersenneforum.org/index.php)
-   Data (https://www.mersenneforum.org/forumdisplay.php?f=21)
-   -   COMPLETE!!!! Thinking out loud about getting under 20M unfactored exponents (https://www.mersenneforum.org/showthread.php?t=22476)

masser 2022-04-16 14:47

Congrats!
 
[QUOTE=petrw1;604056]The last factor in this project was found at: 2022-04-16 03:07 UTC (by me :blush:)

Over these almost 5 years "the collective" found close to 60,000 factors.
On 2017/07/24 I initially identified 497 ranges under 60M that needed clearing.
Along with these there were about 28 other stubborn ranges from 60M to 108.3M that got caught up in our vortex.
In other words the help I received was beyond amazing.

P.S. I humbly reserve the right to add to this as I realize my oversights (5 years is way, way beyond my senior memory capabilities.)

:bow wave:[/QUOTE]

Do you have a list of the ranges and the number unfactored from when you began? A graph with original status and current status would be an interesting thing to see.

chalsall 2022-04-16 17:05

[QUOTE=petrw1;604056]The last factor in this project was found at: 2022-04-16 03:07 UTC (by me :blush:)[/QUOTE]

Fitting!!! :tu:

Thanks, Wayne for thinking of, and then coordinating, this massive undertaking.

It was absolutely amazing seeing the amount of firepower out there! Both GPU and CPU.

And, of course... George and 30.8. Mind-blowing! :bow:

petrw1 2022-04-17 19:39

[QUOTE=masser;604071]Do you have a list of the ranges and the number unfactored from when you began? A graph with original status and current status would be an interesting thing to see.[/QUOTE]

Started 2017-07-27

Each year's update is about the same date of each year.
See how quickly the last 9 months went with the late charge!!!
The totals at the end are remaining.

[CODE]Range 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021
1.8 5 0 0 0 0
2.0 23 0 0 0 0
2.1 43 0 0 0 0
2.3 61 0 0 0 0
2.4 56 36 9 0 0
2.5 39 0 0 0 0
2.6 141 92 78 0 0
2.7 46 23 11 0 0
2.8 173 139 118 0 0
2.9 72 50 36 0 0
3.0 98 23 0 0 0
3.1 190 156 95 54 0
3.2 145 138 111 61 0
3.3 74 72 38 0 0
3.4 131 130 102 99 0
3.5 92 91 76 55 0
3.6 178 171 165 113 0
3.7 102 98 86 86 0
3.8 188 172 148 147 0
3.9 92 78 68 57 0
4.0 99 76 33 13 0
4.1 194 170 141 141 9
4.2 109 72 52 52 0
4.3 164 139 71 71 0
4.4 139 110 110 104 76
4.5 122 79 75 74 0
4.6 164 79 66 66 0
4.7 107 94 73 72 65
4.8 83 48 44 44 0
4.9 91 64 55 51 0
5.0 112 76 73 72 0
5.1 113 66 32 24 0
5.2 237 204 162 155 130
5.3 109 78 5 0 0
5.4 223 195 177 116 82
5.5 192 162 151 113 96
5.6 138 116 104 43 0
5.7 136 102 90 63 0
5.8 137 108 93 48 0
5.9 148 130 120 84 84
6.0 181 137 107 82 55
6.1 171 151 130 80 66
6.2 157 139 138 82 68
6.3 92 64 63 15 0
6.4 134 119 119 92 73
6.5 185 164 129 93 73
6.6 174 160 136 99 76
6.7 149 123 105 75 0
6.8 198 174 165 132 89
6.9 181 157 136 94 61
7.0 179 147 147 109 108
7.1 167 133 133 109 106
7.2 167 136 136 94 87
7.3 214 182 182 136 117
7.4 92 74 74 58 58
7.5 113 83 83 60 0
7.6 146 120 120 62 0
7.7 197 165 165 116 116
7.8 178 155 149 133 109
7.9 89 63 52 29 0
8.0 130 106 91 66 0
8.1 207 178 167 139 138
8.2 198 182 181 135 135
8.3 147 111 111 84 0
8.4 156 137 137 111 92
8.5 171 153 147 126 125
8.6 240 224 220 193 192
8.7 178 160 160 130 129
8.8 79 52 52 26 0
8.9 139 120 120 99 97
9.0 116 109 95 74 0
9.1 199 199 192 172 103
9.2 161 161 156 138 114
9.3 74 74 71 41 0
9.4 99 99 96 83 77
9.5 183 183 176 152 150
9.6 105 105 94 75 0
9.7 172 172 164 145 145
9.8 179 179 178 152 150
9.9 197 177 170 150 148
10.0 192 166 156 128 0
10.1 138 100 94 71 0
10.2 123 73 73 72 0
10.3 133 91 91 91 0
10.4 239 198 198 189 158
10.5 153 119 117 110 98
10.6 178 127 123 122 79
10.7 281 232 232 229 185
10.8 205 148 147 146 126
10.9 148 110 110 108 92
11.0 221 160 159 153 146
11.1 159 103 103 100 96
11.2 164 116 116 112 112
11.3 166 132 132 106 106
11.4 147 104 104 91 91
11.5 49 11 0 0 0
11.6 184 118 118 101 87
11.7 271 207 205 173 173
11.8 186 134 109 98 54
11.9 201 152 123 122 15
12.0 145 120 111 107 95
12.1 199 166 151 151 105
12.2 179 133 119 119 119
12.3 216 190 184 184 184
12.4 138 103 99 99 99
12.5 172 129 114 114 114
12.6 232 179 166 166 166
12.7 207 154 146 146 146
12.8 207 131 131 123 123
12.9 210 154 149 144 144
13.0 148 104 104 86 82
13.1 179 128 128 128 104
13.2 164 116 116 116 104
13.3 170 132 132 131 128
13.4 221 175 175 174 172
13.5 153 104 104 101 98
13.6 199 141 141 135 135
13.7 109 78 78 78 78
13.8 233 190 183 181 181
13.9 213 149 149 145 134
14.0 297 248 243 203 33
14.1 161 138 138 138 128
14.2 202 161 161 161 161
14.3 189 150 150 144 144
14.4 171 122 122 113 113
14.5 175 114 114 114 114
14.6 160 112 112 112 111
14.7 182 138 138 138 133
14.8 172 115 115 115 89
14.9 126 95 95 95 87
15.0 224 205 199 176 152
15.1 197 145 145 145 117
15.2 264 205 198 198 163
15.3 189 147 140 140 92
15.4 151 109 107 107 68
15.5 263 215 215 215 181
15.6 189 149 149 149 116
15.7 134 100 100 99 0
15.8 158 126 126 126 77
15.9 185 141 141 140 88
16.0 166 142 139 137 103
16.1 158 133 133 120 98
16.2 215 179 179 168 145
16.3 228 176 176 159 124
16.4 213 167 167 149 125
16.5 198 154 153 135 111
16.6 128 67 56 39 0
16.7 256 205 202 150 149
16.8 184 131 131 88 88
16.9 205 139 139 112 99
17.0 243 219 219 197 197
17.1 156 122 122 93 92
17.2 134 75 75 58 0
17.3 155 91 91 71 71
17.4 193 140 139 103 100
17.5 233 186 185 161 155
17.6 180 132 130 103 95
17.7 178 137 134 116 108
17.8 125 82 82 63 0
17.9 230 171 170 155 148
18.0 160 137 136 114 112
18.1 157 116 113 87 86
18.2 224 171 169 150 148
18.3 175 112 94 65 0
18.4 208 159 156 121 121
18.5 182 130 121 88 86
18.6 212 160 160 131 127
18.7 185 128 125 96 95
18.8 203 156 151 128 116
18.9 185 144 138 110 99
19.0 125 106 102 73 0
19.1 163 141 141 104 97
19.2 152 132 132 96 85
19.3 128 110 110 86 75
19.4 202 176 176 137 134
19.5 210 192 192 161 160
19.6 99 75 75 54 0
19.7 153 128 128 87 80
19.8 102 75 72 33 0
19.9 135 114 110 98 96
20.0 136 95 78 53 0
20.1 192 151 151 123 98
20.2 195 147 147 147 115
20.3 141 89 89 89 89
20.4 101 49 49 49 0
20.5 140 104 104 104 85
20.6 179 134 134 129 129
20.7 157 118 118 118 118
20.8 199 161 161 161 161
20.9 121 79 79 79 79
21.0 173 108 107 101 98
21.1 91 44 44 44 0
21.2 177 127 127 122 122
21.3 149 107 107 107 98
21.4 155 120 120 120 120
21.5 101 68 68 66 0
21.6 189 136 136 136 91
21.7 201 152 152 151 151
21.8 187 134 134 127 127
21.9 225 182 182 182 169
22.0 113 88 86 84 84
22.1 126 92 92 92 92
22.2 5 0 0 0 0
22.3 178 159 159 159 155
22.4 167 124 124 121 120
22.5 70 35 35 27 0
22.6 164 113 113 113 94
22.7 159 99 99 99 99
22.8 110 92 92 92 92
22.9 102 58 58 58 0
23.0 125 80 78 77 0
23.1 120 67 66 66 0
23.2 159 109 109 109 99
23.3 131 86 86 86 82
23.4 187 141 141 141 120
23.5 131 67 67 67 0
23.6 134 113 96 95 95
23.7 102 81 58 58 0
23.8 121 100 70 70 53
23.9 167 136 122 121 121
24.0 129 110 106 106 99
24.1 172 118 118 118 118
24.2 138 97 97 93 93
24.3 155 117 109 109 99
24.4 154 138 119 119 119
24.5 124 112 91 91 91
24.6 170 124 104 104 96
24.7 221 184 168 168 168
24.8 152 115 110 105 98
24.9 185 135 129 127 127
25.1 109 109 109 108 68
25.2 51 51 51 51 0
25.3 185 185 185 185 160
25.4 118 118 118 116 85
25.5 115 115 115 115 64
25.6 79 79 79 79 56
25.7 129 129 129 129 101
25.8 105 105 105 105 74
25.9 114 114 114 114 98
26.0 122 89 87 82 67
26.1 103 62 62 57 0
26.2 183 148 148 148 124
26.3 139 97 97 97 76
26.4 203 173 173 173 148
26.5 215 178 178 178 149
26.6 153 118 118 115 93
26.7 115 85 85 83 0
26.8 207 177 177 177 152
26.9 176 138 138 138 115
27.0 212 180 179 176 145
27.1 107 86 73 73 0
27.2 232 217 202 200 175
27.3 133 117 103 103 80
27.4 148 134 116 116 91
27.5 170 154 147 147 93
27.6 54 48 45 45 0
27.7 127 121 111 110 82
27.8 163 160 157 153 94
27.9 113 100 99 97 0
28.0 182 145 143 143 86
28.1 124 124 124 123 92
28.2 134 134 134 133 97
28.3 77 77 77 74 0
28.4 65 65 65 65 0
28.5 130 130 130 126 91
28.6 114 114 114 114 15
28.7 87 87 87 86 0
28.8 88 88 88 88 0
28.9 127 127 127 126 94
29.0 138 138 137 136 67
29.1 67 67 67 65 0
29.2 137 137 137 137 0
29.3 104 104 104 102 0
29.4 37 37 37 35 0
29.5 125 125 125 124 0
29.6 119 116 111 103 92
29.7 124 99 99 99 84
29.8 202 193 180 180 132
29.9 95 80 63 53 0
30.0 72 72 72 0 0
30.1 118 118 118 35 0
30.2 124 105 105 38 0
30.3 136 116 116 46 0
30.4 38 0 0 0 0
30.5 168 148 147 64 58
30.6 114 88 88 0 0
30.7 94 70 70 0 0
30.8 164 147 147 74 74
30.9 96 70 69 0 0
31.0 64 56 0 0 0
31.1 52 12 0 0 0
31.2 146 138 123 52 52
31.3 94 87 74 0 0
31.4 88 83 69 0 0
31.5 155 149 131 47 0
31.6 120 113 97 15 0
31.7 91 84 70 0 0
31.8 104 89 75 0 0
31.9 164 153 142 68 63
32.0 66 55 0 0 0
32.1 116 109 97 42 0
32.2 89 79 70 0 0
32.3 84 78 71 0 0
32.4 146 135 117 42 0
32.5 114 106 95 19 0
32.6 70 62 0 0 0
32.7 138 133 118 52 49
32.8 56 49 0 0 0
32.9 51 42 0 0 0
33.0 88 88 87 14 0
33.1 70 70 70 0 0
33.2 40 40 0 0 0
33.3 111 111 111 52 47
33.4 75 75 75 0 0
33.5 32 32 23 0 0
33.6 20 14 0 0 0
33.7 52 52 52 0 0
33.8 66 65 65 0 0
33.9 23 23 0 0 0
34.0 36 36 33 0 0
34.1 28 28 27 0 0
34.2 63 63 63 0 0
34.3 60 60 60 0 0
34.4 130 130 130 60 32
34.5 50 50 50 0 0
34.6 91 91 91 27 0
34.7 115 115 115 43 0
34.8 18 18 0 0 0
34.9 98 98 98 24 0
35.0 25 25 0 0 0
35.1 141 141 141 77 0
35.2 48 48 48 0 0
35.3 127 127 127 64 64
35.4 25 25 23 0 0
35.5 97 96 96 23 0
35.6 4 0 0 0 0
35.7 38 38 38 0 0
35.9 70 70 70 0 0
36.0 56 56 54 0 0
36.2 73 73 73 20 0
36.3 40 40 40 0 0
36.4 40 40 40 0 0
36.5 91 91 91 32 0
36.6 46 46 46 0 0
36.7 29 29 20 0 0
36.9 26 26 17 0 0
37.0 89 89 86 7 0
37.2 11 0 0 0 0
37.3 77 77 77 4 0
37.4 75 75 75 0 0
37.6 94 94 94 35 0
37.7 26 26 0 0 0
37.8 52 52 48 0 0
37.9 12 0 0 0 0
38.0 86 86 78 18 0
38.1 14 13 0 0 0
38.2 88 88 86 29 0
38.3 41 41 0 0 0
38.4 37 37 0 0 0
38.5 20 0 0 0 0
38.6 85 85 61 13 0
38.7 124 124 100 42 0
38.8 97 97 75 37 0
38.9 85 84 67 21 0
39.0 65 65 41 0 0
39.1 14 0 0 0 0
39.2 23 0 0 0 0
39.3 104 104 91 33 0
39.4 89 89 69 0 0
39.5 41 40 16 0 0
39.6 139 137 113 73 0
39.7 52 52 36 0 0
39.8 70 70 52 0 0
39.9 71 71 44 0 0
40.0 60 60 58 0 0
40.1 117 117 117 64 0
40.2 47 47 47 0 0
40.3 97 97 97 35 0
40.4 33 30 5 0 0
40.5 78 78 78 11 0
40.6 24 23 0 0 0
40.7 34 34 27 0 0
40.8 67 67 67 26 0
40.9 5 0 0 0 0
41.0 64 64 62 18 0
41.1 94 94 94 16 0
41.2 13 0 0 0 0
41.3 42 42 28 0 0
41.5 36 36 29 0 0
41.6 50 50 50 0 0
41.7 100 100 100 58 0
41.8 52 52 51 0 0
41.9 48 46 34 0 0
42.0 22 12 0 0 0
42.1 18 11 0 0 0
42.2 15 0 0 0 0
42.3 46 34 34 0 0
42.4 23 10 0 0 0
42.5 4 0 0 0 0
42.6 130 125 122 88 0
42.7 36 36 0 0 0
42.8 16 16 0 0 0
42.9 68 68 39 0 0
43.0 134 134 107 83 0
43.1 47 47 42 0 0
43.2 65 65 65 0 0
43.3 98 95 95 57 0
43.4 103 102 100 54 0
43.6 22 0 0 0 0
43.7 26 0 0 0 0
43.8 50 25 0 0 0
43.9 29 0 0 0 0
44.0 18 0 0 0 0
44.1 13 0 0 0 0
44.2 25 0 0 0 0
44.6 99 65 65 36 0
44.7 61 40 38 0 0
44.8 10 0 0 0 0
44.9 35 7 0 0 0
45.0 16 0 0 0 0
45.2 47 33 0 0 0
45.3 91 78 66 0 0
45.4 15 0 0 0 0
45.5 97 71 71 1 0
45.6 25 0 0 0 0
45.7 32 0 0 0 0
45.8 94 67 67 0 0
46.0 43 25 0 0 0
46.1 6 0 0 0 0
46.2 29 0 0 0 0
46.3 98 65 62 37 0
46.5 62 44 34 0 0
46.6 55 35 0 0 0
46.7 45 18 0 0 0
46.8 31 0 0 0 0
47.0 26 0 0 0 0
47.1 61 39 0 0 0
47.2 39 21 0 0 0
47.5 66 50 2 0 0
47.6 20 0 0 0 0
47.7 47 21 0 0 0
47.8 75 58 38 24 0
48.0 29 0 0 0 0
48.1 27 0 0 0 0
48.2 54 36 0 0 0
48.3 36 19 0 0 0
48.4 114 103 103 83 0
48.6 31 11 0 0 0
48.7 30 11 0 0 0
48.9 24 0 0 0 0
49.1 5 0 0 0 0
49.3 50 35 0 0 0
49.4 82 64 50 37 0
49.5 57 39 0 0 0
49.6 122 105 82 81 35
49.8 73 51 39 0 0
49.9 9 0 0 0 0
50.2 54 43 26 0 0
50.3 35 17 0 0 0
50.4 20 2 0 0 0
50.6 6 0 0 0 0
50.8 13 13 0 0 0
50.9 18 16 0 0 0
51.3 1 0 0 0 0
51.7 5 0 0 0 0
52.2 4 0 0 0 0
52.3 58 47 32 0 0
52.4 6 0 0 0 0
52.9 46 36 22 0 0
53.2 35 35 22 0 0
53.3 3 0 0 0 0
53.5 30 30 0 0 0
53.9 54 53 27 0 0
54.0 19 0 0 0 0
54.2 20 0 0 0 0
54.6 10 0 0 0 0
55.0 10 0 0 0 0
55.4 12 0 0 0 0
55.6 17 2 0 0 0
55.9 12 0 0 0 0
56.0 3 0 0 0 0
56.1 11 4 0 0 0
56.3 33 14 0 0 0
56.5 33 22 0 0 0
56.6 44 37 20 0 0
56.7 28 19 0 0 0
56.8 62 52 39 39 0
57.4 10 0 0 0 0
57.6 31 25 0 0 0
57.7 9 0 0 0 0
57.8 5 0 0 0 0
58.1 33 29 0 0 0
58.7 68 55 37 37 0
58.8 20 0 0 0 0
59.4 66 47 46 46 0
59.6 32 7 0 0 0
59.9 5 0 0 0 0
Ranges 497 441 390 320 204
Factors 55228 44460 40674 31231 21598[/CODE]

petrw1 2022-04-17 19:55

[QUOTE=lycorn;604068]I still look forward to the goal stated in the title of this thread: getting to less than 20M unfactored. I acknowledge it will be a really tough one, but... who knows what this community will be able to achieve? :smile:[/QUOTE]

Yes that was the ultimate goal ... but I understood from the beginning that the ranges above 100M or so will finish on it's own over time.

Viliam Furik 2022-04-17 20:21

[QUOTE=petrw1;604056]What was initially anticipated to take me 685 years (i.e. NEVER) was completed in 1,727 days; about 4.75 years.[/QUOTE]

Somewhere in the early days of this project - I think it was somewhere around the post #500 - you expressed your wish for this project to finish in under 2000 days. Your wish came true!

ATH 2022-04-17 20:50

Congratulations!!! :grin:

As you said the "title project" will finish on its own over time, current status: 20,422,960 unfactored exponents

Based on the speed of the last 365 days with 201558 factors found, ETA to 20M unfactored is 766 days: ~ May 2024.

lycorn 2022-04-18 10:59

[QUOTE=petrw1;604157]Yes that was the ultimate goal ... but I understood from the beginning that the ranges above 100M or so will finish on it's own over time.[/QUOTE]

True. But "finishing on it`s own" means they will be factored as part of the effort to find new MPs, and that will take a LOT of years to progress up the ranges until 1G. Without some dedicated factoring effort, most (may be all?) of us will never see the end of it.
We will keep the TF rate mentioned in ATH´s last post iif we invest resources in TFing exponents for the heck of it, that meaning many years before the front wave of 1st time PRP is even getting anywhere close. A good example is SRBASE´s work. And in any case it will not be easy to keep up as the TF levels go higher, unless there is really a lot of effort involved. Also, P-1 will progressively loose its luster as the size of the exponents grows, while ECM is out of consideration for exponents above 20M or so, at least with the current sw/hw resources.

So, my point is: high ranges will finish on their own... provided we give it a push :smile:.
I´m at it already.

axn 2022-04-18 17:01

[QUOTE=lycorn;604195]A good example is SRBASE´s work. [/QUOTE]
Is there any reason to think that SRBase's work won't be sufficient?

petrw1 2022-04-18 17:11

[QUOTE=axn;604216]Is there any reason to think that SRBase's work won't be sufficient?[/QUOTE]

Yes and Judger and Ryan Propper doing P1 and several other big guns I think we're in good hands.
That said, every bit of help will shrink the time line.

With less exponents in the later ranges and with cheaper TF up there we won't need much P1 to finish these ranges.

lycorn 2022-04-18 18:34

[QUOTE=axn;604216]Is there any reason to think that SRBase's work won't be sufficient?[/QUOTE]

Quite frankly, I can´t say it won´t be. But the amount of "Factored" results they are returning is diminishing over time, in line with the increased effort needed to complete the bit levels. I don´t know how the number of participants is varying, either, and how persistent will they be as the work gets tougher and tougher, so it´s not clear what is to be expected from their side for the future. So far, they have been a /great/ help, that´s for sure.

chalsall 2022-04-18 19:37

[QUOTE=petrw1;604217]That said, every bit of help will shrink the time line.[/QUOTE]

If desired... It would be trivial for me to bring into GPU72 a few ranges (fully reserved this time) for automatic coordination (Colab TF, etc). Just let me know what range(s) I should bring in.

This would actually help GIMPS (in the *very* long term); the Low Composite Cleanup sub-project is definitely only GIMFS...


All times are UTC. The time now is 09:53.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.11
Copyright ©2000 - 2022, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.